Saw it yesterday afternoon with my eight year old daughter. Theater was decently full, but I know a fair amount of people didn't show up because when I bought tickets it was nearly sold out.
My daughter looked rather distressed when Shatner and the host were laughing about spoiling the movie. SHE'D never seen it before. (And in my house we take spoilers seriously.) I think they should have shown that after the film.
And what was Shatner babbling on about Montalban being in a walker? Wasn't Montalban also the star of a very popular television series at the time? That showed him walking around on a regular basis?
I also think Shatner's stories about Spock's death have grown in the telling. For one thing every story I've heard about Shatner has said that 1) he's a crazy hard worker but 2) if he's not in a scene he's not on set. So I doubt he was "around" to see "remember".
ANYWAY.
The "film" looked gorgeous. The only thing I wondered about was the starfield in the opening credits looked a little pixelated. I don't know if it always looked like that (1982 CG) and I just haven't seen it projected for 25 years. And I don't care how big your TV is or how good your sound system is, there is nothing like HEARING a movie in the cinema.
I was so glad nobody cheered at "Khaaan!" It's not a funny line. It's not an upbeat moment. Would anyone cheer at "To be or not to be?" just because it's the best known line? I never had a problem with Shatner's performance of it either.
There was a person a few seats down from me who seemed to be chuckling at a lot of little "Trekkie" things. Like every time someone "died" in the Kobayashi Maru. (I guess she knew the punchline and just couldn't wait.) She settled down a little as the film went on.
My daughter loved the movie. She asked me at the beginning "Is that the captain?" I remember seeing it in 1982 and (when you're trying to figure out where a movie is going) thinking that the Enterprise was going to be captured and Kirk was going to have to get her back. We didn't know the ranks or the colors, so why wouldn't Saavik be captain? And when I was 13 in that first scene she was intimidating as hell. Watching the view screen open and Kirk walk through it is one of the greatest moments of my cinematic life.
Speaking of cheers, the one moment that didn't pay off like it did 35 years ago was "Spock, it's two hours. Are you ready?" That got a gasp and a cheer back in The Day. But now most of the people in the audience know it. Kind of too bad. When I saw Casablanca for the first time in a cinema I think the audience was a little less spoiled. But "I don't like to lose" did get a good laugh.
One of the things I love about this movie that has just about gone away in modern film is how much of it is unscored. After the titles we don't hear music again until Khan and his people show up. All of the scenes in the Kobayashi Maru, Kirk and Spock in that arboretum / lobby area, Kirk's apartment, all run on dialog and sound effects.
I don't hate ILM's work on this film by any shot (it's lovely), but Douglas Trumbull's shots of the Enterprise that are used as stock are just in a class by themselves.
I've never been a fan of most of the restored scenes. Some because I know the originals SO well. (Like the extended take of the Regula staff arguing about Reliant). I don't like the extra scene with McCoy and Kirk in the apartment (that scene was knife edge perfect originally). I see no point for climbing the ladder (especially since it messes up the music). I kind of like the "human ego" exchange. And I run hot and cold on Peter Preston's scenes.
BUT WHY DID THEY TAKE OUT DOOHAN'S SCENE IN SICKBAY?!? That kills me every time. Although Kirk's answer and Shatner's performance of it are pretty terrible. I don't know if the rumors are true that Shatner would flub a line if he wanted a scene cut. But I don't know how you'd deliver that line anyway. It's so condescending. And while I'm totally fine with Khan knowing who Chekov is, Kirk's answer to Scotty sounds like he's forgotten that SCOTTY WAS SITTING AT THE SAME TABLE AS KIRK when Khan was sentenced.
People have mentioned the number of names of people in the credits that are no longer with us. I was OK until James Horner walks by the camera for maybe a second when they're getting ready for the battle in the Mutara Nebula.
Well worth my time and money. Glad we were able to do it.
The ear worm thing is the scariest part on the whole film so I wanted to show my kids that and explain that it's just pretend and how the effects were made.
My daughter wasn't scared by the eels as much as when McCoy runs into the dead hand on Regula. I wasn't taking that moment away from her for anything.
