• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

News Season One hitting DVD/Blu-Ray in November

So let me get this straight.

Nobody wanted Short Treks because no one bought them even though they probably were never for sale given the obvious intent of them being exclusive content?

It's not that hard to believe, no one makes content for it not to make money . Why keep those as exclusives for the US and Canada? It's not like Trek isn't a money making machine.

I would say it's a pretty safe bet they were offered to international distedistrib, Netflix passed and no one else was interested in buying 4x15 minute shorts that they couldn't show the main show of.
 
It's not that hard to believe, no one makes content for it not to make money . Why keep those as exclusives for the US and Canada? It's not like Trek isn't a money making machine.

I would say it's a pretty safe bet they were offered to international distedistrib, Netflix passed and no one else was interested in buying 4x15 minute shorts that they couldn't show the main show of.

four 15 minute shows spread once a month just really isn't the kind of thing netflix does so I can see them passing for that reason, They may air them in a chunk during seasion 2 sometime but the one a month model just isn't them
 
I caved in and bought the blu ray. It looks fantastic upscaled on a 4k TV, so much better than what it looks like on Netflix HDR (DV). One of the best looking blu ray pictures I've seen!
 
Last edited:
four 15 minute shows spread once a month just really isn't the kind of thing netflix does so I can see them passing for that reason, They may air them in a chunk during seasion 2 sometime but the one a month model just isn't them
Yes. And international distribution is not as simple as paying for the "rights" and then putting the data up on the servers. And the overall cost to Netflix would never justify the small amount content, even if it did fit within their paradigm. CBS knew that going in.

But that's assuming they even ever offered the shorties to begin with. CBS's goal is not to promote Star Trek, it's to promote CBS, which is the whole point of exclusive supplemental content. The shorties are one step above the interviews, behind the scenes and other snippets they have on the site. Their sole purpose is to promote the AA and strengthen viewer retention.

And that holds true outside the US because, make no mistake, CBS's goal has always been to become an international product - either directly or through partnerships around the globe. And, I think it's safe to say that the only reason they made the deal with Netflix, to begin with, was because Netflix sweetened the pot so much that CBS couldn't have possibly said no.

But the market/medium has evolved a lot since they made that deal, and it's going to evolve and change even more over the next 18-24 months to the point it's very likely - even inevitable - that CBS and Netflix will become direct competitors (both in North America and internationally). CBS knows this. So it behooves them to keep as many of their own eggs in their own basket as possible.
 
Yes. And international distribution is not as simple as paying for the "rights" and then putting the data up on the servers. And the overall cost to Netflix would never justify the small amount content, even if it did fit within their paradigm. CBS knew that going in.

But that's assuming they even ever offered the shorties to begin with. CBS's goal is not to promote Star Trek, it's to promote CBS, which is the whole point of exclusive supplemental content. The shorties are one step above the interviews, behind the scenes and other snippets they have on the site. Their sole purpose is to promote the AA and strengthen viewer retention.

And that holds true outside the US because, make no mistake, CBS's goal has always been to become an international product - either directly or through partnerships around the globe. And, I think it's safe to say that the only reason they made the deal with Netflix, to begin with, was because Netflix sweetened the pot so much that CBS couldn't have possibly said no.

But the market/medium has evolved a lot since they made that deal, and it's going to evolve and change even more over the next 18-24 months to the point it's very likely - even inevitable - that CBS and Netflix will become direct competitors (both in North America and internationally). CBS knows this. So it behooves them to keep as many of their own eggs in their own basket as possible.

It works even less like that. Yes let's create content to the tune of $1 million per episode and not offer to sell it to international distributors, let them pirate it and watch it for free.

But let's offer it to Canada though, even though they don't have CBS All Access.

Your reply makes no business sense, the shorts are not content sellers, keeping them exclusive does nothing for CBS. CBS are a long way off from launching anything internationally. Heck even places where they do operate outside the US like Australia Star Trek Disc is on Netflix.

