Rank the Trek doctors...

[Xhiandra]

As doctors, only using the main ones:
- EMH
- Bashir
- Crusher
- Phlox
- "He's dead, Jim"

As interesting characters:
- Phlox
- EMH
- Bashir
- Crusher
- McCoy

Most importantly, though, the "would enjoy having a round of drinks with" factor:
- Crusher
- Phlox
- McCoy
- Bashir
- No, not the EMH.

 

[Prax]

Which Doctor is the most likely to send you to the Counsellor?

And which Doctor is the biggest champion of Psychiatry?

Which Doctor is the most unqualified to give Psychiatric advice?

 

[WarpTenLizard]

In terms of who I like as a character....

1.) EMH
2.) McCoy
3.) Beverly Crusher
4.) New movie version McCoy
5.) Julian Bashir
6.) Dr. Lucian ("Renegades")
7.) Dr. Lewis Zimmerman
8.) Dr. Sellar (Or Selar or however it's spelled...)
9.) Any doctor who isn't a racist b*tch and doesn't have a butt crack on his forehead

 

[Amaris]

Personal Favorites (in order from most to least):

1. McCoy (TOS)
2. The EMH (VOY)
3. Pulaski (TNG)
4. Phlox (ENT)
5. Crusher (TNG)
6. Bashir (DS9)

It might seem odd that while being a Niner, Bashir isn't my favorite doctor, but while I love the actor, the character of Dr. Bashir often grated on my nerves.

 

[Vger23]

Which Doctor is the most likely to send you to the Counsellor?

And which Doctor is the biggest champion of Psychiatry?

Which Doctor is the most unqualified to give Psychiatric advice?

?

 

[Relayer1]

1. Dr. McCoy
2. Dr. Bashir
3. EMH
4. Dr. Phlox
5. Dr. Crusher
6. Dr. Selar
7. Dr. Chapel
8. Dr. Boyce
9. Dr. M'Benga
10. Dr Culber
11. Dr. Piper
12. Dr. Pulaski

 

[Martok91189]

Bashir
EMH
Phlox
McCoy
Pulaski
Crusher

 

[TrekNut87]

Based on who I feel I could stand the most
1. Kelvin McCoy
2. Bashir
3. EMH
4. Bones
5. Crusher
6. Culber
7. Phlox
8. Pulaski

I find Phlox and Pulaski to be equally annoying, but given that I hated Pulaski when I first watched TNG, I put her last.

 

[Tenacity]

Which Doctor is the most unqualified to give Psychiatric advice?

"Doctor" Suder?

9.) Any doctor who isn't a racist b*tch and doesn't have a butt crack on his forehead

Did you have anyone in particular in mind?

 

[WarpTenLizard]

"Doctor" Suder?Did you have anyone in particular in mind?

Sorry if you're a Pulaski fan. I can't stand her.

 

[Prax]

Is Pulaski racist?

 

[Tenacity]

She had a problem with Data, does that make her a "machinist?"

 

[STEPhon IT]

McCoy
Boyce
M'Benga
Bashir -- before he was retconned into a genetic superman.

 

[Vger23]

She's a rabid anti-positronicite

She had a problem with Data, does that make her a "machinist?"

 

[STEPhon IT]

Which Doctor is the most likely to send you to the Counsellor?

Crusher, Pulaski, Bashir, and the EMH since they were in an era where they lacked the qualification.

And which Doctor is the biggest champion of Psychiatry?

Doctor McCoy, Boyce, & M'Benga

Which Doctor is the most unqualified to give Psychiatric advice?

Phlox... maybe???

 

[auntiehill]

Bashir
Crusher
McCoy
Phlox
Pulaski
EMH

 

[JirinPanthosa]

If the question is who I’d like to hang out with Bashir wins by a landslide. I could invite him to my holosuite fantasies.

 

[Voth commando1]

Which Doctor is the most likely to send you to the Counsellor?

And which Doctor is the biggest champion of Psychiatry?

Which Doctor is the most unqualified to give Psychiatric advice?

That's an interesting series of questions.

1. Probably Crusher given she was friends with Troi she'd feel very comfortable about sending you to the counsellor if she felt you needed it.

2. That's a tough one I'd say a tie between Bones and the EMH.

3. Probably Bashir as that didn't seem to be his specialty.