The Least Disliked Episode 2025 - DISCO Final Rounds

[Seven of Five]

The Pike plot was great, like in a lot of S2 episodes.

The Contol bits of Through The Valley Of Shadows bog it down too much.

Through the Valley of Shadows - 3
If Memory Serves - 0
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0
Under the Twin Moons - 0

 

[Quinton]

Another Quinton post, another vote for (or rather, against?) IMS!

Through the Valley of Shadows - 3
If Memory Serves - 1
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0
Under the Twin Moons - 0

 

[Sakonna]

I will finish off "In The Valley Of Shadows," for the sin of being part of season 2. (Also, for introducing soooo many plot holes to the Pike story)

If Memory Serves - 0
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0
Under the Twin Moons - 0

 

[Farscape One]

Voting for "If Memory Serves".

Like season 1, neither of the season 2 entries in the Finals are worthy of being here, much less winning.


Memory Serves - 1
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0
Under the Twin Moons - 0

 

[Seven of Five]

Under The Twin Moons is more of the continuation of the lukewarm start to S5.

Memory Serves - 1
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0
Under the Twin Moons - 1

 

[Quinton]

“If Memory Serves” again!

If Memory Serves - 2
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0
Under the Twin Moons - 1

 

[BlueStuff]

Under the Twin Moons doesn’t strike me as a real standout episode.

If Memory Serves - 2
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0
Under the Twin Moons - 2

 

[Detached Nacelle]

Adding my voice to Under the Twin Moons. It's perfectly fine but in comparison, fine doesnt cut it.

If Memory Serves - 2
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0
Under the Twin Moons - 3

 

[Sakonna]

I'm really the executioner this game. I will off "Under The Twin Moons", season 5 had better episodes.

I'll give my next round point to "If Memory Serves." It is fantastic, but infected by some season 2 problems around the margins.

If Memory Serves - 1
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Farscape One]

Voting "If Memory Serves" again. Same reasons as before.


If Memory Serves - 2
That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Seven of Five]

I quite like the remaining episodes now.

The Hope Is You Part 1 is probably the weakest episode left now.

If Memory Serves - 2
That Hope is You, Part I - 1
People of Earth - 0
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Detached Nacelle]

Wow now this a hard choice. I'm going for People of Earth, I think it might be marginally a fraction of a point weaker.

If Memory Serves - 2
That Hope is You, Part I - 1
People of Earth - 1
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Quinton]

Believe it or not, I’m going to vote for “If Memory Serves”!

If Memory Serves - 3
That Hope is You, Part I - 1
People of Earth - 1
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Detached Nacelle]

Believe it or not, I’m going to vote for “If Memory Serves”!

 

[Tiran O'Saurus]

"That Hope Is You" has the same sin of the premier in not showing the Discovery or its crew on a show called Discovery.

If Memory Serves - 3
That Hope is You, Part I - 2
People of Earth - 1
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Poldon]

Finishing off "If Memory Serves", mostly for reasons already given. 'Time crystals'?

And I'll start the next round of with a vote against "People of Earth". I don't feel it's as good as the rest of these

That Hope is You, Part I - 0
People of Earth - 1
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Seven of Five]

I'll go with That Hope Is You 1 again, same reasons.

That Hope is You, Part I - 1
People of Earth - 1
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Tiran O'Saurus]

"That Hope Is You Part 1", same reasons.

That Hope is You, Part I - 2
People of Earth - 1
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Quinton]

Hmm. I’ll go with “People of Earth” this time, although its predecessor isn’t terribly far behind. It’s a good episode, but it doesn’t really engage me like a solid third of that season does.

That Hope is You, Part I - 2
People of Earth - 2
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0

 

[Detached Nacelle]

People of Earth is a teensy bit weaker than its compatriots

That Hope is You, Part I - 2
People of Earth - 3
Species Ten-C - 0
Coming Home - 0