• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers The fate of the Federation

Well, we can rest secure in the knowledge that TPTB will tie this to the Greater Whole eventually, as is their wont. They just can't leave a sleeping dog lie.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Shouldn't the universal translator adapt to language drift anyway?

The UT we've seen has been "taught" as it goes (ENT) and I'd assume as new languages are discovered (later series'), they would be added in as well. But if a UT was on it's own for 1000 years, would it automatically "get" that drift? Even if it could, it might take a while.
 
Maybe the reason for V'Draysh not being translated by the Universal Translator is that although Federation was the origin of that word, it may have a different or additional meaning
 
Maybe the reason for V'Draysh not being translated by the Universal Translator is that although Federation was the origin of that word, it may have a different or additional meaning
As V’Draysh seems to be a proper noun the UT wouldn’t necessarily translate it. Hoshi had the same issue with “Rigel” in “Broken Bow”
 
I do, however, have that John Denver song in my head now...

:scream:
I'd like to think, now, the final captain of Discovery was Steve Zissou, and he just forgot where he parked Discovery while searching for the rare or non-existant jaguar gormagander, taking the entire crew on two shuttles to go find it.
 
As V’Draysh seems to be a proper noun the UT wouldn’t necessarily translate it. Hoshi had the same issue with “Rigel” in “Broken Bow”

Perhaps V'Draysh is a name for the multi species hybrids, we know about from Daniels and the Temporal Cold War arc in Enterprise. If they exist in this timeline.
 
Well, we can rest secure in the knowledge that TPTB will tie this to the Greater Whole eventually, as is their wont. They just can't leave a sleeping dog lie.

Timo Saloniemi
Yeeeeeeah ... lets just give this one a pass.

I do hope they get this season right. Hit the ground running.
 
Perhaps V'Draysh is a name for the multi species hybrids, we know about from Daniels and the Temporal Cold War arc in Enterprise. If they exist in this timeline.
Ooh that’d be cool. Didn’t Phlox say Daniels was “more or less” human?

And DSC did like its Enterprise references in s1 so maybe they’ll have more in s2...
 
Yeah, that's why it was also very weird that Craft didn't know what "Tuesday" meant. Like, we have names for our "days" since many thousand years! It should be reasonable that humans have that 1000 years in the future as well.

Perhaps Alcor IV has such a different orbit around its sun (vs. Earth) that Alcorians had to invent a whole new way of day- and time-keeping.
 
They seem to be still around,Craft recognized the Discovery s something like His enemies and her age. So they are the federation as the author says or something descended from the Federation
 
Not to throw a wrinkle into this, but do we even know that "Calypso" takes place 1,000 years after 2258? It could be 1,000 years after some other point. If Discovery ended up some time in the past or future, it could be that time -- whenever it was -- plus the 1,000 years.

It could be the 33rd Century, and probably is. But there's no way to know for sure.
 

Do they actually give a specific time in the episode, or does that only come from the trailer?

I honestly don't really remember anymore. But I kinda' thought the "1000 years" was more a rough estimate (as vague as the rest of the future worldbuilding), than a specific date.
 
V'Draysh obviously comes from Federation but for all we know it refers to a Ferengi/Bajoran alliance or some random species, a lot can happen in a 1000 years.

Just like in the 18th century the "Holy Roman Empire" was basically germany and didn't even include rome or significant italian territories anymore the name "federation" might have shifted to a different power while the majority of what we know as the UFP continues to exist as the "Quandican Union" (don't ask me what quandican means, I just pressed buttons until it looked like a name).
 
Not to throw a wrinkle into this, but do we even know that "Calypso" takes place 1,000 years after 2258? It could be 1,000 years after some other point. If Discovery ended up some time in the past or future, it could be that time -- whenever it was -- plus the 1,000 years.

It could be the 33rd Century, and probably is. But there's no way to know for sure.
I never thought of that - if they were sent back in time, and the 1000 year wait is to sync up with the present they left?
 
"Wouldn't it be cool to have a lone dude on a starship fall in love with a computer?"
"hellz yeah! But make it the far future or something, so that we don't have to care about continuity!"
"yeah"

*cue a bunch of fans wildly obsessing about continuity
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top