Apparently when the First Order first started to come about, the NR didn't want to get officially involved with the fight against them, so they let Leia leave and start the Resistance. As you could tell from the movie, even though they technically were separate from the Republic, they still had their support.I enjoyed it and would give it a 7-7.5-8/10 (I'm not sure if I'm under rating it or not, which is why I'm a bit loose with the rating). Good return to the universe, maybe an overly safe film. I enjoy most of the new characters and the return of familiar ones (though Fisher was a bit stiff). One thing I was sure I'd hate was the ball droid, ended up being one of the most expressive characters in the film. Good action and fight scenes, well shot, so there are quite a number of positives.
I did feel like I missed out on a bit between the two films, but maybe that's just a hangover from formerly being into the EU.
I wouldn't be much of a fan if I didn't have a bunch of (mostly unnecessary) nitpicks.
*I didn't get why the Resistance was a thing. The Republic apparently rules the galaxy so why isn't it out there dealing with the First Order? Oh, and what's up with the random planet they were on, why not Coruscant?
Here's the SW.com Database entry on Hosnian Prime:
Hosnian Prime
The capital of the New Republic, Hosnian Prime is a cosmopolitan world on the outskirts of the galaxy’s Core Worlds region. One of Mon Mothma’s reforms in establishing the New Republic was that member worlds would host the Senate on a rotating basis, a sharp break from the millennia in which Coruscant was the center of galactic power. But Hosnian Prime’s tenure as Senate seat makes it the target of a terrifying attack by the First Order.
I've actually been wondering about that myself. The first time we saw the Emperor he was a giant hologram so it's not impossible. At the same time I don't really think him being a giant would be totally out of place in the SW universe.*Kylo Ren and the Knights of Ren...what the hell is a "Ren"? I'm assuming him and Snook aren't Sith because no one is a Darth. Plus are there still a bunch of them or is Kylo the only one?*Snook is definitely not a giant right? It's just the holoprojection?I'm pretty sure the armored guys we saw with Ben vision were the other Knights of Ren.
* Perhaps this was a big enough mission they brought everybody, or maybe he just worked maintenance when he's not off on missions.*Why did the First Order take a janitor to a village murdering mission? And why did that old guy have part of a map to Luke Skywalker? Why is there even a map in the first place?
* Lor San Tekka's Database entry:
Lor San Tekka
A legendary traveler and explorer, Lor San Tekka is a longtime ally of the New Republic and the Resistance. After the Battle of Endor, San Tekka helped Luke Skywalker recover secret Jedi lore that the Empire had tried to erase, and Leia Organa hopes the old scout can now help find her brother. Following decades of adventure, San Tekka retired to live simply on Jakku, where he follows the dictates of the once-forbidden Church of the Force. But his retirement is fated to be anything but peaceful.
So I'm assuming he must have worked with Luke sometime after he left the New Republic/Resistance, and Luke trusted him enough to give him that piece of the map.
I'm assuming the reasons for the map and why he trusted San Tekka enough to give him a piece of it will be dealt with in VIII.
They were a way to get Han off of his new ship and back onto the Falcon. I know we did have the gangs, but this is Han Solo, so they probably felt they needed a bigger threat than then get Han to leave.*I guess it wouldn't be a Star Wars movie without a random monster, but the random monster scenes were...I don't know...if they didn't exist would it matter?
I was actually wondering the same thing.*Can the galaxy gun...I mean Starkiller base move? It's impressive and all that, but if it can't once that sun is gone it would be useless.
Because it's easier and less costly for you if you shoot a big gun at something than to send hundreds of ships and troops.*On that note, why waste it on the Rebel base? Just send that Star Destroyer, the Resistance only seemed to have a dozen X-Wings. Though I guess the X-Wings did seem super powerful, but not planet killer needed powerful.
Capt. Phasma was technically wearing chrome, not silver, and she'ss the leader of the stormtroopers.*Why is there a Silver Stormtrooper and what does it do?
I loved the ending. I thought it was a cool, epic close to the movie.*Is a sign of the dark side a lack of OH&S? Are safety railings particularly light side?
Some of those I expect to be fleshed out in later movies, so I'm not overly concerned about them, it's more of an impatience wanting to know everything immediately thing. Nitpicks aside, I am looking forward to the next movie.
Oh, one final thing, I thought the ending was a bit over done. They should have just gone straight to the credits after Luke turned around and lowered his hood. The multiple cuts from his face to Rey's, to the lightsabre, back to faces and then the spinning aerial shot, all with no one saying anything was too drawn out and felt a bit awkward.
I retrospect I'm more and more bothered by the whole Starkiller Base, and not for its mere impacticality/implausibility, but for what it does narratively.
Like the Death Star 1 the thing blows up an inhabited world with presumably millions or billions of people on it. Okay, fine, copying the original. Got it.
But then they are targeting the Resistance, and who knows how many people are on that base, and in the middle of planting the charges, Han stops to talk to his kid. I'm sorry, but countless lives are hanging on the destruction of this thing and this... THIS is the moment when you stop to face the kid? In the original film there's no such personal moment clumsily inserted into the climactic action. Here it forces Han to act selfishly, to risk the lives not only of himself but of his companions AND Leia and all those people, and—potentially—the entire galaxy, if they fail. It even puts Chewie in a position where he can't do the right thing and push the detonator because it'll kill his buddy.
...annnnnd could not be set off because Han was having a moment.
..... annnnnnnd (aside from having demonstrated that the premise itself has an erroneous foundation) it's worth pointing out that the moment included trying to save his son from the Dark Side, and therefore save countless others who might fall victim to his son (as Jake succinctly states above).
Honestly, categorizing Han's actions as "selfish" misses the entire point of the scene.![]()
I agree on this point. Hans actions weren't selfish at all. They were stupid though. Yeah its his kid but come on he just mentioned minutes before to Finn that they had to save the galaxy. The Death Star III had already obliterated a few worlds. He didn't have time to talk to his evil kid. All Han did was make Kylo stronger and even though Star Killer base was destroyed the dark side is now stronger. All Han did was make things more difficult.
I thought it made perfect sense. The whole reason Han went on the mission was to go after Ben, so of course he's going to confront him as soon as the opportunity arises. They had already planted to charges, so that part of the mission was complete. They obviously still had time since they were able to set off the charges before the gun fired.It was selfish, because it risked many many lives without any clearly defined possible reward. For all Han knew blowing the charges when Kylo was on the bridge would have dropped him into the pit and that would be that. AHHHhhhh......... .. . . splat
I laughed.
![]()
![]()
....except, Neil, the shot of BB-8 there was accomplished with a giant Sphero prop with a CGI BB-8 head added to it in post. It really was rolling across the sand under its own power. (Other times granted it was a rod puppet being pushed around like a wheelbarrow, but the point remains.)
I had the same thought when I heard that complaint.