• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Borg

I always viewed the Borg less as a story about technological advancement or how the Federation is a “primitive species” compared to them, but as a cautionary tale about a society shedding their individuality and becoming too connected to technology. Sure, the Borg might be somewhat stronger than the Federation in terms of firepower, but the price is a complete loss of their self determination and humanity.
 
That's a good way to look at it, but it's not how it was handled. They've gone from an unstoppable villain that maybe some day peace could be made with, to a collection of individuals held captive that should not be destroyed, to freely just murdering as many as possible to get away, and back to mixtures of all of the above. If anything, they came closer to warning about being part of an unthinking collective.
 
My first introduction to the Borg (and Trek in general, actually) was watching First Contact just before bed as a child, and while it was terrifying for me I loved it and mostly always enjoyed the Borg episodes of TNG/Voy when they happened.

I do think their writing was a bit all over the place, of course. But because of that they're interesting for different reasons at different times. In TNG they were the unknown, inescapable threat they weren't ready for, which transitioned into a more known enemy with clear flaws they could exploit later in the series.

In First Contact they were more like an old enemy, and their lore had been expanded upon with the introduction of the Borg Queen. Personally, I love it, but it does completely change the nature of why the Borg should be scary. Before they were a mindless, endless, adaptive swarm; now it has a face and can be negotiated with. With that comes a different set of weaknesses and capabilities, which shakes things up, and I can see why some people wouldn't like that. Personally I think it makes sense, and the writers can still have plenty of situations which don't involve the Borg queen's influence.

Then we get Voyager, where the Borg are once again old enemies but also a familiar tether to the known Trek universe. Their lore is expanded on yet again and in my opinion, parts of it start to make more sense because of this; their primary hub is in a really disorganized part of the galaxy. The Delta quadrant doesn't have many organized federations with the scale of those we see in the Alpha quadrant. And instead of the unstoppable, unknown force we see them as in their TNG introduction, we see their more insect like nature up close in their natural habitat.

They are just scavengers taking what they want from a disorganized mess of smaller races and civilizations in the delta quadrant, being the largest and most organized force there by far. We see that there are other, stranger forces holding the Borg semi-captive in this region of space, acting as a suppressive force. The parallels to Ant behavior were always there with the Borg, but here they actually make sense and I think a lot of the different ways the Borg have been shown to us start to support each other.
 
I always viewed the Borg less as a story about technological advancement or how the Federation is a “primitive species” compared to them, but as a cautionary tale about a society shedding their individuality and becoming too connected to technology. Sure, the Borg might be somewhat stronger than the Federation in terms of firepower, but the price is a complete loss of their self determination and humanity.
Yes I agree with your view as well. I think both positions are true.

But remember that Picard, even though he had the chance to do it, did not destroy the Borg and let them live. Is it worh it, for a civilization that has no culture, no practices, no identity and centers all of its existence around assimilating others, expanding their species?

Perhaps not. By human judgement, most certainly not. But Picard can see past this. He remembers they are way more advanced than the Federation and he recognizes that maybe our judgement is not the supreme judgement. That perhaps this species commands a purpose we have not realized yet.

I know many Trek fans say this was a mistake by Picard. I can see where you are coming from. But I will argue that Picard was the most intelligent, in all ways, of all the Trek captains I've seen. He looked at this issue from an universal perspective. He forgot he was human, to let go of the judgement. And all he could see is an enormously populated species being exterminated by the other, for the sake of their ideals and purposes.
 
I'm watching this video and wondering well why not? This seems as valid an idea as anything else that people have suggested but the Borg may not have wanted humanity itself but were really after the Q

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
The Chodak are seen in the PC game A Final Unity, though they were referenced in the Trek RPG materials put out by Last Unicorn Games.

Think Humpty-Dumpty with repulsor chairs and wands that act as combined weapons/multitools.
I have been having a glitch when trying to access Quora. Did read a title, which asked if, post war, the local powers were scrambling to reverse engineer Dominion technology. My immediate thought was, yes, all the local powers would try to do this with any scrap of Dominion tech they could get their hands on. And the local powers would try this with any scrap of Borg tech, or Chodak tech, or each others tech for that matter.

Conceivably this could result in second rate-more likely third rate-imitations.
 
