• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Should Americans be required to buy health insurance?

Do you think that the Civil Rights bill was perfect? It took years and plenty of modifications AFTER it was signed before it actually took the form that we see today. The lawmakers at that time passed what they could, knowing they would work on it, shape it, in the following years. How about a bill I know you liked - the Patriot Act. How many modifications did that take, after it was signed?

Do you believe the Patriot Act was passed in order to solidify a voting block? Because that's what this bill is all about. In my opinion, of course.
Of course, you're wrong.

I do allow for that possibility, but it's not bloody likely!
 
I guess from my point of view, I don't want to pass a "bad" bill just because they can't pass a "good" bill.

That's the problem with conservatives. They don't like to leap without looking.

Maybe I'm tired or something but what? :wtf:

They took a major leap in the Iraq War and completely missed their mark. They decided to focus on Iran when they should have focused on North Korea. They do leap without looking first.
Bush? Conservative? He's another big government guy.

Oh, for heaven's sake! How often do we need to tell you that the quality of your health care will not drop just because the costs/risks are spread over a larger pool of insured citizens?

Often. Now tell me that my same income is going feed and cloth my family the same even though fees, costs, and taxes are rising for everything.

If you want to talk about inflation then open another thread.
I was giving you a parallel to your statement.

All that matters is they can say the US has UHC. It doesn't matter to them what it looks like on the other side. It doesn't matter how much it'll cost or that it'll bankrupt the nation. That's the problem with conservatives. They don't like to leap without looking. But, as one, I'm just a selfish bastard.

'Bankrupt the nation'?
You may have no confidence in your own country, but I don't believe for a second that your country is actually to stupid to implement UHC.
It's... baffling to me that those who pontificate about the greatness of America, the Exceptionalism of America the most are also the ones who think the US are incapable of making UHC work financially. Especially considering that smaller, economically weaker countries can make it work just fine.

But it is indeed a declaration of bankruptcy (the German Bankrotterklärung sounds better) that, after 100 years of debate, you still haven't got what every other western country sees as a societal necessity.
What is the national debt at the moment?

The US has health care.

A bill that will usurp control of 1/5th of the US economy should be hashed out beforehand. It should be debated openly in public forums and televised on TV. Not pushed through slapdash by partisan votes after not allowing the public to read the bill or CBO report.

Mhmm, you mean the bill that was available to read on the internet?
Do you mean those town hall meetings all over your country?
Do you mean the constant debate on TV, radio and the internet?

Yeah, all that never happened. :rolleyes:
Naw, the one Reid just slammed through. The one that had perhaps 24 hours exposure. Remember, these aren't all the same bills.
 
A bill that will usurp control of 1/5th of the US economy should be hashed out beforehand. It should be debated openly in public forums and televised on TV. Not pushed through slapdash by partisan votes after not allowing the public to read the bill or CBO report.

Mhmm, you mean the bill that was available to read on the internet?
Do you mean those town hall meetings all over your country?
Do you mean the constant debate on TV, radio and the internet?

Yeah, all that never happened. :rolleyes:

You know one day these people will be able to make an argument on this issue without resorting to lies.

On that day I think the rest of us will die from shock.

Should also point out that the cost of health care reform is actually less than what the U.S has spend so far on Bush's Operation IraqiClusterFuck and will actually save Americans money long term and provide improved health care i.e provide tangible benefits which is more than can be said for Bush's wars.
 
A bill that will usurp control of 1/5th of the US economy should be hashed out beforehand. It should be debated openly in public forums and televised on TV. Not pushed through slapdash by partisan votes after not allowing the public to read the bill or CBO report.

Mhmm, you mean the bill that was available to read on the internet?
Do you mean those town hall meetings all over your country?
Do you mean the constant debate on TV, radio and the internet?

Yeah, all that never happened. :rolleyes:

You know one day these people will be able to make an argument on this issue without resorting to lies.

On that day I think the rest of us will die from shock.

Should also point out that the cost of health care reform is actually less than what the U.S has spend so far on Bush's Operation IraqiClusterFuck and will actually save Americans money long term and provide improved health care i.e provide tangible benefits which is more than can be said for Bush's wars.

And this says it all when it comes to the basic ideological differences between Democrats and Republicans.

Democrats want to spend money to help Americans. Republicans want to spend money to kill non-Americans.
 
