It isn't just you. I thought he was too much of a pretty boy when he was young.
which oddly enough would also apply to jeffery hunter's pike.
though i really like greenwood and the others have done with pike in the film.
i could see pike becoming this person after his experience on talos.
during the cage he went from someone tired of the responsibilities of command to someone who has gotten back his mojo.
i think i first remember greenwood when he was in nowhere man.