• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Private Benjamin being remade.....

Actually, if you had just written the first half of the post, I would have suggested making it in 3D to get around your criticism.

Ha!

But the leap from silent to "real" film is far greater than from 2D to 3D.

Still, if the issue is about originality of Hollywood, the remake is still a remake (although they're both ripping off a book, but oh well).
 
A Star Is Born has been made three times and a fourth version with Beyonce Knowles is scheduled for 2012.

The first version was released in 1937, in full sound (of course) and Technicolor. It was very highly regarded. Despite that, the 1954 remake with Judy Garland is the best known and received the most Academy Awards and award nominations of the three.
 
Why? Private Benjamin isn't brilliant and it was made a long time ago.

The "remake craze" just gave us a superior version of True Grit after all.

Given the current situation of our armed forces this ought to be quite...different. Faris is a good choice...who'll play the part Eileen Brennan did, though?

Jane Lynch, of course!:)


As much as really didn't like that movie or the series, Jane Lynch would be perfect in that role.
 
I don't have a problem with some remakes...but they're also remaking The Bodyguard and Soapdish...both from 1991. That's a little soon.
A Song Is Born (1948), starring Danny Kaye and Virginia Mayo, was a remake of Ball of Fire from 7 years earlier.

West of Zanzibar, a 1928 silent starring Lon Chaney, was remade as Kongo in 1931 with Walter Huston.

But the leap from silent to “real” film is far greater than from 2D to 3D.
“Real” film? WTF?? Are films from the pre-sound era somehow not “real”? Norma Desmond would disagree!

soapdish was a tv series right?

You may be thinking of Soap.

A Star Is Born has been made three times and a fourth version with Beyonce Knowles is scheduled for 2012.
Good Lord, please spare us. Didn’t Barbra Streisand ruin that story for all time with her beyond-dreadful 1976 version?
 
You can't remake a legendary comedy like Private Benjamin! What's next, new versions of such iconic cinema classics as Summer School, The Toy, Deal of the Century, Turner & Hooch, and dare I say it, Ice Pirates? Where will it end, Hollywood? Where will it end?

Short of getting Kate Hudson (which might seem too derivative) Anna Faris is a perfect choice to play the Goldie Hawn role, both looks and personality wise. Hopefully her resemblance to Hawn was why they chose her and not because they're aiming for Scary Movie/House Bunny levels of comedy.
 
Anna Faris is the new Goldie, IMHO.

At this stage, I really couldn't care about the proposed remake. If it's great or even good, then well and good, I'll give it a viewing. If it's crap, well, no-one's raped my childhood and it's not like the original is an untouchable classic to begin with.
 
I'm not against remakes, persay, but remakes of movies from the 70s and 80s just seem too "too soon" for my tastes.. Superior product or not, it just seems wrong...

Remaking movies from decades ago, I have no problem with... Can't really explain it..
 
Why? Private Benjamin isn't brilliant and it was made a long time ago.

The "remake craze" just gave us a superior version of True Grit after all.

Given the current situation of our armed forces this ought to be quite...different. Faris is a good choice...who'll play the part Eileen Brennan did, though?

Jane Lynch, of course!:)


As much as really didn't like that movie or the series, Jane Lynch would be perfect in that role.

As for the movie and series, I thought the movie was great, the series not so much, considering they had to get a nobody to play Goldie's role.
 
I've been told a number of times that Goldie Hawn babysat me for a couple of hours one evening in 1957 or '58. I of course have no recollection or way of corroborating that, nor any reason to doubt it...nor have I any idea how close it gets me to Kevin Bacon.
 
Oh for the love of GOD, another remake?! I'm so sick of Hollywood remaking movies (sometimes mediocre ones at that). Doesn't anyone out there have an original idea anymore, or has the creative well run dry in LaLa Land? Pathetic.
 
As for the movie and series, I thought the movie was great, the series not so much, considering they had to get a nobody to play Goldie's role.

It seems like that now, but at the time Lorna Patterson was considered something of an up-and-comer after her role in Airplane!

--Justin
 
^ That's what they should be doing, remaking bad movies into good ones, instead of giving us Touch of Evil with Ashton Kutcher and Chris Klein.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top