^ Well, to be fair, we only want to kill those non-Americans who would otherwise kill us first. You can't help Americans if you're dead. ;)
 
A bill that will usurp control of 1/5th of the US economy should be hashed out beforehand.

It's not taking control of anything. Read the bill.

It should be debated openly in public forums and televised on TV.

CSPAN. Town Halls. It was openly debated and televised on TV. Anyone can walk into a hearing or sit in the gallery.

Not pushed through slapdash by partisan votes after not allowing the public to read the bill or CBO report.


It was the second longest debate in US Senate history. And here's the CBO report. Congress can't wait until every single American reads something. It's easily found on Google. You wanna read it? Look it up. Don't expect the government to do it for you. Isn't that your motto?

From the CBO:
According to CBO and JCT’s assessment, enacting the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act would result in a net reduction in federal budget deficits of $130 billion over the 2010–2019 period

Ohhh...didn't wanna see that...did ya?

No, these huge 2000+ page bills that Obama's cronies make up and push through regardless of public opinion aren't about fixing anything. Just about grabbing power by increasing the size of government.

It's only 800 something pages (314,900 words), which puts it in the "normal" range for large bills using the standard guidelines for printing bills in Congress. At the old norm of 250 words per page (which is less than what Congress uses) it only comes out to 1259.6 pages, significantly less than War and Peace which comes in at 460-560,000 words.

The Safe, Accountable, Flexible, Efficient Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for Users, 2005 was 314,832 words but I don't remember too many people bitching about it's length like petulant children. Perhaps that's because it was introduced by a Republican.

It's 2000+ pages when you ramp up the font, the margins, and print on one side of the page.
 
How about a bill I know you liked - the Patriot Act.

Liked that one? I'm sorry but I don't believe you.
You don't believe that I believe that you like the Patriot Act???
Oh I believe that but I believe you'd be wrong.

Democrats want to spend money to help Americans. Republicans want to spend money to kill non-Americans.

And that's why we can't have anything nice in this house.

The US has health care.

Only millions do not have access to it.

:techman:

Yes, a very small percentage. 50, er 47, er, 40, no wait, 30 million. And about 20 million of those are illegal aliens. So we're going to ruin the health care of 300 million just to give 10 million some coverage and it's going to cost 2.5T. Not including the doctor bill coming up to fill the gaps of the health care bill.

I'm appalled with the corruption in these bills. If this was such a good thing bribery wouldn't be necessary. As I keep saying, this isn't about health care.
 
Yes, a very small percentage. 50, er 47, er, 40, no wait, 30 million. And about 20 million of those are illegal aliens. So we're going to ruin the health care of 300 million just to give 10 million some coverage and it's going to cost 2.5T. Not including the doctor bill coming up to fill the gaps of the health care bill.

Oh, if it's only 10.000.000 million people... :rolleyes:

BTW: Nothing is ruined for those who already have health insurance.
The worst that could happen, if you implemented a system like Germany's, it that they would get the chance to enter into a system that is a lot cheaper while still having the highest of standards.
 
And as numerous anecdotal examples in this thread alone show, even a lot of people who have health insurance apparently have pretty crappy health care in the US.
 
And as numerous anecdotal examples in this thread alone show, even a lot of people who have health insurance apparently have pretty crappy health care in the US.

or have health insurers who retroactively cancel policies after a procedure that would of been covered has been carried out.

but that doesn't matter to the fuck-you-I've-got-mine crowd who are so opposed to health care reform.

It would be poetic justice if they picked up something nasty from some who contagious because they'd been denied coverage which then lead to a loss of coverage and big out of pocket expenses.
 
Yes, a very small percentage. 50, er 47, er, 40, no wait, 30 million. And about 20 million of those are illegal aliens. So we're going to ruin the health care of 300 million just to give 10 million some coverage and it's going to cost 2.5T. Not including the doctor bill coming up to fill the gaps of the health care bill.

Oh, if it's only 10.000.000 million people... :rolleyes:

Yup, only. If these people can't get insurance through work them perhaps the Democrats can start a charity fund to pay for the health care. Then anyone can voluntarily contribute. Or they can just fix medicare and cover those people that way. But better to make people uncomfortable in their poverty so they decide to better themselves.





And as numerous anecdotal examples in this thread alone show, even a lot of people who have health insurance apparently have pretty crappy health care in the US.

Yeah, that'd be a NOPE.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top