• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Replicator Limits and Thresholds?

AsianPotato

Cadet
Newbie
Replicators cannot create fatal poisons and objects of high complexities. However, can weapons be mass produced using Replicators?
 
I suspect that it may be able to replicate individual components or ingredients separately but at what point will it stop replicating?
 
Replicators cannot create fatal poisons and objects of high complexities.
If the replicator can make certain medications, then it should be able to produce many poisons. There could be programming restrictions, but the replicator mech itself could do the deed.
However, can weapons be mass produced using Replicators?
Don't see why not, as long as the replicator has power and materials.
 
One species deadly poison is another's after school snack.

How would the replicator know if you're ordering a 5 kilo chocolate bar to romance Troi or to kill a dog?
 
If the replicator can make certain medications, then it should be able to produce many poisons. There could be programming restrictions, but the replicator mech itself could do the deed.

Which then begs the question. Could a person with a severe allergy order something that could send them into anaphylactic shock? Are allergies still a thing in the Star Trek future?
 
In DS9, in different episodes, a phaser is replicated which automatically fires on someone, and another time a rifle is replicated with a transporter muzzle. I think a poison might have been replicated in DS9 once, or a disease, as part of a latent Cardassian security protocol, after Quark changes all the replicators in the station to generate mugs with Quark's themed branding.

As someone else pointed out, if some drugs can be replicated, then some poisons/toxins/carcinogens etc should be replicatable. Not all, because we know there are drugs and certain naturally occurring chemicals which cannot be replicated, such as a particular mineral water.
Which then begs the question. Could a person with a severe allergy order something that could send them into anaphylactic shock? Are allergies still a thing in the Star Trek future?
If I were writing Star Trek, I would have the cure for all allergies as a working assumption, at least so far as deadly or otherwise heightened reactions go. There have been some contradictory statements in regard to sneezes being all but eliminated thanks to a cure for the common cold, but later on, in another episode, someone might have got a cold. In either case, it seems that sneezes are so rare that maybe no allergies is a thing in Star Trek.

I would assume Barkley has allergies but I don't think he ever exhibited any.
 
are all replicators hooked up to some kind of permanent network? does earth seem entirely wirelessly networked at high data speeds in earth episodes? can individual units be hacked and modded? or black market isolinear chips installed or something? can you get drunk and die off replicated alcohol? or is it all synthehol? if you're in pain, order up some morphine? do coke dealers no longer go to suppliers, but go to replicator hackers? it seems likely you can make whatever, since malicious stuff has been made in them. unless it ruins the plot if such-and-such can be made
 
do big starships have industrial replicators on board? i don't remember anything being replicated of moderate size.

but if you needed to copy stuff, wouldn't it be pretty easy with a transporter? it inadvertantly makes clones often enough. store something in the pattern buffer and just keep transporting it? where did it get matter to make thomas riker?
 
do big starships have industrial replicators on board? i don't remember anything being replicated of moderate size.

but if you needed to copy stuff, wouldn't it be pretty easy with a transporter? it inadvertantly makes clones often enough. store something in the pattern buffer and just keep transporting it? where did it get matter to make thomas riker?

The Intrepid class ot VOY must have on, after all they seemingly had an endless supply of hull and shuttle plates. ;)
 
It can but I was differentiating between shuttle plates and whole shuttlecraft which seem to reproduce like tribbles on Voyager.
When Voyager builds the Delta Flyer it is built in parts so it seems reasonable the shuttles are built from replicated parts too, instead of being replicated in one go.

We don't know what an industrial replicator is specifically, but they seem powerful enough and rare enough (given, I think, just one could turn Bajor's economy around) that it seems unlikely every starship has one rather than an upsized machine shop replicater of some sort.
 
Replicators cannot create fatal poisons and objects of high complexities. However, can weapons be mass produced using Replicators?

Who is to say what is 'poison' ?
I have some weed killer that could probably kill a person if they drank it for example.

On DS9 I think they replicated a weapon that could shoot through walls.:eek:
 
General-purpose replicators in crew quarters probably have security protocols to prevent replication of certain substances or items.

Or they may simply be limited to a pre-programmed menu that does not include those harmful things in the first place. Computers can only do what they are specifically told to, after all.

If someone is resourceful enough, they may be able to work around the restrictions somehow.

Kor
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top