• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 2x09 - "Subspace Rhapsody"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    323
Throughout this series, I've felt bad for Chapel, knowing that she's doomed to spend years pining for Spock during the TOS/TAS era (assuming they don't seriously diverge from canon). However, after watching this episode, now it almost feels like karmic retribution for breaking his heart in the first place, though I admit I feel kind of petty for having that thought. In any event, this does seem to recontextualize their future dynamic. When Spock rejects her in TOS, it's apparently not because he can't reciprocate her feelings, but rather because he doesn't want to get hurt again.

I know that line she asks spock “Have you ever been engaged, Mr. Spock?” from What Little Girls Are Made Of?” Hasn’t age well. No I wonder if she was giving him a hard time.
 
I know that line she asks spock “Have you ever been engaged, Mr. Spock?” from What Little Girls Are Made Of?” Hasn’t age well. No I wonder if she was giving him a hard time.
More than a betrothal; less than a marriage.

His experience is not like other engagements.
 
However, do we really want SNW to be mainly a soap that shows how the various relationships are doing week to week? So, I'm ok with how it's worked out.

No, we don't want SNW to turn into a relationship soap- that would be the demise of the show, I think. Character development? Sure. Arcs? Sure. But let's get on with exploring SNW.
 
Last edited:
Throughout this series, I've felt bad for Chapel, knowing that she's doomed to spend years pining for Spock during the TOS/TAS era (assuming they don't seriously diverge from canon). However, after watching this episode, now it almost feels like karmic retribution for breaking his heart in the first place, though I admit I feel kind of petty for having that thought. In any event, this does seem to recontextualize their future dynamic. When Spock rejects her in TOS, it's apparently not because he can't reciprocate her feelings, but rather because he doesn't want to get hurt again.

This is an old story in relationships. One partner is dissatisfied and leaves the other, later regrets it and would like to get back together, but the spurned partner has a) moved on and/or b) lost the trust that was there the first time. The grass isn't always greener, and sometimes the 'better deal' someone thinks is waiting for them either isn't there, or isn't actually a better deal at all.
 
Last edited:
Rewatched this ep now with my daughter (she's a 12 year old musical nut so thought it might hook her on live-action trek)

Have to say. Celia Rose Gooding is a great singer, but for all the hype about her going into this Christina Chong is better. She was incredible. The best of them all by far - and they were all good
 
Yeah, too bad he can't sing though.
(I find that scene just plain painful.)

The terrible singing is part of what makes it so awesome. If he was a great singer, all that enthusiasm would have been warranted. The fact that it's not is what makes it so damn funny. Besides, Klingon opera should sound like a 2 AM cat fight waking you out of a sound sleep.
 
Christine Chong is a terrific singer and I really enjoyed the song... but this isn't Star Trek and this at a point when the show couldn't sink any lower than "Those Old Scientists". Mediocre committee writers who wants to have "fun".

If there were more episodes per seasons then I wouldn't mind as much, but with two "Worst of Star Trek" in short order in a season that's merely ten episodes...

1/10
 
1) Rent is over a quarter-century old. It's not a contemporary musical. It is as old today as Hair and 1776 were when Rent premiered.

Feeling my age: I confess I wince whenever I see commentary about this episode citing "traditional" musicals like . . . Les Miz and Phantom of the Opera?

I mean, I know, intellectually, that those shows are close to forty years old now, but I still think of them as "modern" musicals, as opposed to Oklahoma, My Fair Lady, Brigadoon, etc.

Ouch.

Just like I still think of, say, "Back to the Future" and "The Terminator" as "modern movies," as opposed to "Forbidden Planet" or "Bride of Frankenstein."

(Dare I confess that the soundtrack album to "My Fair Lady" was probably the very first LP I ever bought with my own money, back when I was a kid?)
 
Well, I have literally been saying all season regarding Spock and Chapel that they were going to twist the knife and tear out our hearts with a smile on their face and a song on their lips. Looks like I was more right than I could have ever guessed.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top