• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Strange New Worlds Episode 7 - Those Old Scientists

Grade The Episode


  • Total voters
    319
So for all the people who insisted to me that Lower Decks got better since I quit watching Lower Decks after episode 5, is this the part where I said "Told you so" ?
Not even close.

Read the room.

How many people do you actually know watch Yellowstone?

You know, last week I started to think that I was being unfairly dismissive of what you post here.

Thanks for the reassurance.
 
Well, that doesn’t really fly with the C to the D. Or the nil to the A, for that matter. Or the Defiant to the Defiant-A. And on and on.

Why not? Presumably for the 1701 and the C wreckage could have been recovered and installed. Even if that was after construction if we assume the A was already finished.

Stranger things happen for tradition.
 
The B almost certainly had a piece of the A installed in her. They had enough time between the end of Star Trek VI and the Enterprise-B's launch later that year to take a component of Kirk's final ship and bolt her into Harriman's new one.
 
LD isn't bleeding viewers but the Iron Rule of the TBBS is: "Absolutely No One Watches the Show(s) I Don't Like"
The arrogance goes both ways. People like the show and told me Lower Decks got better, assuming it would get better for me just because it did for them. Obviously they can't think outside a certain mindset if they assumed that.

Also I find it a little strange that certain posters who took extreme overreactions to my jokes on this forum (always about fictional characters) to personal attacks against me, to the point they had to be put on ignore, seem to find this episode really funny when I click the 'Show Ignored Content' button to follow the thread of conversation. To say I find it ironic and odd is an understatement.
 
I do find it strange that some people who said they hated Dal and can't stand him on Prodigy (which is now canceled so I guess they won) are the very same people saying they love Boimler and Mariner. :shrug:
This feels like a false dichotomy though. I can see why people would not like Dal and like Boimler and Mariner and vice versa, but the appeal for either is not remotely similar.

I haven't noticed Dal hate. Or comparisons really. Prodigy is not my favorite because that style of animation is not my favorite, but as a kid's show with a protagonist who overcomes hardships, learns how to work together with a team, think strategically, be compassionate, and also how to lead, he's a fine character. Also, I'm confident Prodigy will find a new home after the strikes are resolved.
 
Paramount Exec: So a bunch of people quit Lower Decks. They're not even hate-watching it, they just stopped watching it period a long time ago.

SNW Showrunners: Don't worry, we have a plan to force them to watch at least one more episode. We'll turn an episode of Strange New Worlds into Lower Decks! :lol:

Paramount Exec: Brilliant, brilliant! We don't pay you enough. Actually, er, forget I said that, wouldn't want you using my words against me during a strike or anything.

Is this your example of your unique brand of humor?
 
Una is used for Starfleet recruitment despite being an augment, yet Prodigy shows that at the time of said poster augments still aren't allowed in Starfleet. Hypocritical much?
Based on what we saw with the courtroom episode, I'm gonna guess that that part of her record was most likely expunged.
 
I loved that Quaid did Boimler's weird jog walk as he bolted from Una.
B4wuqgB.jpg

:guffaw:
 
Holy Q, that was... something. I'm still not sure what rating I'm going to give it, because I'm still trying to reconcile how both worlds collided here on a stylistic level, but there were numerous great moments, well worth several rewatches to catch and digest. Spock guffaws! Don't look! Star Trek insignia on bottom of Boimler's sneakers! A lofty Pike hair compliment, to be followed by horribly animated Pike hair at the end! So much to take in... I had unusually high (and different) expectations going in, so that might be coloring my perception. It's like one of those vinyl albums of yore that you either dislike or are at best "meh" about at first, until you listen to it a few (dozen) more times and it becomes your favorite. Either way, I salute the effort, and can't wait until 9/7 for the next LD season.
 
I watched a few episodes of that show. Its totally a farce. How can something like even exist after tng? Idiotic. I thought these were going to be different versions of the lower deck characters not coming straight from the cartoon and actuallt acknowledging it. Also boimer pretty much knows the snw world looks more real. So he knows his world looks like a cartoon. Come on man. How does it even fit in any previous trek canon?
As others including myself already pointed out the miles difference in tone and cadence between the two sets of characters make for an organic generational gap, further reinforced by how the "younger" characters are so much more high energy. Also there's the old trek mantra of "infinite diversity in infinite combinations" having wild gaps in tone and culture between planets, ships, sectors of space, time periods, etc shouldn't be that far fetched. Even lower decks played with the notion with Boimlers brief stint on Rikers Titan feeling more like being in a startrek movie(or a season of discovery) than episodic life on the Cerritos.
 
It has been a long time since I have just sat and enjoyed an episode of Trek beginning to end. Well done to all involved.

I gave it a 9/10, felt like the story was missing another element, but nothing that stopped it from being just great fun.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top