Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
X-wing Alliance had a couple Thrawn trilogy call-outs.
X-wing Alliance had a couple Thrawn trilogy call-outs.
Star Wars: Episode VII: The Nerd Rage Awakens
- Thread starter cooleddie74
- Start date
Doctorwhovian
Fleet Captain
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
TIE fighter also had Thrawn himself in a major role.
TIE fighter also had Thrawn himself in a major role.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
Of course, if Thrawn actually appears on-screen with a slightly different backstory in the new movie or in a later episode of the Sequel Trilogy then it'll still be fine to use his character in future games. I hope he does, and that they can use him again.
Of course, if Thrawn actually appears on-screen with a slightly different backstory in the new movie or in a later episode of the Sequel Trilogy then it'll still be fine to use his character in future games. I hope he does, and that they can use him again.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
I think you need to realize that they are not going to reference the out of continuity novel.
I think you need to realize that they are not going to reference the out of continuity novel.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
The novel might have been rendered null and worthless in the official continuity now that The Mouse runs things, but there's of course nothing in the wiping of the EU slate that handcuffs and prevents the current and future filmmakers from taking some past EU elements and characters that they really like, rewriting and refashioning them and then inserting them into the new movies if they feel they can be of use to the story.
Sure, Heir to the Empire's dead for all practical purposes whether we liked and cared about the Thrawn novels or not. That story and its timeline are gone. That doesn't mean the character of Thrawn himself couldn't theoretically surface with a new backstory and sequence of events if the writers think it'd be a good idea.
I don't think it'll actually happen, but I'm not going to say never when it comes to this universe.
The novel might have been rendered null and worthless in the official continuity now that The Mouse runs things, but there's of course nothing in the wiping of the EU slate that handcuffs and prevents the current and future filmmakers from taking some past EU elements and characters that they really like, rewriting and refashioning them and then inserting them into the new movies if they feel they can be of use to the story.
Sure, Heir to the Empire's dead for all practical purposes whether we liked and cared about the Thrawn novels or not. That story and its timeline are gone. That doesn't mean the character of Thrawn himself couldn't theoretically surface with a new backstory and sequence of events if the writers think it'd be a good idea.
I don't think it'll actually happen, but I'm not going to say never when it comes to this universe.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
We just need to look at the way that Clone Wars treated the EU. They referenced it when possible and contradicted it when they felt like it. They used it as a source of ideas but they were not beholden to it. I imagine that's how things will be going forward; they'll mine it for ideas to reuse.
We just need to look at the way that Clone Wars treated the EU. They referenced it when possible and contradicted it when they felt like it. They used it as a source of ideas but they were not beholden to it. I imagine that's how things will be going forward; they'll mine it for ideas to reuse.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
Yes. Good points there.
Yes. Good points there.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
They referenced it because David Filoni was a fan of the Expanded Universe material. Note that the elements they usually referenced were to elements that he liked.
They referenced it because David Filoni was a fan of the Expanded Universe material. Note that the elements they usually referenced were to elements that he liked.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
If he has a new backstory, he's not Mitth'raw'nuruodo.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
And that's fine with me. Rewrite an EU character's entire backstory for all I care, but I wouldn't mind seeing a few of them picked out of the EU wastebasket and used in a future movie or television project so we get to see at least a small handful of these interesting characters on the big or small screen.
And that's fine with me. Rewrite an EU character's entire backstory for all I care, but I wouldn't mind seeing a few of them picked out of the EU wastebasket and used in a future movie or television project so we get to see at least a small handful of these interesting characters on the big or small screen.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
I want to see TIE Defenders (I know, it won't happen).
I want to see TIE Defenders (I know, it won't happen).
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
I don't understand. You're saying that you want to see them pick up some of the EU characters, but are okay with changing them entirely? What's the point of using them in that case?
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
Agreed if it's the character in name only then it's pretty much not the same character.
Agreed if it's the character in name only then it's pretty much not the same character.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
There's nothing to not understand about the concept, really. The Clone Wars did it. Take a piece of EU mythology and use it (changing some of the details to fit their own scripts and meet their own story requirements). It didn't necessarily resemble the original EU element except in name and the basic concept, but it allowed something from a book or graphic novel written years earlier to make an on-screen appearance (in the very last episodes of the series they even changed the name of the ancient Sith homeworld without any indication they were going to do so). And that was when the old EU was still fully canon, so it'd be even easier now that this has all been tossed up into the air or completely jettisoned.
I like Thrawn as a character and liked what he was in the old Timothy Zahn novels, but he's not a movie character who's been set in stone. I wouldn't mind seeing him in a movie and don't really care if they change details about him. He's not Darth Vader. So long as he'd be recognizable as Grand Admiral Thrawn from the old novels it's not that important. Besides, if the EU is no longer official would it matter that he wouldn't be the precise same Thrawn from the Zahn books? That character and that sequence of events connected to him no longer exist in the Lucas universe.
Anyways, it probably won't happen to begin with but I'm not rigidly beholden to portraying former EU characters the exact same way they were written in the old books before the Disney takeover. And I imagine I'm not the only fan who thinks along these lines.
It's just my own take and opinion on the matter. Your own mileage, of course, may greatly vary. To each their own.
There's nothing to not understand about the concept, really. The Clone Wars did it. Take a piece of EU mythology and use it (changing some of the details to fit their own scripts and meet their own story requirements). It didn't necessarily resemble the original EU element except in name and the basic concept, but it allowed something from a book or graphic novel written years earlier to make an on-screen appearance (in the very last episodes of the series they even changed the name of the ancient Sith homeworld without any indication they were going to do so). And that was when the old EU was still fully canon, so it'd be even easier now that this has all been tossed up into the air or completely jettisoned.
I like Thrawn as a character and liked what he was in the old Timothy Zahn novels, but he's not a movie character who's been set in stone. I wouldn't mind seeing him in a movie and don't really care if they change details about him. He's not Darth Vader. So long as he'd be recognizable as Grand Admiral Thrawn from the old novels it's not that important. Besides, if the EU is no longer official would it matter that he wouldn't be the precise same Thrawn from the Zahn books? That character and that sequence of events connected to him no longer exist in the Lucas universe.
Anyways, it probably won't happen to begin with but I'm not rigidly beholden to portraying former EU characters the exact same way they were written in the old books before the Disney takeover. And I imagine I'm not the only fan who thinks along these lines.
It's just my own take and opinion on the matter. Your own mileage, of course, may greatly vary. To each their own.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
Good because I could never remember how to pronounce that.
Good because I could never remember how to pronounce that.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
Good lord, the EU is just in love with apostrophes.
Good lord, the EU is just in love with apostrophes.
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
That name might as well be Andorian seeing how hard it is to spell and correctly pronounce!
That name might as well be Andorian seeing how hard it is to spell and correctly pronounce!
Re: New Casting and Story Rumors re: EPISODE VII
Timothy Zahn is in love with apostrophes.
Good lord, the EU is just in love with apostrophes.
Timothy Zahn is in love with apostrophes.
