IDK, Guardians sounds more like a hockey name, if that sort of thing is quantifiable in that way.
Cleveland Baseball Club would have been better
I was talking to someone about the swing/no swing and was really surprised that there isn't even a rule for it in the MLB. It's ridiculous to leave anything up to the judgement of these umps. They might as well just flip a coin.
Most announcers refer to the "front edge of the plate" like that's the deciding factor, but I've always thought that no corner umpire can realistically make that call. Bat crossing the foul line would be a better criteria.
Cleveland Baseball Club would have been better

I was talking to someone about the swing/no swing and was really surprised that there isn't even a rule for it in the MLB. It's ridiculous to leave anything up to the judgement of these umps. They might as well just flip a coin.
Most announcers refer to the "front edge of the plate" like that's the deciding factor, but I've always thought that no corner umpire can realistically make that call. Bat crossing the foul line would be a better criteria.
The Major League Baseball rulebook does not contain an official definition for a checked swing, but defines a swing as "an attempt to strike at the ball". It is the decision of the umpire as to whether an attempt was made or not. Generally, factors such as whether the bat passes the front of the plate or the batter pulls their wrists back are considered in the ruling. Some umpires prefer to use the "breaking the wrists" criterion as the method to decide a checked swing: if the wrists "rolled over", a swing occurred.
Last edited: