• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Supergirl - Season 1

I more or less hate the show too, but I find the Mazouz/Pertwee scenes are usually pretty solid. I keep watching in hopes the writers will eventually figure it out and write everyone else off the show.
 
I haven't really read many comics with characters with speed like that. Has anyone ever used accuracy and momentum with speedsters? Like they can go superfast but they don't have as precise control or they need time to build up to maximum speed or stop? Seems like it would be a way to explain why they can't always use 100% of their abilities at a time.
Kinda. There's been at least a few who've visited various aspects (and difficulties) of being a speedster. The most notable example I can think of off the top of my head is Danny from Next Men; he can run about 200mph or so, but doing so burns straight through his footwear and burns his feet. I also remember some burning off their clothes, and even one who died as soon as he learned he had the power after practically vaporizing himself by running uncontrollably into a wall or something, but I'll be damned if I can remember where that's from.
 
Last edited:
Regarding Spidey's strength, he was actually an early example of a character who had a well-defined strength limit...in the early comics of the '60s, they were saying that he had the proportional strength of spider, which was being able to lift about 40 times his own weight. Now depending on Peter's weight, that would be more in the 3-4 ton range, rather than the 10 that the OHOTMU upped it to--Presumably, Spidey must have gotten a good workout from all those years of fighting villains and whatnot.

As to whether comics writers and artists have realistically kept within those set limits...that's another thing entirely.

Mark Gruenwald and his artistic collaborators explored the effects of super-speed a bit more realistically in Squadron Supreme and D.P.7. (I had to look up the title of the latter, it was one of those "New Universe" books.)
 
I noticed that it kind of started getting really wonky as soon as they introduced the whole ridiculous spider god angle or whatever it was.
 
Uh, so now if you find one scene to be really badly written, you hate the show and are some kind of masochist who only watches shows you hate?

Okay... We have a rational mind at work here for sure.

"You hate the show" is the fallback for anyone struggling with the fact that Supergirl has various problems. I guress we should be like a couple of YouTube reviewers (I'll leave nameless) that explode with "oh, that was great!!!" about everything in the series

People don't usually drone on about one bad scene over 5 thread pages...

Whether you realize it or not, you are contributing to the page count by trying to push back against the opinions you do not like. That happens often in The Walking Dead thread, JJ-Trek threads, etc.

...and welcome to the message board....
 
As to whether comics writers and artists have realistically kept within those set limits...that's another thing entirely.

But that's just the thing... Ever since the iconic "If This Be My Destiny...!" storyline in Amazing Spider-Man 31-33, one of Spidey's defining tropes has been ending up in situations where he faced seemingly impossible odds but was able to push beyond his normal limits of strength and endurance through sheer will power and refusal to give up. The fact that he's forced beyond his limits but keeps striving anyway is the whole point. Heck, I even homaged that sequence in my own Spidey novel, although I had him overwhelmed mentally rather than physically.
 
None of which pertains to his ability to flick a dumpster around with one finger. If anything, making him capable of too great of feats in too casual a manner undermines the more meaningful limit-pushing situations that you allude to.
 
Last edited:
Watching that Smallville scene I just realized, we haven't seen Kara fly in space yet, have we? Seems like something she might have got around to at some point before now.
 
It's a box car in a train yard?

Paladin has k-mart level ironman armour that lets him lift/press 1 ton (my head told me that. I don't know why. But twenty years ago I had all this shit memorized.)


Paladin tilted that boxcar 30 degrees, it's already almost flipped over, and Peter is ten times stronger than Paladin.

Also, that clipart is 25ish years old.
 
It probably is. Those things are very carefully designed not to go off by accident, breach containment, or otherwise endanger the people who live and work around them. There was a 1961 B-52 crash where a partially armed nuclear missile plunged into a muddy field at 700 MPH and didn't go off or leak radioactive materials.

Oh, I definitely hope they have the best safeguards possible, and I fully admit that I don't know what the abilities of those safeguards are - maybe they're much much better than I would expect. At the same time, I seriously doubt any military officer who just casually let a nuclear missile fall to the ground from that height would have much of a future in their career from the point on. Taking any unneccessary chance
with that kind of destructive force is just dumb.

If it were really a million tons in weight it would have sunk through the ice and to the earth's core.

Yeah, that was actually another irritating moment in this episode. Especially since that ground didn't even look that sturdy to start with.

"You hate the show" is the fallback for anyone struggling with the fact that Supergirl has various problems. I guress we should be like a couple of YouTube reviewers (I'll leave nameless) that explode with "oh, that was great!!!" about everything in the series

For the record, I don't hate the show. But I don't like it much, yet, either. I started watching because I love superheroes and I've learned several times over in the past ten years that these new movies and tv shows, when done right, are a great way to get into more cool superheroes that I never used to follow back when I still had the opportunity to to follow comics. I'm still watching right now because it's not so bad that it's unwatchable (the way Arrow is), so I'm trying to give it a chance to improve.

The Flash was a show that had lots of problems for me, as well, from the start (and it still isn't as great as it could be) but it improved greatly over the first season. Its now a show that I honestly enjoy and has introduced me to a whole new hero/mythology. I'd love for Supergirl to turn out the same way, but it's just not happening yet. If it doesn't happen by the end of this season, I'll probably just let it go.
 
I guress we should be like a couple of YouTube reviewers (I'll leave nameless) that explode with "oh, that was great!!!" about everything in the series

Your approach of "oh, that was shit!!!" about everything in the series isn't much better either.

Almost every episode you go on a nitpicky multi-page tirade on some thing you really don't like about this show, but I've never seen you argue that passionately about anything you do like on this show.

So sue me for getting an impression you don't like this show :nyah:
 
I had a few geek out moments with the Indigo episode! I've been watching the show but it hasn't really been grabbing me, but there were a few moments here. Fortress of Solitude! The Key! Legion Flight Ring! (that particularly set me off, it promises the show is going to go BIG in the future) Indigo! (I actually read those comics with her!) Smallville-Supergirl!

I do think Indigo's costume looked pretty bad, though. Could it have been any close to Movie Mystique?! I did a google image search and I much preferred it when she had green skin, purple hair, and a silver dress.
 
Am I the only one who noticed the personalized license plate "PLASTINO" (no doubt referring to Silver Age artist Al Plastino--guess you need to be a geezer like me to catch such a thing)?
 
Am I the only one who noticed the personalized license plate "PLASTINO" (no doubt referring to Silver Age artist Al Plastino--guess you need to be a geezer like me to catch such a thing)?

I caught it too. Plastino's name has shown up in a number of signs in the show so far. Plastino, of course, co-created Supergirl with Otto Binder, although the show only lists Superman's creators Siegel and Shuster in the opening credits due to the vagaries of creator contracts. So the producers like to find other ways to sneak Binder & Plastino's names into the show. (They also created Brainiac and the Legion of Super Heroes, so it's appropriate that there was a name drop in this episode.)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top