Last edited:
Q would seem to be a more interesting target. Federation technology is quite primitive compared to what the Borg already possess. And it isn't obvious that human biological distinctiveness is all that impressive.
 
Q would seem to be a more interesting target. Federation technology is quite primitive compared to what the Borg already possess. And it isn't obvious that human biological distinctiveness is all that impressive.
That's why I love the video that I posted. I like the idea that they might be using humans and other species to get to the Q
 
Perhaps not. By human judgement, most certainly not. But Picard can see past this. He remembers they are way more advanced than the Federation and he recognizes that maybe our judgement is not the supreme judgement. That perhaps this species commands a purpose we have not realized yet.

*Janeway cackles maniacally*
 
I'm watching this video and wondering well why not? This seems as valid an idea as anything else that people have suggested but the Borg may not have wanted humanity itself but were really after the Q

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

All of these lore ideas come from what I think is a misinterpretation of Q's "don't provoke the Borg" line to Q Jr. A lot of people seem to think this implies fear of the Borg by the Q.

I've always interpreted it to mean the Q don't want to accidentally cause a galaxy-wide mess they'll have to clean up. Provoking the Borg may result in them tearing across the Milky Way assimilating any and all civilisations who have information about the Q, including their favoured Human pets. They want Humans to be left to develop naturally as they see potential in us.

They have internal rules, punish members who overstep, and seem to recognise that excessive meddling can destabilise the galaxy, perhaps in ways that would be difficult for even them to restore.

The Borg can't even assimilate Species 8472, The Changelings or the Denobulans.

What chance would they realistically have against a species that could likely erase their entire species with a single thought?

It'd be like fighting a particular aggressive ant nest, they might ruin your garden and bite your dog but they're not occupying your house, stealing your car or emptying your bank account.
 
^That's how I've always taken it too. The Q don't fear the Borg, but do fear the indirect damage that could be caused by provoking them. Witness the events of "Q Who", where depending on how you look at it Q either did Our Heroes a favor or set them up for massive trauma...or both.

Although, if any known galactic civilization could become a threat to the Q (eventually), I'd put my money on the Borg. Mostly because I don't see any other race having the appetite to want to take them on.
 
I'd love to see a Q interact with a Borg Queen in the same way that they first did with Picard. Just to see her getting frustrated would be fun
 
Yeah, Q's "don't provoke the Borg" felt more like, remember they'll ignore you (Voyager) until they see you as a threat, then they come after you en masse vs he's worried about his species' safety.
 
Tried several times-and failed-to link to a clip on YouTube. From the episode Future Tense (ENT).

Showing initial examination of a strange, high tech artifact. A similar situation would be initial examination of a Borg artifact.

Title of the clip-"Star Trek Enterprise - Unknown Space Capsule."
 
Last edited:
Yeah, Q's "don't provoke the Borg" felt more like, remember they'll ignore you (Voyager) until they see you as a threat, then they come after you en masse vs he's worried about his species' safety.

He said that in TNG, then by Voyager time he was able to provide Janeway the means in which to enter where the Q live, so it stands to reason to some degree that that Borg can get there and that if they can get there, who knows what they might be able to do at some point (outside of assimilation).
 
I imagine on ongoing, secret program by Starfleet Intelligence. Reverse engineering by the Foreign Technology Division. Most of this would involve technology from peer and near pear powers in our corner of the galaxy. But some of this would be artifacts representing higher tech levels.

Come to think of it, some of the artifacts might be from old UFO crash sites on Vulcan, Andoria, Tellar Prime, Earth.....

For the dangers involved with reverse engineering, scroll down to Paleotechnology.
 
Last edited:
We've seen examples of Qs being depowered and becoming mere mortal human(oid)s, but still retaining enormous amounts of knowledge, including some far out there science and physics. If the Borg could get their hands on a depowered Q and assimilate them, and said Q retained the knowledge of how the Q became what they were in the first place ... although one would imagine the other Q would consider that a serious enough problem to deal with urgently if it ever seemed likely to happen.

Kinda like when RepliCarter kidnaped Daniel in Stargate and started probing all of his ascended knowledge. Though that backfired to an extent. Maybe a depowered Q being assimilated would still have a strong enough mind to control the collective?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top