If he were to return, wouldn't it be better on Discovery?
Reanimating Kirk would only serve to reinforce the fantasy that "No one really dies."
Yes but you also want to get Shatner involved as well. While I would love to see him trying to play a young Kirk in his 20's I am not so sure the audience would buy into it It would be super meta though..

Jason

It seems a touch 'unfair' that our female Captain/Admiral is denied another moment in the sun like Kirk and Picard have had repeatedly. I'm not trying to look for sexism and fully respect people may not like Janeway and most certainly won't project sexism on them. You don't like Janeway for being Janeway, that works. However her popularity is proven and by current viewing statistics. If the actress wants to be considered then it is an opportunity.