AuntKate, you only subtracted 1 back there. (Add 1, subtract 2.) Fixing the totals through Supernuke's post...
Kathryn Janeway 3
Tuvok 2 -
The Doctor 4 +
Out:
4th: B'Elanna Torres
5th: Seven
6th: Tom Paris
7th: Kes
8th: Chakotay
9th: Neelix
10th: Ayala
11th: Harry Kim