• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers 'Obi-Wan Kenobi' series [Spoiler Discussion]

Has that fan-edit been released yet?

I think there were two actually, I saw one that was edited it down to a two hour movie, and another that was redoing a lot of the effects and so on, making edits. Like making the Grand Inquisitor look more like he did in Rebels, etc.

Unless I’m mistaken and they’re both the same thing
 
Has that fan-edit been released yet?

I think there were two actually, I saw one that was edited it down to a two hour movie, and another that was redoing a lot of the effects and so on, making edits. Like making the Grand Inquisitor look more like he did in Rebels, etc.

Unless I’m mistaken and they’re both the same thing
Who cares? That kind of thing almost always comes from a petty petulant place, and is rarely executed well.
 
I enjoyed the show a tonne, just curious to look at it is all :shrug: Trailer looked interesting
The one I caught a glimpse of made GI's head look horrendous. YMMV.

Plus like I said a lot of these "I fixed it" type fan edits tend to be motivated by an unearned sense of smugness that I find repulsive.
 
Most fan edits of theatrical films suck. I can go the rest of my life and not care about the announcement of a new fan edit hitting YouTube.
 
Has that fan-edit been released yet?

I think there were two actually, I saw one that was edited it down to a two hour movie, and another that was redoing a lot of the effects and so on, making edits. Like making the Grand Inquisitor look more like he did in Rebels, etc.

Unless I’m mistaken and they’re both the same thing
There are two edits going around, the Patterson cut, and I can't remember the name of the one you alluded to. I don't believe it has been released yet. Patterson cut of Obi-Wan is decent.
 
There are two edits going around, the Patterson cut, and I can't remember the name of the one you alluded to. I don't believe it has been released yet. Patterson cut of Obi-Wan is decent.

I watched the Patterson cut a couple weeks ago and it makes a very watchable movie out of a very questionable series.
 
I seem to remember a fan-edit that turned Star Trek V into a TV episode length show that more or less seemed like a normal episode of Star Trek, rather than Shatner's film that is fairly panned.
 
The fan edit of the prequel trilogy is also generally well regarded. I’m not sure I’ve seen it (maybe?).
Was that Andywan who did that one? Shoot I can't remember who did it but I know there was one fairly well regarded.

And I enjoy fan edits because to my mind it shows off good scenes. If a scene is good, then I find the show is still good regardless of the edit. And, yes I know that videographers and editors are pulling their hair out at such a suggestion. Just my experience.
 
Why would the prequel trilogy need an edit?
The PixelJoker version isn’t just an edit. It’s a radical reimagining of the story. Using elements from the EU Kenobi novel and playing more into his mental state.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top