• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Last thing you don't wanna discuss about Star Trek!

"On a related subject, I must confess that I'm giving serious thought... to deleting your wife." - Capt. Kathryn E. Lecter, MD
 
Why was Kim never promoted. Duh, you’d end up with a ship full of commanders (if normal promotions were carried out).

Everyone probably got raised two ranks up once they got back to the AQ.
 
Well, no. We know from Lower Decks Tom Paris was only bumped up one rank.
Tom had been bumped from ensign to JG, so a one-level increase was appropriate.

Had Harry not had that reprimand on his record, he would likely have gotten upped by two ranks. As it is, we can't be certain. It depends on (1) how serious reprimands are in Starfleet, (2) who was reviewing him (Will Riker, space womanizer, likely wouldn't care), and (3) if Harry fought it (he probably could have gotten it stricken, since he was in sn altered mental state).
 
So what WAS the real reason Harry Kim didn't get promoted? Like the real world, not in-universe reason. Tuvok got promoted. Paris got demoted and re-promoted. Why did the producers leave him as an Ensign for 7 years?
 
^ The official reason was what Mr. Wang was told: "someone's got to be the ensign".

The suspected actual reason was that Garrett Wang and the production team had issues, but they couldn't get rid of him (Jennifer Lien was axed instead). So, they decided to humiliate him by humiliating his character.

For further information/discussion on this topic, here's the place to go. https://www.trekbbs.com/threads/why-didnt-harry-get-promoted.318129/
 
So what WAS the real reason Harry Kim didn't get promoted? Like the real world, not in-universe reason. Tuvok got promoted. Paris got demoted and re-promoted. Why did the producers leave him as an Ensign for 7 years?
Combination Brannon Braga never cared for Harry Kim the character and the fact that from the fourth season onward Garrett Wang the actor was only there because UPN insisted he had to be there.
 
Yup. And I know I was involved too, but we should use the designated topic (see link above) for further discussion. The mods created it just so I would stop mentioning the subject everywhere else, after all. And there is a long and delicious discussion on the topic, where we can beat the dead horse into equine jello to our heart's content.

Not sure if this topic is for things you say you don't want to talk about (but secretly do), or things you don't want to talk about and really don't. So for me...

Secretly do: Chakotay/7 were a trainwreck.
Really don't: Chakotay/7 weren't so bad.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top