• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Rank your favorite Series of all time

Doctor Who
TOS
DS9
Space: Above and Beyond
Fringe
Life on Mars UK
Alias
Buffy
Angel
Merlin
Torchwood
Sarah-Jane Adventures
Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Heroes
TNG
ENT
VGR
 
You know what I think is amazing about me........? Out of the countless hours of Sci-Fi I've watched in my lifetime (I turn 40 this September) I've not seen a single episode of Dr. Who.

Apparently I need to make same time to catch some of this long-running series.
 
1. Deep Space Nine
2. Farscape
3. Life On Mars (UK)
4. LOST
5. Doctor Who
6. ST - the next Generation
7. Babylon 5
8. nu BSG
9. Heroes
10. Firefly
 
1. Deep Space Nine

Great cast, well rounded characters, and an interesting storyline that kept evolving into new territory right until the end. It's been my favorite for over a decade and will likely always remain that way.

2. Farscape

Excellent for basically all the same reasons as Deep Space Nine. Season 4 had an unfortunate tendency to get kind of gross at times and the show laughed in the face of science a little too much for its own good, but overall it was superb.

3. Chuck

It's primarily a comedy, and still running so there's no way of knowing how it will measure up in the end, but it's just so much fun that I feel I have to list it. It has already gone places I didn't expect it to, and look forward to seeing how the newly announced fourth season will play out.

4. Star Trek

It's a classic, plain and simple. The cast had tremendous chemistry, Kirk, Spock and McCoy are iconic characters for a good reason, and while the scripts were not exactly consistently great, they proved themselves capable of achieving greatness.

5. The 4400

I've only recently watched this, but it impressed me a lot. The writers were never afraid to change the story around completely at a moment's notice, yet they always managed to make it feel like an organic extension of the original premise. Very clever and concise (every season is pretty short) little show.

6. The X-Files

Though I stopped caring about the series in its 6th season, the first five years of the show hold up well. The show was at its best when it was a simply being a monster movie every week. Its stabs at serialized storytelling and mythology building are, with notable exceptions, pretty weak. Fortunately, in the early years they are easy to ignore in favor of the show's strengths.

7. Earth Final Conflict

Excepting the final season which bears no resemblance to the rest of the show, I count myself as a fan of this frequently maligned show. I love the Taelons, the general look of the show, and the majority of the revolving-door cast and characters. It got stupid at times, and the first season is still the best, but nothing is perfect.

8. Pushing Daisies

Does this count? Eh, I guess if Chuck does, so does Pushing Daisies. Very unique, colorful and witty show that was axed far too soon.

9. Firefly

I don't subscribe to the idea that Firefly is the best show to ever air anywhere, but I do enjoy it. It's a shame it wasn't given the chance to grow, but the movie Serenity is a good enough consolation prize.

10. The Middleman

Yep, another genre comedy. It was a lot of fun for all of its short twelve episode run. I didn't even know it existed until I was given the DVDs as a gift, though, so I hope it's getting enough attention out there.

11. Battlestar Galactica (new)

Yeah, I'm adding an eleventh. Why not? It's really the last show I'd add to the list anyway. BSG was a frustrating show to watch. At times it was excellent, at other times I was embarrassed to admit I was watching it. In the end, though, I am glad I watched it. That's about all I have to say about it, too.
 
You know what I think is amazing about me........? Out of the countless hours of Sci-Fi I've watched in my lifetime (I turn 40 this September) I've not seen a single episode of Dr. Who.

Apparently I need to make same time to catch some of this long-running series.
Yes, yes you do.
 
