• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

She-Ra and the Princesses of Power

Asking questions is what children do. It's how they learn. Children are very perceptive. They notice things, they wonder about things, they try to figure things out. They're a damn sight better at adults than remembering the difference between imagination and reality, because they use their own imaginations all the time, but that doesn't mean they're too stupid to wonder about the flaws in a work of imagination. On the contrary, it means they're the experts at imagination, so if you want to offer them something creative, they deserve nothing less than your best effort. Just as children always deserve the best we can offer them.

I'm not sure what your experiences of children are but I have three exceptionally clever ones who bring dozens of their peers through my door at one point or another. If there were a pattern there it's that they are in many ways more perceptive than adults about themes and ideas in shows and many programs do cater to that. I'm a fan of Ben and Holly which is extraordinarily subtle in how it conveys complex social themes. My daughter watched it at seven and instantly drew the parallel between the Wise Old Elf and my own union activities, she got the implied racism and class war between the elves and the fairies.

However they are children and you are not, nor is She Ra particularly an attempt to cater to adults attempting to draw faux intellectualisations out of blatant and inconsequential plot holes in painfully weak attempts to impress other adults on an internet forum. On the contrary I'm pretty confident most kids would be fully cognisant of the fact that She Ra was written as a female counterpart or reflection of He Man and that the blazingly obvious hole in the plot was about that parallel rather than being something to question from an in universe perspective.

They wouldn't make a point of drawing attention to that plot hole in a pretentious attempt to find profound insights in the truly mundane because they would assume that much was already a given to any intelligent viewer. The issue isn't one of you seeing kids as having intellectual prowess that most adults don't allow for, but rather you yet again failing to grasp how your ongoing underestimation of everyone makes your attempts to present the most empty and meaningless humdrum observations as being evidence of your own profound insights fall flat. It just looks silly and comes across simultaneously as patronising and embarrassing.
 
So?

I'm pretty sure you could watch the first five minutes and pick twenty holes in it because it was never meant to hold up an adult's critical analysis.

These things were fun, they have nostalgia value for adults to watch who grew up with them, but attempting to meaningfully critique them is just silly. What's next? Looking at Jack and Jill's motivations or applying a Freudian lens to Zippy and Bungle?
Who are Zippy and Bungle?
 
...and again in 2002. I don't see any reason why they shouldn't be doing a straight-up She-Ra series. I'm sure if the show goes on long enough it's only a matter of time before they introduce the concept of Adam/He-Man & Eternia.

Just from a conceptual standpoint, I honestly always thought She-Ra had the more interesting premise. So in a way i think it actually works a lot better as a starting point for a franchise.
 
...and again in 2002. I don't see any reason why they shouldn't be doing a straight-up She-Ra series. I'm sure if the show goes on long enough it's only a matter of time before they introduce the concept of Adam/He-Man & Eternia.

Just from a conceptual standpoint, I honestly always thought She-Ra had the more interesting premise. So in a way i think it actually works a lot better as a starting point for a franchise.

I don't see why it would be an issue for He-Man to be the spin-off this time.
 
It looks good... but I'm still not sure how they're doing this without doing He-Man first.

The same way Marvel did a Black Panther movie (and a movie with Ronan the Accuser in it) without doing Fantastic Four first, and included Scarlet Witch without having the rights to Magneto. The same way Arrow was able to feature the League of Assassins and Ra's al Ghul without doing Batman first. Remakes get to do things differently. That's kind of the point of doing them at all.

In this particular case, it doesn't seem that difficult to me. The core of She-Ra's origin story is that she was raised as a member of the Horde, had it revealed to her that it was evil, was endowed with the power of She-Ra, and used it to join the rebellion against the Horde. The fact that the person who gave her that revelation was her hitherto-unknown twin brother who was also a superhero from a parallel universe is an added complication that was only necessary the first time because it was setting up She-Ra as a spinoff. Doing She-Ra as a standalone series means you can leave off that convoluted part and just focus on the core story of Adora's redemption. Maybe have a member of her own supporting cast, like Bow or Glimmer, be the one who shows her the suffering the Horde causes and inspires her to break free. Have the source of the magic sword be integral to the magic and mythos of her own reality rather than a random crossover from a separate universe. If anything, She-Ra might work better without He-Man, because it's a more streamlined and unified story without that intrusion from another reality.
 
Aside from the "Honour of Grayskull" thing. Unless "Grayskull" pertains to something (or someone) on Etheria, rather than Eternia. Or we could have "For the Honour of the Crystal Castle" instead.
 
Aside from the "Honour of Grayskull" thing. Unless "Grayskull" pertains to something (or someone) on Etheria, rather than Eternia.

No reason it can't. Remakes can change anything. As long as the essential aspects of the premise and characters remain, the details can be remixed any way you want.

Then again, perhaps the nature and origin of this "Grayskull" thing, and the reason it endows her with powers, will be presented as a mystery that She-Ra will explore over the course of the series, eventually leading her to discover Eternia and her long-lost twin brother.

Or we could have "For the Honour of the Crystal Castle" instead.

She does shout "For the Honor of Grayskulllllll!" at the end of the teaser clip.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top