I've taken time to properly digest the new design and I still love it. The first word that came to my mind was "glorious", and I still think so. There's just so many things about this set to like! It's been designed very well froma production standpoint, to look bigger than it actually is, with plenty of layers, nooks and cranies to make it interesting. Additionally, it has plenty of classic series nods, and lots of what I think are natural evolutions from things we knew of the previous sets. To wit:
IRREGULAR DESIGN - Only the TVM and 9-10 consoles made a real attempt at being a symmetrical shape, and even the TVM only did so in an absctract fashion (with large shadowed walls around a symmetrical console and superstructure). Here we have a mishmash of walls in an almost triangular fashion, with doors and stairs leading off in odd directions. Escher has been referenced on this thread before, and that is very evident. Even the console itself is symmetrical only in that it has six sides, but each panel looks different in size and height.
DIFFERENT WALLS - The 60s console room set had photographic blow-ups for some of its walls. This is brought into the new set in grand fashion, with at LEAST two different wall designs, not including the floor and ceiling. While it was distracting at times to see a large photograph in the back of the old sets, it's almost welcome here to make the set look less regular and bigger as well.
DOORS - If not a REAL door, you'll notice that part of one wall almost looks pushed up and out of the way of the exterior police box door. While I highly doubt the set will have tha wall piece move, it's a nice nod to the fact that we used to have the walls of the old TARDIS open up before you exited through a pair of wooden doors. It's also worth noting that the set doesn't have any internal doors leading off; this maintains a more alien feel to the TARDIS than having a fairly nondescript hinged door.
I can't wait to see where all those stairs go! An earlier post wondered why there were two sets of stairs leading down and off to one side... It looks like one leads off to a lower portal like the one opposite that leads up, and the one with the shallower steps seems to take a turn to lead to the lower level. Moreover, it's probably a cheap way for the show's cast and crew to get onto the set's main level from the floor of the studio.
This leads to my one criticism of this set, which is that it is STILL not a full 360-degree set. As with the previous set, this one is not a fully "closed" set, and seems to incorporate a large section of wall that simply isn't there. This facilitates the production crew having a large gap to place all their cameras and microphones and such (in fact, I'm reasonably certain that the slots in the platform for the missing safety rails may also allow hooking in extensions to the platform for more people to stand on). All the shots we've seen, including the one with the Doctor suspended underneath the main platform, are shot from the missing gap in the set.
The thing is, the set this time is so irregular that they may not be able to "cheat" by using a different wall fo the set to represent the missing walls (as they did recently in the Sarah Jane Adventures crossover last year as well as Tennant's regeneration scene). I could be wrong, and they in fact do have a "wild" wall that they can close off the set with, but somehow I doubt it. Instead, they did a great trick by offsetting the exterior door, which will give them many more camera angle options for entering and exiting the TARDIS than the "pan right" technique that has already been mentioned.
Regardless, I can't wait to see this set in action. I do hope that this thing will take its place as one of the most unique console sets in the series history, along with the TVM and Secondary sets. The previous set was great for its time and for the setup of the series concept, but had numerous faults that became only more obvious as the show went on. Here, we have a very complex set that will take some time for the series to explore with its cameras.
Five years ago, a production crew member suggested that the last set was the Doctor's patched up 1970s VW minivan, all rusty and held together with bailing wire and duct tape... If that's the case, then this one is his restored 1950s Chevy, complete with hot rod fins and dice in the mirror. You can tell it's been through a lot, but damned if it hasn't been made to look awesome again, under the hand of a new guy who cares an awful lot about his ride.
Mark