OMG I watched a lot of scifi.... :)
1 Babylon 5
2 Battlestar Galactica (2003)
3 Firefly
4 Doctor Who (2005)
5 Star Trek DS9
6 Farscape
7 Futurama
8 Stargate SG1 (I even loved s9, and some of s10!)
9 Star Trek ENT (well, season 3-4 was better than ds9, season 1-2 was worse than the worst of TNG)
10 Star Trek
11 Fringe
12 Star Trek TNG
13 Torchwood (season 1 would be just above Defying Gravity, season 3 would be above BSG...)
14 Chuck
15 Lost
16 Stargate SGU
17 Caprica
18 Alias
19 Sanctuary
20 Threshold
21 The 4400 (ended way too soon)
22 Eureka
23 FlashForward
24 Journeyman (ended way too soon)
25 Warehouse 13
26 Crusade (ended way too soon)
27 Dollhouse
28 V (2009)
29 Stargate SGA (season 3 and 4 was an abomination)
30 Terminator SCC
31 Earth: Final Conflict (I loved this one, too bad it gone to hell, don't even mention s5)
32 Defying Gravity
33 Andromeda (First season was perfect the rest got progressively worse)
34 Space Above and Beyond
35 SeaQuest
...
...
36 Heroes (except first season, which is waaaaaay better)
37 Star Trek VOY
 
1. Babylon 5
2. Life on Mars/Ashes to Ashes
3. Jeremiah
4. DS9
5. Angel
6. Battlestar Galactica (new)
7. Star Trek
8. The X Files
9. Farscape
10. Firefly
 
1. Battlestar Galactica (new) - I love the characters and the plot. My biggest complaint is that the last two seasons had too little humor. It's the best drama series I've ever watched.
2. TNG
3. ENT - I've never gotten the hate for it. Even the first two seasons were good in my opinion. S4 is exactly what the whole series should have been as a prequel and the Xindi arc is brilliant.
4. Firefly - Why did it have to be cancelled so soon?
5. Babylon 5 - I've only watched the first season and it took me some time to start liking it. I really like the story arc at this point but there are too many standalone episodes in the first season for my taste. I have a feeling that the series is going to get much better and that's why I'm putting it on this list.
 
1. Star Trek The Next Generation- Really the television series that introduced me to the concept of mainstream science fiction and made me fall in love with this franchise that has come to mean so much to me for many personal reasons.

2. Doctor Who- Epic 'nuff said.
3. Babylon 5- Was hooked from the pilot episode and made me fall in love with episodic arc based science fiction if that makes sense.
4. Battlestar Galactica (New)- Epic
5. Space:Above and Beyond
6. Smallville
7. Batman the Animated Series
8. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
9. Angel
10.Stargate SG-1

These are my top ten.
 
1) nuBSG
2) Firefly


3) TNG
4) TOS
5) DS9

6) nuOuter Limits
7) Supernatural
8) Futurama
9) Caprica
10) Dollhouse

(space for emphasis)
 
My list:


1. [highlight]Doctor Who[/highlight]. Never thought some odd-named British import that showed up late one Sunday night on my local PBS station would turn out to be my favorite sci-fi--correction, favorite television--series of all time. I was lucky enough to have a PBS station that really treated their Doctor Who fans well and aired every available story from the First through Seventh Doctors. This show had its hooks in me so bad that I didn't realize that some of my mannerisms come across as "Doctorish" at times. With the new Eleventh Doctor in play this year, I can still say that I haven't met a Doctor I haven't liked.

2. Robotech. The show that truly introduced me to the kind of deeper stories and characterization that was really possible in anime. While my first exposure to anime where with shows like Speed Racer, Battle of the Planets, and Voltron--Robotech was the game changer abd my perception about anime was never the same again, and it launched me into other various anime shows.

3. Star Trek (all of it). Rather than list each series separately, I'll just lump them in all together. While there are definitely some Trek shows I like much more than others, I can't deny that Trek in general is inescapable for me. TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY, and even my least favorite series ENT all have their great points and they still aspire towards a hopeful future where Humanity has become united and people are judged by what they do rather than by what they are.
 
1. Thunderbirds
2. Captain Scarlet and the Mysterons
3. UFO
4. Space:1999
5. Star Trek-TOS
6. Battlestar Galactica (classic)
7. Star Trek-TNG
8. Star Trek-DS9
9. Space: Above and Beyond
10. Babylon 5
11. Star Trek-Voyager
12. Star Trek-Enterprise
13. nuBattlestar Galactica

Cheers.
 
