Spock didn't have a half-brother nor Kirk a son during the years of TOS.
Spoilers Star Trek: Picard General Discussion Thread
- Thread starter Tuskin38
- Start date
It was 20 years ago.
I went to my high school reunion a few years ago, and not everyone was with who they were with when we were seniors in high school. I didn't need to be spelled out to me, I figured it out on my own. People had moved on with their lives between 1997 and 2017 and not everyone who was together back then was still together now. It's not exactly rocket science.
I had a girlfriend senior year of high school, we were not a good fit, it's pretty obvious in retrospect, and no one I ran into afterwards ever asked me, "What happened to her?" They asked me, "So what have you been up to lately?"
People aren't stupid. They can put two-and-two together. So credit them with some intelligence.
Last edited:
Firstly, Voyager was over 20 years ago, huge changes in what has become "norm" on TV since then. Seven has become rogue, so not a surprise her sexuality has done the same. As for Hugh, I mean, you can't be a Trek fan and not know who that was. Maddox/Icheb you may not have, heck I sure didn't at first, but the viewer isn't sidetracked by not knowing.
No offense taken. But it doesn't have to be me, it's just an example of how things work in general. And people can figure out, "Oh, they were together and now they're not, they broke up!"
I think you know this too, and are just keeping this going to keep the argument going. Do you really think Seven and Chakotay made a good pair? Tell that to me with a straight face. Let's see if you're lying or not. They had zero chemistry. ZERO.
They're not together anymore because they just weren't a good fit. You know it too. You just don't want to say it.
One more point about this, then I'm done. If people really wondered what happened to Seven/Chakotay, we'd have seen several threads about it in the PIC Forum or at least one that would never end. We'd have had posters going on and on and on about it. The Gatekeepers have given Picard a lot of shit, but not about that; from what I've seen. The Gatekeepers will jump on anything and everything they can. So the fact that they haven't in this case (with the exception of right here) actually says something.
Last edited:
Where would you have referenced it?
I can't think of a suitable spot between the vengeance and genocidal extragalactic AI invasion.
right when she was rescued by the LaSirena. "Hi, Locutus, I was in a relationship with a piece of wood once, but now I'm better. You can call me Annika!"
Picard didn't reference the Crushers, either. That would've been way more relevant than Chakotay.
TMP doesn't mention any of Kirk's old girlfriends or his son. TFF doesn't mention Gillian. Or Saavik. First Contact doesn't mention anyone from DS9. Nemesis ignores Worf's diplomatic career.
None of this matters in the slightest.
TMP doesn't mention any of Kirk's old girlfriends or his son. TFF doesn't mention Gillian. Or Saavik. First Contact doesn't mention anyone from DS9. Nemesis ignores Worf's diplomatic career.
None of this matters in the slightest.
Rumours abound that a major TNG character will be killed off that will set the story of season 2 in motion......so that will be one of (Riker, Picard, Q, Guinan or as rumored to appear) Wesley or Geordi...)
Season 2 is a long form version of Tapestry/Times Arrow....
Season 3 is looking like long form version of First Contact...
More to follow...back soon.
Season 2 is a long form version of Tapestry/Times Arrow....
Season 3 is looking like long form version of First Contact...
More to follow...back soon.
Bi means both, we've seen one, which doesn't rule out the other.
Yes, how out of character for a guy who used to be alive to suddenly die from a deadly disease, and then other characters deciding to give him a new body.
Do you still reference your first relationship from high school or college 25 ys later? I mean, unless it's a reunion of said school or college, or you meet people who've last known you then.
Just wondering where you are spreading this from.
Citation, quote, link, source?
Thanks!
Last edited:
Considering how much blowback the first season got from killing off minor characters like Hugh and Icheb just for teh dramaz, this would be an absolutely awful choice to kick off season 2.
Edit: I mean, they would be fucked both ways. Either they don't , make a big deal out of it, and it comes across as cheap drama, or they give it weight...and it's Season 1's Data plot all over again.
Until I see links I'm gonna treat this the same way I do an InfoWars story. Extreme skepticism followed by possible Gifs.
The only two deaths that wouldn't seem like they did it just for the sake of doing it would be Beverly's, because that's what I expected even before Season 1 was released (and you can see old posts of mine where I said that's what I thought), and it seems like something that would fit the fabric of Picard...
... and Ro. Mainly because she was in the Maquis and there's a very good chance she was killed when the Dominion slaughtered them during the fifth season of DS9. If she survived, then that would be the surprise, not the other way around.
... and Ro. Mainly because she was in the Maquis and there's a very good chance she was killed when the Dominion slaughtered them during the fifth season of DS9. If she survived, then that would be the surprise, not the other way around.
Similar threads
