Seven of Nine or T'Pol?

[captcalhoun]

Seven

 

[InfoStyle]

T'Pol is beautiful but 7 of 9 is 10.

 

[USS Triumphant]

Seven, just because Jeri Ryan didn't publically bitch about her show's craptastic writing the same way Jolene did. I still like Jolene but, those comments shouldn't have been made. It's unprofessional.

It might be "unprofessional", but the output of the stage is *supposed to be* ART, and those who make it, artists. Jeri Ryan is a talented actress that I enjoyed as 7 and in other works, but I think I prefer it that an *artist* be willing to speak up when he or she believes that what they are making or have made is crap and not art, even at the risk that that will make it more difficult for them to get work later. (To be fair to Ryan, perhaps she wasn't remaining silent in spite of seeing problems with the writing: maybe she really didn't SEE problems with the writing. A lot of people really like Voyager... somehow. And Voyager did have some stinkers, to be sure, but none of them were ever as bad as TATV. Even Threshold.)

I thought T'Pol was attractive, Jolene herself moreso, and Mirror T'Pol very much moreso. I never found Seven attractive at all, except she was lovely in the episodes where she wasn't Borgified or in the catsuit (and Jeri Ryan generally is, elsewhere). Given a choice of which one I would want on my ship, though, I'd rather have Seven. She has two additional centuries of Borg and general knowledge, and isn't a crack addict.

 

[The Old Mixer]

I thought this thread looked familiar...but it may be an even earlier one than the one I was thinking of.

@InfoStyle , we generally discourage reviving long-dormant threads here (haven't been posted in for at least a year), in favor of starting new ones.

Hope everyone managed to get their votes in sometime during the last seven years, because this poll is now closed.