• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers 'Obi-Wan Kenobi' series [Spoiler Discussion]

Bringing it back to Kenobi; say what you will about some of the technical limitations that it ran up against, they still did a good job of directly bridging the two trilogies in terms of style and tone. It has both that sense of grand melodrama of the PT, and the feisty scrappiness of the OT. So again; points for coherence.
I will agree on this point.
 
I remain a little surprised that Kenobi doesn't have a better reputation. Yes, there was some BS in it. But when it was good it was very good.

On the other hand, its usage of the Inquisitors was inexplicably pitiful. I know someone who gave up after the first episode. He's typically vocal about disliking projects with weak villains, and in this case I couldn't disagree.
 
They did more in Rebels. I think the only time Fifth Brother did anything with the Force in Kenobi was that time he Force-TKed Reva. The Grand Inquisitor killed Flea, not exactly an impressive feat, but didn't do much else that we saw. I don't remember Fourth Sister doing anything at all other than barking orders at some subordinates. With Reva as the lone exception, they didn't even get in lightsaber battles!
 
They did more in Rebels. I think the only time Fifth Brother did anything with the Force in Kenobi was that time he Force-TKed Reva. The Grand Inquisitor killed Flea, not exactly an impressive feat, but didn't do much else that we saw. I don't remember Fourth Sister doing anything at all other than barking orders at some subordinates. With Reva as the lone exception, they didn't even get in lightsaber battles!
The lightsaber battles with them in Rebels were not a high point.

They felt like they were barking orders, intimidating non Force users, and Imperial power plays.
 
At least in Rebels two of them working together used the Force to hold back a ship from taking off. In Kenobi they mostly just stood around.
 
At least in Rebels two of them working together used the Force to hold back a ship from taking off. In Kenobi they mostly just stood around.
In Kenobi they lacked uniformity. They were infighting rather than cooperating.

So, perhaps they were not "identical" as to their portray in Rebels but felt about as useful.
and I’d like to forget them turning into lightsaber-powered helicopters.
I would love to forget that.
 
ETA: One of the minor details to come out of the SDCC publishing panel caught my eye, courtesy of the upcoming 'Dawn of Rebellion' visual guide; that homeless clone Ben ran across on Daiyu has been given a name: Nax. That's actually an existing character from the Clone Wars movie novelization, which is interesting in and of itself since I gather that one is a little controversial for taking liberties with the script, which given it was written by Traviss doesn't sound all that surprising. Anyway, we can now imagine that he's one of the nameless troopers on Christophsis, Teth & Umbara.
It just occurred to me.

Seeing Owen and Beru torched in A New Hope was dark, but imagine seeing that right after seeing the two of them fight off Reva and barely get lucky to have Luke's life spared.
Yeah, anyone doing a blind chronological watch through is in for a wild ride.
 
Last edited:
It just occurred to me.

Seeing Owen and Beru torched in A New Hope was dark, but imagine seeing that right after seeing the two of them fight off Reva and barely get lucky to have Luke's life spared.
Luke only survived because of his plot armor.

You had one job, Obi-Wan. :rolleyes:
 
It just occurred to me.

Seeing Owen and Beru torched in A New Hope was dark, but imagine seeing that right after seeing the two of them fight off Reva and barely get lucky to have Luke's life spared.

It also tells me Owen and Beru put up a helluva fight before finally going down and becoming charred corpses. :)
 
Oh hey look, I found Nax!
yLHj6jt.png

And I see what they meant by: "taking liberties with the script."
I thought this was a joke, then I googled and...

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

FFS, what the fuck were they thinking?
My only way of coping with this silliness is to suppose that Malachor has lower than usual gravity and a thicker than usual atmosphere, and that they're mostly just doing long jumps with the force, using the sabres as stabilisers for gliding rather than propulsion. It's not a very good way to cope with it, but it's better than "go-go-gadget Inqusicopter!"
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top