• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers How literal is LD in your headcanon?

How literal is LD in your headcanon?

  • Completely, like a lost Doctor Who tape saved with animation

    Votes: 32 28.6%
  • Mostly, though some bits are over the top for fun

    Votes: 47 42.0%
  • Only in general terms, though the building blocks are set

    Votes: 16 14.3%
  • I don’t think about it

    Votes: 17 15.2%

  • Total voters
    112
If you want me to be completely honest, either it’s all real, and happened exactly as it appears on screen, (all the shows), or none of it is. Hell in my headcanon pretty much all species are non humanoid, and the universal translator literally sounds like gibberish from the outside.
 
LD does nothing Trek hasn't done before, that's one of its defining traits... and I guess I just don't really care about continuity in Trek enough to have a significant "headcanon" at this point. It has always been a mongrel, seat-of-the-pants creation, and Lower Decks continues that tradition (emphasized through its tongue-in-cheek simultaneous reverence for and roasting of the slapped-together universe it lives in).

There was a time when it drove me nuts that Trek production seemed to treat continuity as an enemy instead of a resource; more recently I've come to the realization that embracing the improvised and pieced-together nature of Trek is embracing the soul of Trek, and that every production takes its own particular approach to that. LD's comedic approach is no less valid than any other. I don't have to precisely triangulate which "canon" it's in or to have a "headcanon" for it beyond recognizing that all the pieces of Trek are just aggregate "headcanon" of various production teams grafting their own interpretations onto something that consisted from the beginning of exactly those types of grafts. I voted "Mostly" but I really should have voted "Completely."

(There are sci-fi universes that have continuity and consistent worldbuilding built into them, which is cool and is why I love The Expanse. But I'm over expecting Trek ever to achieve that or even aspire to it. Its DNA is just different, and is likely to stay that way.)
 
I feel like it is mostly 90% literal but there's occasionally a joke that isn't in my view of what would happen.

I also choose to believe that someone has spiked the raktajino in the replicator and that's why everyone acts like hyperactive hamsters. Probably Captain Freeman to increase efficiency.
 
I think that it is careful not to do anything unexpected with any established characters. Tom Paris is a lieutenant, the rank you would expect him to be. Will Riker is captain of the Titan, and his wife is next to him on the bridge. If we saw or heard about Janeway, she'd likely be an admiral.
 
Harry is either an Ensign or Vice Admiral now.

If he was on Lower Decks, probably true. Either he shoots up once he's out from under Janeway's boot, or his career is beyond salvage due to seven years as an ensign.

Three years have passed since Tom was reinstated to JG, so LT is about right for him. Harry has done LTJG level work for 7 years, so realistically, either LT or LCDR is most likely. Voyager's new first officer, maybe?
 
I imagine that we're watching the toony exaggerations of a "real" Federation starship's misadventures. Like, "Lower Decks" is to the "real" adventures of the U.S.S. Cerritos as "The Voyager Coronary" is to the "real" Voyager of "Trek" canon.
 
I think there are ships like the Cerritos, though. Given the number of messes (i.e. massive and unexpected transformations in the way assorted societies live) left in his wake, like a hyperactive Corgi with a massive intestinal upset, someone had to walk along behind him with the scooper.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top