• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sarah Jane Season 5 starts Oct 3 in the UK

I think those two and the Trickster are just as good as anything NuWho has come up with. And lord knows SJA captures the spirit of the classic series much more than Torchwood.

RTD certainly agreed regarding the Trickster since he played a major role in Doctor Who itself (or at least his Brigade did - see Turn Left) and even got a major shout-out in Torchwood: Miracle Day.

Torchwood was never devised to be like Doctor Who, so it's irrelevant whether it captured the spirit of the classic series. But SJA was, to a degree, and for the most part I agree. The series basically meets half-way between classic Who and the revival. I'd almost go so far as to call it a transition point.

I'm curious to see how they handle the missing 3 stories. If "The Man Who Wasn't There" was written as the series finale as mentioned above, one thing SJA has done the last few years is do a fairly good job tying things together. But if that means, for example, a "return appearance" by a character or villain introduced in one of the unfilmed storylines, I wonder if we'll be provided with synopses or something of those unmade stories? I'd like to think they might form the basis of an "original" SJA novel ("original" in quotes since it would technically be a novelisation the same way the Target releases of the unproduced Doctor Who Season 23 stories or the upcoming Shada adaptation are technically "original" novels since they adapt material we never saw on screen).

Alex
 
i enjoyed it. i loved Clyde's line about 'what does that mean to those of us watching the betball team out the window during chemistry'.
 
23skidoo:

Guess thats why I've never been much of a Torchwood fan. Its more like an X-Files UK, but with more sex.

And yeah, seeing the unproduced stories from this season would be great. A novelization, or hell, just a print version of the scripts would be nice.
 
Yeah, Torchwood as a standalone show I have no major problem with, but Torchwood as a spinoff of a show for all the family always felt a little wrong, and the longer it lasts the more screwed up continuity is gonna get.
 
I know it's been said to death but Clyde and Rani really need their own show.

Part 2 was a bit by the numbers but it was still miles better than the last series of Torchwood.
 
Miss Myles looks like an older Hayden Panetierre. I have a feeling that I'm going to like this series. Batman meets Predator. Whoever designed the Metalkind has to have seen Batman: Dead End.
 
Miss Myles looks like an older Hayden Panetierre. I have a feeling that I'm going to like this series. Batman meets Predator. Whoever designed the Metalkind has to have seen Batman: Dead End.
I hope this isnt your first episode.

Miss Myres (spelt the alien way) was in Farscape (Lieutenant Teeg), as well as the normal The Bill & Casualty
 
i was saying to me mum last night, i was already depressed at Lis dying and this being the last season, but the potential with Sky for new stories and character development makes me even more depressed.
 
I wonder what the plan was? On the one hand it looks like Sky is the Luke replacement, and you do have to wonder if Rani and Clyde might have been marked to go on to other things, with some other younger cast memebers bought in? On the other hand it seems to be the case that they knew Lis wasn't well so you have to wonder why they were doing so much forward planning.

Unless they though (hoped) that Lis wasn't as ill as she was.

Amazing to consider she was probably really ill whilst making this because she still seems so vital and full of energy, nt to mention gorgeous :(
 
Amazing to consider she was probably really ill whilst making this because she still seems so vital and full of energy, nt to mention gorgeous :(

I know, it made very sad to hear her talk about life ending in that episode.
 
Since he's into art, I'm suprised Clyde didnt get what Rani was talking about when shutting down the core.
 
Miss Myles looks like an older Hayden Panetierre. I have a feeling that I'm going to like this series. Batman meets Predator. Whoever designed the Metalkind has to have seen Batman: Dead End.
I hope this isnt your first episode.

Miss Myres (spelt the alien way) was in Farscape (Lieutenant Teeg), as well as the normal The Bill & Casualty

No, it's not my first episode. I've seen all the stories. I've been a fan for years. I meant "series" in the sense that the English use, the same way Americans use "season."

I said that the villain looked like Panetierre because a poster above said that she looked familiar but couldn't place her.
 
We just had a miscarriage three weeks ago and seeing Sky go from baby to girl in a second made me think of what my wife and I are missing. That coupled with seeing Lis Sladen made it depressing. On its own merits the story was fine.
 
We just had a miscarriage three weeks ago and seeing Sky go from baby to girl in a second made me think of what my wife and I are missing. That coupled with seeing Lis Sladen made it depressing. On its own merits the story was fine.

Sorry to hear that :(
 
We just had a miscarriage three weeks ago and seeing Sky go from baby to girl in a second made me think of what my wife and I are missing. That coupled with seeing Lis Sladen made it depressing. On its own merits the story was fine.

My sympathies to you both man.
 
It was a fun story. Sky is good, and it's nice for them to finally admit Luke is gone. (Is that scarf really a thing UK students wear?)

The Metalkind design was impressive; shame it was invisible/slumped against a wall most of the episode!

The gag about Miss Myers's name was good.

I wanted something more emotional/character-based for the climax than Clyde moving rods, though.

Oh, and the tramp was a bit Pertwee-esque.

When are Clyde and Rani going to make out finally?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top