DataRules said:
Finally! A thread that singing TNG's praises and not tearing it apart. Like most of you, TNG holds a special place for me, as I watched it during its original run from age 16 to 23. I have fond memories of watching the show in college with about 30 people each week on early Saturday evening before going out. Good times! :thumbsup:
Peace.
I love Trek!!

In general

I honestly have trouble rating them in any kind of order because they all have various strengths and weaknesses.
TOS: Classic. I love Kirk. He's the only captain in ANY of the series to say, "I'm a soldier, not a diplomat". They were a rogue bunch and their complete disregard for the prime directive was awesome. However, many of the episodes were completely ridiculous. The movies were brilliant.
TNG: While some of the early episodes were awkward and the actors uncomfortable in their roles, the show quickly comes around and has some incredibly powerful episodes, tackling several ethical issues and offering meaningful, insightful messages throughout. Episodes are generally self contained mini-plots and you could watch in any order (though story archs are clearly present and well accomplished-- they are fragmented throughout the series).
DS9: Great first season. Great characters and probably the best acting throughout. Incredible continuity-- instead of being independent of eachother the episodes meld into one another brilliantly (great for die hard trek fans only watching from season one on chronologically, casual fans are less likely to enjoy this series). Downsides? DS9 is often preachy and annoying and sometimes it feels more like a soap opera than Star Trek.
VOY: Offers the best comedic episodes of all the series. Excellent character development, though the writing of Janeway is often incoherent and bipolar-- Tes, Seven, the Doctor, Paris, Torris and Neelix are develop brilliantly. Episodes are, like TNG, self-contained and the series offers little continuity or sweeping plot (yeah, they're trying to get home-- but the light years "shed" off the journey here and there are meaningless).
And there's my view
