The Most Disliked Episode of PICARD, Finals Round - 2025 Edition...

[Santa of Five]

Broken Pieces moved the arc on somewhat, and also happened in S1 so automatically wins for me.

Broken Pieces" - 2
"Hide and Seek" - 2
"Mercy" - 0

 

[Detached Nacelle]

I'd love to be a productive memeber of society but I've stuck to my guns thus far and shall continue on.

It does pain me an undeserving episode will win. For the unforgivable crime of being in season 3 it really should be one of those episodes left on here but democracy (albeit our very tiny one) spoke.

"Broken Pieces" - 2
"Hide and Seek" - 2
"Mercy" - 1

 

[Frostscape One]

48 hours have passed. "Hide and Seek", being the first one to hit a whopping 2 votes, is saved.

New round.

This is a good/bad news situation for me.

Bad news: a season 2 episode was just saved. Good news: it makes my decision for a final vote SUPREMELY easy. (Having to pick between two season 2 episodes... both are bad, I would literally be tossing a coin.)

So my final vote for PICARD is "Broken Pieces". Because it isn't season 2.


"Broken Pieces" - 1
"Mercy" - 0

 

[Detached Nacelle]

I have chosen my hill to die on.

"Broken Pieces" - 1
"Mercy" - 1

 

[Sakonna]

Either would make a worthy winner for me.

I wish it were any of the other season 2 episodes still here! I prefer all 9 of those to "Broken Pieces."

But I just hate "Mercy." Doesn't work for me at all. And I kind-of-sort-of like the many-Rios thing in "Broken Pieces." So I'll give that my final point.

"Broken Pieces" - 2
"Mercy" - 1

 

[Santa of Five]

Broken Pieces again.

Broken Pieces" - 3
"Mercy" - 1