1. Star Trek: The Next Generation
2. The X-Files
3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer
4. Firefly
5. Space: Above and Beyond
6. Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
7. Star Trek
8. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
9. Angel
10. Planet of the Apes (70s tv series)
 
1. "Batman: The Animated Series" - The only show I loved during childhood that I love just as much (and maybe a little more) as an adult. It has its fair share of awful, horribly corny episodes, but the best episodes are transcendent...right up there with the best live action movies and TV series I've seen.

2. "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" - It seems every generation has a show that carries them through adolescence as they relate to its teenage characters ("Dawson's Creek, "Beverley Hills 90210", etc.) and this is mine. Most of all I love how insightfully its characters and their lives reflect the high school and university experience (with a few major exceptions, like a lecturer yelling at and kicking a student out of a university class for talking. Ridiculous! They simply wouldn't care that much!) :angryrazz:

3. "Star Trek: The Next Generation" - Something I liked as a kid that I like exponentially better as an adult. Contrary to the beliefs of many, I believe it has aged beautifully, like a fine wine.

4. "The X-Files" - It went on too long, but I can forgive its mediocre seasons and episodes because the best episodes and seasons were more mind blowingly atmospheric, suspenseful, and captivating than most shows I've ever seen. Like "Batman: The Animated Series", its finest episodes were beautifully cinematic...superior in their significantly shorter running times to many science fiction films I've seen.

5. "Xena: Warrior Princess" - Perhaps the most frustratingly inconsistent show I like, with its constant shifting between painfully melodramatic serious shows, painfully broad slapstick comedies, genuinely moving and subtle dramatic episodes, and heartwarming, uplifting, sweet, and clever comedies.

6. "Star Trek: Deep Space Nine" - I have only been watching this show for two years and I already love it as much as shows I've loved for my whole life. Unfortunately, its legacy is severely tainted by a few unbelievably terrible episodes, characterizations, and story arcs that the writers should been smart enough not to include. :(

7. "X-Men" - I just revisited this for the first time since childhood and I'm surprised by how well it holds up. It is surprisingly sophisticated for a Saturday morning cartoon show, with its serialized storytelling and top notch voice acting. There are some cheesy story lines, performances, and episodes (as one would expect with this kind of show), but the high points are truly magnificent. John Colicos as Apocalypse is the ultimate scenery DEVOURING villain. His epically over-the-top deliciously, gloriously, majestically evil dialogue cracks me up so hard. :lol:

8. "Futurama" - I find a lot of the episodes in this serious middling, but the greatest episodes are at levels of originality and cleverness that are unparalleled and even though it's animated, its sentimental moments are some of the most moving I've ever experienced in any media (and no, I'm not thinking of the overrated and terrible maudlin trash that is "Jurassic Bark").

9. "Star Trek" - It's still pretty new to me as I've only been watching since 2008 and haven't seen all the episodes yet. It will likely move up on my list.

10. "Batman" (1966) - More comedy than science fiction, but someone else listed it, so I will too. I've been re watching this for the first time since childhood and am really impressed by how much smarter and wittier it is than I remembered. I especially appreciate how cool the sets are, the creativity of The Riddler's riddles (as well as the brilliance of Frank Gorshin's performance), the ingenuity of Catwoman's schemes, and Julie Newmar's absolutely mesmerizing mugging and meowing. :drool:

I like the new "Battlestar Galactica" a lot and "FireFly" too, but certain episodes of "Firefly" were so boring to me that watching them was suffering, and I've only watched all of BSG once. I have never seen a single episode of "Dr. Who" or "Babylon 5". What channels were these shows on anyway?
 
Last edited:
II have never seen a single episode of "Dr. Who" or "Babylon 5". What channels were these shows on anyway?

Ok, based on what your top 10 shows are you seriously need to rent/buy/download all of Babylon 5 and at least the "In The Beginning" movie and watch it straight through. If it doesn't end up in your top 5, I'd be shocked.

(and I'm incredibly jealous you get to experience that series for the first time ever..........)
 
1. Doctor Who (10th Doctor Era) My favourite series and favourite Doctor, i could rewatch all but 1 episode multiple times without getting bored.

2. Stargate Atlantis - Enjoyed every single second of it. It's not perfect, but the cast- especially David Hewlett - make the series excel beyond it's occasional dodgy episode.

