I've been considering getting this, but I've been reading a lot of complaints about it on other sites. A lot of people are saying that the city is boring, that there's less customisability than in SR2, and that a big chunk of the main missions are actually side missions in disguise. Overall, consensus seems to be that SR2 was better. Is this just a reaction to the hype or is it really a step down from the previous game?
There are definitely some legitimate gripes. Shaundi feels like an entirely different character, which is really jarring. And the storyline feels half as long as it should. Act 1 is pretty heavily padded with side missions masquerading as storyline missions, but that goes away pretty quickly (thank God).
If I had to sum it up, the game doesn't feel
complete -- that it's
almost there, but it needed another six months in development. Example: There's a fully fleshed out train track system running throughout Steelport, but no trains.
Of course, I'm quite aware of the fact that THQ hasn't been doing particularly well lately (reported a $92 million loss for Q2 after losing $47 million in Q1), and if we didn't get
Saints Row: The Third now, we probably never would have, but it definitely feels ... hollowed out. Most of the blame for this I lay squarely at the door of THQ, not Volition. There seems to have been quite a bit of mismanagement on THQ's part behind the scenes (development began in 2008, and the reveal of the game kept getting pushed back from 2009 to 2010 to March 2011), and from talking to some Volition developers on the Something Awful Forums, there's definitely a faint air of ... disgruntlement with THQ regarding some of the decision-making.
Now, that said, while there are definitely flaws in the game, but it's
so much fun I almost don't care.
Kanye West's "Power" playing while I parachute into a Morningstar penthouse and shoot shit up? Awesome. "Holding Out for a Hero" during the finale? Awesome. Random wrestling references that ACTUALLY MAKE SENSE IN CONTEXT? Awesome.
Killing people by punching them in the groin? Awesome. Running up and dropkicking someone straight out of their car? Awesome. Running up and smashing someone's face into the pavement, then flashing some cocky pose? Awesome.
It's not a perfect game, but it's the most fun I've had with a game all year, even more than
Arkham City (which I've played through twice). I'd still recommend it without reservation to anyone who likes sandbox games.
SR1 was the first game I got with my 360 and I thought it was okay, but not great. I'm replaying it now for the first time in almost 5 years and I'm finding it to be much more fun this time even though it's fairly basic.
Man, I tried going back to
Saints Row this past summer while I was trying to kill time after finishing
Saints Row 2 again, and it was like going from a Ferrari to a Pinto.
