• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

My theory on why Kes wasn't a more beloved character. Also opinion on Lien. post-"Voyager."

It was either the Borg makeup or the silver catsuit.

The Borg mask folded under the collar of the full suit. Not a big deal, except Ryan wasn't measured for the outfit with the 'extra skin' on.

So when fully done up, her threat was being compressed by the mask and the collar.
 
maybe not make her so robotic in how she deals with people.

She'd been a drone for eighteen years. The other ex-Borg woman in Unity and the Bajoran ex-Borg woman in Survival Instinct both had been assimilated as adults and had been drones only for a few years. Seven had been assimilated as a young child and had been a drone for the vast majority of her life. Of course, she's not going to have an "everybody else" kind of a personality and that's exactly what made her unique as a character. It wouldn't have been believable for her not to have had a "robotic" manner. She'd have been boring if she'd been just like "everybody else".
 
And Jeri Ryan is sexy. It's not like they needed to put her in a skin tight uniform for her to be sexy.
So true. It's not like she looks bad in a standard Starfleet uniform:
Anna_Jameson.jpg
 
I'll give Seven this though: at least the writers had freedom in choosing her outfits, as she wasn't part of Starfleet and something of an unique case- even if I happened to not like the choices made. For Deanna, there was no such excuse- she simply should have worn the Starfleet uniform.
 
I'll give Seven this though: at least the writers had freedom in choosing her outfits, as she wasn't part of Starfleet and something of an unique case- even if I happened to not like the choices made. For Deanna, there was no such excuse- she simply should have worn the Starfleet uniform.
Yeah, the clothes she wore gave the impression that she was a civilian employee, rather than a bona-fide member of the crew.
 
Kes wore catsuits too
Well, someone in charge was upviously obsessed with women in catsuits.

However, I must state that Kes's catsuit (which was a ridiculous idea) wasn't as "sexy" as Seven's, Troi's and T'Pol's catsuits.
Neither was Kira's.
 
Yeah, the clothes she wore gave the impression that she was a civilian employee, rather than a bona-fide member of the crew.
I just think it made her stand out too much as not being a part of the crew. I think, as they experimented with more colors and designs, it got better, but initially, it was a strange look.
 
Well, someone in charge was upviously obsessed with women in catsuits.

However, I must state that Kes's catsuit (which was a ridiculous idea) wasn't as "sexy" as Seven's, Troi's and T'Pol's catsuits.
Neither was Kira's.
Sex had always been a part of star trek back to the original series. They didn't have catsuits but they just showed lots of skin

sexy-costumes.png
star-trek-womens-costume.jpg


A catsuit seems pretty conservative next to some of the original series outfits
 
I'll give Seven this though: at least the writers had freedom in choosing her outfits, as she wasn't part of Starfleet and something of an unique case- even if I happened to not like the choices made. For Deanna, there was no such excuse- she simply should have worn the Starfleet uniform.
I agree with that. I never understood why Troi was not in uniform.
 
Sex had always been a part of star trek back to the original series. They didn't have catsuits but they just showed lots of skin

sexy-costumes.png
star-trek-womens-costume.jpg


A catsuit seems pretty conservative next to some of the original series outfits
Well, we had the beautiful ladies in Neelix's program too.

By the way, which one of the beautiful ladies in the picture above became a main character in TOS?
 
What's a main character matter if they show up in every episode? Anyways, here's one:
ZrHbbBb.jpg

And Uhura actually wears a longer skirt in the Mirror Universe!
Do8s1Ev.jpg
 
She'd been a drone for eighteen years. The other ex-Borg woman in Unity and the Bajoran ex-Borg woman in Survival Instinct both had been assimilated as adults and had been drones only for a few years. Seven had been assimilated as a young child and had been a drone for the vast majority of her life. Of course, she's not going to have an "everybody else" kind of a personality and that's exactly what made her unique as a character. It wouldn't have been believable for her not to have had a "robotic" manner. She'd have been boring if she'd been just like "everybody else".
The thing is the writers didn't have to give her the same backstory when creating the character. Their is no reason they couldn't create a more emotional ex-Borg if they wanted to.
I mean I don't hate what they did for the most part I am just saying that the sexual allure was a huge thing that went into creating the character from both personality and catsuit.
I think we can all agree at least on one thing even if we don't mind catsuits is that the silver one was beyond absurd. The future ones were at least a little more subtle but with the silver one they could have had her walking around all naked and it would have been more subtle than that version.
Jason
 
I'll agree that those TOS outfits can be seen as being as least as "provocative" as the outfits of 7.

Then again, I don't know what public reaction was back in the 60's in the U.S. , but I'd imagine that had they been tried in the 90's in VOY (or DS9), they would have caused the same type of reactions that 7 got.
 
The thing is the writers didn't have to give her the same backstory when creating the character. Their is no reason they couldn't create a more emotional ex-Borg if they wanted to.
I mean I don't hate what they did for the most part I am just saying that the sexual allure was a huge thing that went into creating the character from both personality and catsuit.
I think we can all agree at least on one thing even if we don't mind catsuits is that the silver one was beyond absurd. The future ones were at least a little more subtle but with the silver one they could have had her walking around all naked and it would have been more subtle than that version.
Jason
Finding her personality "sexual" is your own interpretation, which you admitted, and gives me the impression that you've only seen the "trailers."
 
Maybe all female characters on Voyager should have had catsuits and/or miniskirts already from the start. That would have solved all problems.

Braga would have loved it, that would definitely have attracted more male teenage viewers which had raised the ratings and then it would have been more money for Berman to count.

And Jeri Taylor could have come up with a story about the responsible for that dress code having a problem or issue with his/her father!
:lol:
 
I'll agree that those TOS outfits can be seen as being as least as "provocative" as the outfits of 7.

Then again, I don't know what public reaction was back in the 60's in the U.S. , but I'd imagine that had they been tried in the 90's in VOY (or DS9), they would have caused the same type of reactions that 7 got.
I read, somewhere, that NIchelle didn't mind the skirt because she had a similar wardrobe at home, so it didn't strike her as odd. Compare that the to Kelvin universe and Zoe struggling with her own personal comfort in wearing that skirt, and I think there might be some other considerations, and not just the blanket of TOS screencaps that are being presented.

It bothered me in TOS, it bothered me in TNG, it bothered me in DS9, it bothered me in VOY, in ENT and in Abrams Trek.

Maybe all female characters on Voyager should have had catsuits and/or miniskirts already from the start. That would have solved all problems.

Braga would have loved it, that would definitely have attracted more male teenage viewers which had raised the ratings and then it would have been more money for Berman to count.

And Jeri Taylor could have come up with a story about the responsible for that dress code having a problem or issue with his/her father!
:lol:
I agree completely.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top