No one spends that kind of money to say to shareholders that one day we will put this on our on platform that doesn't currently exist .
 
No.

The cost of the Short Treks was proverbial pocket change.

And business produce content at an initial loss all the time - especially in the entertainment industry (video games are notorious for this). In fact, across most industry, the accounted ROI is almost never immediate.
 
Amazon says that the DVD will be back in stock Dec. 6 while the blu-ray will be back Dec. 7

By which time most people who want to buy this will have got it elsewhere, some of them undoubtedly for $10. Assuming the copies on eBay from Chinese sellers are genuine, and there's no money in faking DVDs, it's quite mind blowing to see just how badly CBS has screwed US retailers. If I was running the likes of Amazon, Walmart, Target, Best Buy etc, I wouldn't touch CBS product ever again.
 
By which time most people who want to buy this will have got it elsewhere, some of them undoubtedly for $10. Assuming the copies on eBay from Chinese sellers are genuine, and there's no money in faking DVDs, it's quite mind blowing to see just how badly CBS has screwed US retailers. If I was running the likes of Amazon, Walmart, Target, Best Buy etc, I wouldn't touch CBS product ever again.
What is wrong with you?

Your last year of post history is just all negative posts, nothing positive/nice, just complaining about whatever the topic is about and sometimes just being outright rude.
 
Last edited:
I've seen plenty of physical copies, including several last night. Sometimes I wonder if Amazon deliberately doesn't make it hard to buy physical media because they want to push people to streaming (and their streaming service).

Admittedly, not selling stuff people want to buy seems like an odd choice for a retailer, but I've looked on Amazon over the last year for several big-name blurays and haven't been able to get them. Either they have a horrible stock-management problem or something is going on.
 
But let's offer it to Canada though, even though they don't have CBS All Access.

They have to run in Canada first, because the show gets a lot of tax-incentives from Canada - under the condition it's both filmed, produced, and aired there.

Outside from this legal requirement for the money they receive, they air them nowhere outside the U.S. Which is IMO really, really dumb - their honestly better promotion for DIS than the entirety of DIS itself so far....

The cost of the Short Treks was proverbial pocket change.

I don't think so. They heavily feature vfx, heavy make-up, main characters, production values, and a handfull of extras. Yes, they are "bottle-shows". But not of the cheap kind.

I guess if you add up the cost of all four Shorts together, you'd end up way higher then the budget of one "regular" episode, probably two, even though the runtime is comparable.
 
For those who own the home release, does episode 4 still have the TOS tech manual style UFP logo? I’m curious if they replaced it with the logo seen later in the season.

It appears on the screen after Lorca watches the Corvan II distress call
 
Last edited:
...and there's no money in faking DVDs...

Really?

https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2004/jul/13/ukcrime.film

Terrorist groups and organised criminals can make larger profits from DVD piracy than from drug trafficking, according to a report published yesterday.

Illegal versions of the latest DVDs, which can often be bought from market stalls or car boot sales before the film is released on to British screens, are thought to be worth around £500m each year to criminal groups.

But as organised crime increasingly moves into the counterfeit DVD trade, industry experts predict the figure will exceed £1bn within three years.

According to Interpol, the high profits and low risks associated with DVD piracy mean that 1kg of pirated discs is now worth more than 1kg of cannabis resin to criminal and terrorist groups.

Do you ever get tired of being completely wrong?

Here's a Google search about bootleg DVD's on Ebay...

https://www.google.com/search?sourc...j0i131i67j0i22i10i30j0i13j0i13i30.Tx_aKIJrtNQ
 
Last edited:
Since we're currently subscribed to CBSAA for the Short Treks/season 2 run I am putting off buying the BD until the next hiatus.

No sense plopping down the cash now while I can currently access DSC whenever I want.
 
How the hell did we get onto the topic of DVD pirating versus drug trafficking? How is this in any way relevant to anything? If this is just someone's (i.e Admiral Bear's) way of justifying their opinion that they don't like DSC, then perhaps someone needs to find a better use of their time.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top