• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Scotty has been cast! And now Sulu too!

Re: Scotty has been cast!

WHAT!?!?!

Can you say "miscast"?

UGH!

He's a good actor, but totally wrong for Scotty. Hell, I'd rather have McAvoy.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Damn. I really wanted McGillion as Scotty. Oh well, I'm cautiously optimistic.

Man this has been an exciting last few nights for Star Trek news!!
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Turbo said:
WHAT!?!?!

Can you say "miscast"?

UGH!

He's a good actor, but totally wrong for Scotty. Hell, I'd rather have McAvoy.

Every single dork that saw Shaun of the Dead and Hot Fuzz is going to go see Star Trek.

I promise!!!
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

^^ Whatever it takes to make the film a success, and bring Star Trek back to life!
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

It's stunt casting, plain and simple.

It can be argued that Paul McGillion or James McAvoy would be stunt casting as well, but at least we know they can play Scottish characters.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

^Who's to say Simon Pegg can't play a Scottish character? We don't know yet. We haven't seen him in the role.

Give 'em a break.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Stunt casting? Are you being serious?

This casting news (both for Scotty and Sulu), plus the one from a few days ago of Bana, and the offering of the role of Kirk to Pine is awesome.

Now if they could somehow get Cruise to play the role of Pike..

The casting so far seems to be pretty top notch.

Sometimes I think it would have just been better for them to go in a different direction with new characters. I just hope the movie turns out to be equally good.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

dalehoppert said:
Well I guess there had to be a clunker in the casting somewhere... I'm not sure this is a bad idea, but it doesn't seem as natural as any of the other confirmed cast so far. I really like him, but I'm having a hard time seeing him as Mr. Scott. Photoshop visualization? Anyone?

I was rooting for Mcgillion but I guess its decided now. I've liked Pegg from what little I have seen him in, about the last 20 mins of Shawn of the Dead and an episode of Doctor Who. Apparently he was also in MI3, which I saw but don't recall him?

Anyway look forward to seeing how the new crew works out, here is my photoshop attempt.
peggscottyka2.jpg


And this was my first scotty manip with Mcgillion.
scottymcgillionws7.jpg
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Nice news, Pegg is a good actor and it'll be fun seeing him in the movie :)
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Yeah... McGillion would have been 10/10 for Scotty, but Pegg is so awesome, that I'm pretty sure he can pull anything off... :thumbsup:
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Well...

I'm pleased for the guy, but my gut says no. As a brit, I've been a massive fan of Pegg for years. Spaced, Hot Fuzz & Shaun and the Dead are on my DVD shelf. Thing is, he's one of us - guys. He really is. I've never seen him talk about Trek before, but he is a MASSIVE Star Wars fan.

You do the math.

Simon Pegg (Star Wars fan) + J.J. Abrams (Star Wars fan). I bet they got on really well. I can see it now.

I'm totally happy for Simon Pegg, but this is the first casting that has split the internet I think.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Wow. Talk about being so very, very random. Would not have guessed Pegg for the role in a million years.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Well, that's certainly shocking. Not someone I'd have ever guessed to be picked to play Scotty. Pegg is cool since he's a big Star Wars nut. All we need is McCoy. And Kirk but I think Pine will end up taking the offer.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

None of us has seen the Script (have we?)

I bet Scotty's role is (at best), four or five scenes - which I imagine may be "lighter". I'm not saying comedy scenes, I mean lighter than the rest of the movie.

I think the costumes and make-up will sell this one. I trust his acting chops.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Simon Pegg is great, I love Spaced. But I can't picture him as Scotty whatsoever.
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Well, there goes any and all interest I might have had in seeing this film. :(
 
Re: Scotty has been cast!

Okay, Simon Pegg is awesome. I love Shaun of the Dead, his role in M:I3 was fun, and I really want to see Hot Fuzz. BUT...I really can't see him as Scotty. At all.

As for John Cho -- well, the only thing I've seen him in is American Pie, so that's not a whole lot to go on, is it?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top