With all these script problems, is there a chance it could even be worse than MiB2?
The original
Men in Black is essentially that generation's
Ghostbusters. It was a brilliant comedy with an excellent blend of special effects and went whole-hog with its concept. Having re-watched it just recently, it holds up incredibly well. Script, direction, acting, scoring, editing -- it's really a very well put-together movie.
But, like
Ghostbusters, it's a movie that was
not desperately crying out for a sequel. There was no story begging to be told, and as a result we got a lackluster sequel made simply because Columbia wanted to score some more bucks from a property that worked well the first time and so it parked dumptrucks of cash in front of the three principals and said, "Make another one."
And now this third one is just looking like it's going to be an abortion. Tommy Lee Jones has no idea what the hell's going on (and I believe Josh Brolin hasn't even begun shooting his stuff yet, because they only shot the present-day material before production was halted and the script went into emergency rewrite mode), and with the parade of writers (I think Etan Cohen, David Koepp, Jeff Nathanson and now Will Smith's private bobo have all had cracks at the script), it seems like it'll just be a hodgepodge of ... crap. Again, it's a movie being made for, well, the sake of being made, not because Sonnenfeld had a great idea to bring everyone back together.