• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The redeeming elements of bad and clumsy episodes

Bad Thoughts

Vice Admiral
Admiral
Does any DS9 episode lack at least one redeeming quality?

There have been plenty of threads about the best and worst episodes. Many of them tend to be Ferengi episode; the comic storylines don't please everyone. However, I felt that even in the worst Ferengi episodes, Armin Shimerman could always be counter on to give a strong and dedicated performance. There was always one actor trying to make the Ferengi material work,using his stage experiences to make a bad story better.

As a consequence, I started to look at a lot of the least lovable episodes--the ones that are controversial, awkward, or just plain bad--but see if there is still something good in each one. Is there at least one thing that is good or interesting in each episode?

Doctor Bashir, I Presume: Brian George and Siddig play off each other well in order to make the antagonism real, and the the conversations about what parents expect of their kids gets close to the emotions of Nog's story in Heart of Stone.

Let He Who Is Without Sin: Worf's story about killing a kid while playing sports is one of the few intimate moments Dorn got, and the lack of synchronicity between Worf and Dax is an interesting conversation about early relationships--until they reach Risa, at least.

Prophet Motive: Quark's bewilderment is hysterical, and I love the scene where he and Rom try to guess if their is something secret in the new Rules of Acquisition.
 
It took me years before I could stomach Turnabout Intruder from TOS, but now I appreciate it for pointing out the blatant sexism in the series and for the subversive subtext.
Harder to do with Let That Be Your Last Battlefield. :rolleyes:
 
With DS9 it's so often is the cast saving the lousy episodes, I've always thought this ensemble is just leaps and bounds ahead of every other Trek TV cast.

"Profit & Lace": I laugh at the way they all chime in on singing the Slug-O-Cola theme ("the slimiest cola in the galaxy!") I hate myself for it, but I laugh.

"Ferengi Love Songs": I love the scene where Ishka is asking Quark, why isn't he happy, now that he's proven himself a "true Ferengi" after "betraying friends and family for personal gain"? And Quark is horrified to realize it's because...

QUARK: I think I've been hanging around humans too long. I think I'm developing a...
ISHKA: Conscience?
QUARK: It's been coming for a long time. I've fought against it, I really have. But living with those people, day in and day out, being exposed to their ethics, their morality! It's like I've been brainwashed.

Armin Shimmerman just plays it so real -- you truly feel the struggle!

"Life Support": This episode is a complete dog -- save for that fabulous confrontation between Bashir and Winn in the conference room over Bareil's treatment. Makes you wish they had gotten to play more moments between those two.

"You Are Cordially Invited": Nog dancing.

"Who Mourns For Morn?": I find the teaser and the first act of this are delightful, with the crews reactions to Morn's death and everyone's reminisces about him at the memorial service. And the later bits where people in the bar are keeping Morn's chair warm. And then the rest of the story... ugh. (It's having nearly everything the guest characters reveal about Morn ultimately turn out to be lies that kill it. If they had structured the same kind of caper, but had been doing truthful reveals about Morn and his ex-wife and royal heritage etc and building out an actual crazy backstory for him, that would have made all the difference)

"Time's Orphan": It was just nice to see Keiko again! She had been absent from the series for so long at this point.

"Equilibrium": Jadzia's visions of the masked figures are satisfyingly creepy

"Let He Who Is Without Sin": Alexander Siddig in a tank top.
 
Last edited:
Profit & Lace": I laugh at the way they all chime in on singing the Slug-O-Cola theme ("the slimiest cola in the galaxy!") I hate myself for it, but I laugh.

Although the his part could have used more depth, I thought Henry Gibson was quite funny. He would have made a great Gov. William Lepetomane
 
"MOVE ALONG HOME" - I still enjoy that episode, despite how much everyone hates it. I've always felt it was an imaginative and great premise.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top