3. Stargate SG-1 - Brilliant series that i never expected to like. I found Stargate the movie to be a great idea executed poorly resulting in a exceedingly dull film. So i was pleasantly surprised when SG-1 proved to be such an enjoyable series.

4. Torchwood - OK i admit series one wasn't that great, apparently RTD's idea of a darker companion piece to Doctor Who was sex aliens and the occasional f-bomb. But despite its iffy beginnings, Torchwood has improved dramatically as its continued, and Children of Earth is one of the best pieces of Sci-fi television ever produced.

5. Stargate Universe - not a popular choice but i really like the show so far. It's a nice change of pace from the previous Stargate shows, but is still firmly rooted in the settings mythology.

6. Firefly - Joss Whedons best work, an absolute masterpiece of a series that would place higher on my list if only there were more of it.

7. Doctor Who (11th Doctor Era) - I like where Moffat is going with the new series and Doctor, but 11 isn't anywhere close to being as great as 10.

8. Babylon 5 - Another masterpiece as far as i'm concerned. Series 2 of Babylon 5 was the first time i'd gotten into a tv series that wasn't Star Trek and i really have it to thank for expanding my sci-fi horizons beyond Trek.

9. Crusade - I wish we could have seen Crusade without network interference. Despite a plethora of idiotic network suggestions, Crusade is still one of my favourite series and one i rewatch quite often.

10. Invasion Earth - A massively underrated series, the mini-series gripped me from start to finish. The N-D's were truly alien and terrifying, i still have the occasional nightmare involving them. I just wish it were easier to get a hold of, i'm relying on a rapidly decaying VHS recording of the original broadcasts.
 
I have never seen a single episode of "Dr. Who" or "Babylon 5". What channels were these shows on anyway?

I'm amazed! You have a lot of excellent TV to look forward to. Doctor Who's current season is on BBC America assuming you're in the US; Space if you're in Canada, while older episodes (the series is in its 31st season) often turn up on PBS and there are s*itloads of DVDs. B5 has been off the air for a decade, so unless there's a cable channel showing reruns somewhere, your best bet is DVD as well. Get thee to Netflix!

Now for my list:

1. The Prisoner (original). Nothing has topped it, and it remains topical and intriguing 40 years later.
2. Doctor Who. I'd rank it here even if nothing came before 2005. It consistently outstrips any SF being made Stateside. Add in the 26 years of classic series, and you have a remarkable achievement.
3. Star Trek Deep Space Nine. Probably the more consistent of the Trek series in terms of storytelling and performances.
4. The Twilight Zone (original). Each episode is a master's class on SF/F short story writing.
5. Max Headroom. A series that was very much ahead of its time. I think its upcoming DVD release will be a revelation in terms of how it predicted a lot of what we're seeing today.
6. Twin Peaks (first season only). Still the scariest TV series ever produced, hands down.
7. Buck Rogers in the 25th Century. Yeah, it had its stumbles, but it still had a great retro feel, Erin Gray in a catsuit, and its much-maligned second season was actually a lot better than I remembered.
8. Battlestar Galactica (new version). Its unrelenting darkness prevents it from ranking higher, but they still did a hell of a job.
9. UFO. Another ahead-of-its-time series. Ignore the green wigs and there's some great storytelling in this Gerry Anderson show.
10. Torchwood. It's stumbled on occasion, but when it scores, like it did with Children of Earth, it outshines everything, including Doctor Who.

Other shows falling just out of the Top 10: The Six Million Dollar Man, The Bionic Woman, The Tick (live action), Alias, Star Trek: Enterprise, Star Trek TOS, Star Trek: The Next Generation (seasons 3-7 only), Dead Like Me, Wonderfalls. And of course I'm only listing SF/F shows, so other shows like All in the Family, Deadwood, etc. aren't included.

Alex
 
Not including Star trek (Which would take top spot)

1. BSG (Nu)
2. The X-files
3. B5
4. Fringe
5. Andromeda
6. V (Oringial)
7. Heroes


Haven't seen much of these yet but:
Caprica
Flashforward (I know it's cancelled but it was good and showed promise)
V (New)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top