What I'm gathering from these threads is that some people believe that sexual orientation is about actions. You can't choose to stop being black, but you can choose not to act on your homosexual urges. Race is involuntary, while sexuality is not.
Actually, there are two distinct views here:
Both say "homosexuality is a choice."
However, KT and Brent mean two different things by that.
KT is of the stripe that affirms that homosexual orientation itself is a choice. That's a direct contradiction to the literature of Exodus International itself, and has been pointed out to him repeatedly. He believes this because his theology denies a few other items on the menu that essentially lead to the idea that our desires are chosen. That's a rather extreme version of libertarian action theory.
Brent says that when Christians say "homosexuality is a choice" he's referring to homosexual behavior only. Of course this contradicts Exodus insofar as Exodus is targeting people like KT, and Brent is actually affirming the definition of homosexual behavior qua behavior.
Both can't seem to draw a distinction between orientation and behavior very well, although of the two Brent is, I think, more amenable.
On that level, he's correct, though some of you may dislike it. Churches that affirm the immorality of homosexual behavior should be free to exclude such persons from their membership but not their attendance (membership and attendance are not the same thing) for the same reason they should be able to exclude persons who are persistent liars, etc. from membership but not attendance.Personally, I don't have a problem with Brent's position in that regard.
The problem there is that most churches will carry on a witch hunt against the homosexual but the chronic liar will go undisciplined or even undetected. Ditto with many such things.
On KT's level, well, he just plain can't get away from what gays do in the privacy of their own homes. He's the type that would deny a gay man a job just because the thoughts of what that man might do or may have done at one time, or now, or in the future gives him the heeby-jeebies. So, it's not just a matter of behavior with KT, it's a matter of orientation qua orientation and, frankly, his mental obsession with gay sex - because, really let's be honest, that sort of thinking requires he be, on some level, fixated on it.