• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Russell T. Davies Returns to Doctor Who as New Showrunner

I suspect that if Tennant is coming back, it's just for the 60th anniversary special, not as the star of the next series. If he does return, they're asking for trouble if it's anything other than the actual tenth Doctor, or at the very least a Curator type character that is very similar. It's what the common fan wants and Tennant playing a different role will likely be a disappointment.

I suppose a Rose/Moment type thing could work but that seems less likely for the Doctor.

I don't know what to make of these rumors. I'm pretty sure they're just fans guessing. After all, Tennant is a fan favorite who has always expressed an interest in returning. So, he's a logical guess!
 
It’s the kind of thing that might (and to an extent has) work as a very short story on a page, but not on screen.
Paul Cornell used the idea in his comic for IDW, The Girl Who Loved Doctor Who. The eleventh Doctor's TARDIS glitches, and he finds himself on our Earth, there's a little girl who's a big fan of Doctor Who, and there's a Doctor Who convention where Matt Smith is appearing...

Come to think of it, Steven Moffat also did something similar in a short story he wrote for the Lockdown project. Umpty-Umms, I think was the title.
 
Would they be playing completely made up characters, or heightened versions of themselves I wonder? I mean Tennant has already done that in staged!

No idea if there's any truth to it, but it does feel like the kinda thing RTD would do.
 
Terror of the Umpty-Umms is a bit different as the Doctor never actually appears, but is just "heard".

The plot is a troubled child in a care facility who invents a persona of being a killer cyborg so that he can suppress his upsetting emotions and rationalise acting out against the adults there (humans trying to hold him hostage, fools! They shall tremble before his might!!).

We don't find this out until well into the story though - it's written as if the character actually IS a cyborg that has assumed human guise. "The Doctor" is presented as having "tapped into the cyborg's transmissions" to talk to him, but is actually his own conscience talking him out of setting a fire at the facility - he bases the better side of his personality on the fictional character he watched in happier times.
 
Paul Cornell used the idea in his comic for IDW, The Girl Who Loved Doctor Who. The eleventh Doctor's TARDIS glitches, and he finds himself on our Earth, there's a little girl who's a big fan of Doctor Who, and there's a Doctor Who convention where Matt Smith is appearing...

Come to think of it, Steven Moffat also did something similar in a short story he wrote for the Lockdown project. Umpty-Umms, I think was the title.

There was a run of them in DWM in the eighties and nineties, and a rather nice one in one of the big name fanzines. It had the Doctor as an advisor on the TV show, which was of course his story all along, and making a rather melancholy goodbye from the edge of the field where they were shooting survival.
 
A new report on GB gives some context to those rumoured Tennant/Tate appearances


The plot is a meta thing where the newly regenerated Doctor finds a world where their adventures are chronicled like a TV show.

Tennant and Tate aren't playing themselves, but they are playing actors portraying the Tenth and Donna. This turns out to be a plot to ambush the real Doctor

Aw, John Brosnan's old annual pitch to the production office from the Tom Baker era..
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top