• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Historical stories not covered enough by Hollywood

As far as American history is concerned, the Tulsa Race Riot would make an interesting film, and certainly deserves some attention, as no one seems to even know that it happened.
Agreed. There have been documentaries about the Tulsa Race Riot of 1921, in which the black district of Greenwood burned to the ground, hundreds were killed and thousands left homeless, but it’s still a ripe subject for a good docudrama.

And why has there not been a major studio treatment of the Fatty Arbuckle scandal? Just think: It had sex, Hollywood glamour, courtroom drama, shady characters, sex, moral crusaders out to cleanse the movie industry of sin and filth, and an almost certainly innocent man accused of a terrible crime. And sex.
 
^^ The story of Umberto Nobile and the airship Italia was done fairly well in The Red Tent (1969).
Wow! Did not know that! And some kind of cast! Thanks for that. :)

And above me...
Boudica - red-headed, wronged MILF goes bat-shit crazy on the Romans' asses in her funky war chariot. Unfortunately, she probably didn't have a happy ending.
There's one already, which I haven't seen, with Alex Kingston (River Song, Dr Who) in the lead role (hubba hubba!)
 
Boudica - red-headed, wronged MILF goes bat-shit crazy on the Romans' asses in her funky war chariot. Unfortunately, she probably didn't have a happy ending.
There's one already, which I haven't seen, with Alex Kingston (River Song, Dr Who) in the lead role (hubba hubba!)
Saw that one. Absolutely awful. Ridiculously anachronistic dialogue and costumes.

The 1967 Hammer production The Viking Queen was very loosely based on the story of Boudica, but any resemblance to history is purely coincidental — starting with the fact that Boudica was Celtic, not Viking. Vikings didn’t arrive in Britain until more than 700 years later.
 
Boudica - red-headed, wronged MILF goes bat-shit crazy on the Romans' asses in her funky war chariot. Unfortunately, she probably didn't have a happy ending.
There's one already, which I haven't seen, with Alex Kingston (River Song, Dr Who) in the lead role (hubba hubba!)
Saw that one. Absolutely awful. Ridiculously anachronistic dialogue and costumes.

The 1967 Hammer production The Viking Queen was very loosely based on the story of Boudica, but any resemblance to history is purely coincidental — starting with the fact that Boudica was Celtic, not Viking. Vikings didn’t arrive in Britain until more than 700 years later.

Yeah, the rubbish Alex Kingston one is a TV movie anyhow. As you say, Boudica was an ancient Briton (specifically the de facto leader of the Iceni). I think a new adaptation could draw on parallels with the piss-poor implementation of the "winning hearts and minds" strategy of a certain modern power in its overseas military intervention.
 
For a film based on a historic event to work it needs to lean towards to war, action, explody, "mannish" side of history as men are the ones who go see such movies. A slow-yet-accurate tale of someone's quiet struggle with some random-yet-powerful discovery wouldn't make for a well attended movie and would =FLOPP!

Mmm, I was remended of Lorenzo's Oil, was that a success or not? (I have no idea and can't be arsed looking it up).

It made 7 million on a 30 million budget.
 
Kenneth Branagh (sp?) did a pretty competent TV movie/mini-series of Shackleton's Antarctic expedition. An amazing story -- I prefer to tell people that it's sort of like the Apollo 13 of Antarctic expeditions, when all is said and done. That usually gets them hooked...

If anyone has heard of either the Franklin Expedition (for the Northwest Passage), or some of the subsequent rescue attempts -- those could be pretty interesting movies if done well. For instance, the story of the recently discovered HMS Investigator.

Also, some of the crazy stuff the Coast Guard did up in Alaska (like trying to cross-plant reindeer from Siberia, the Overland Expedition, etc.) are some ripe possibilities.

Heck, even a biography of "Hell Roaring Mike Healy" would be entertaining. Talk about a character!

Cheers,
-CM-
 
The Revolutionary War, or the War of 1812. I don't think there are enough stories about early U.S history. There's the Civil War, but that seems to have been done accordingly with Gettysburg, Gods & Generals, and another I'm forgetting. There was the John Adams miniseries, but it would be fun to see something even earlier than that, like during Washington's term right when it officially became an independent country.

I'd nominate the Revolutionary War as one of the most ignored periods in film-dom. I'd like to see a movie that's less like The Patriot (blech) and more like John Adams. Maybe it's too big and complicated a topic for any movie. In that case, how about a Revolutionary War version of Band of Brothers? I'd rather see that than anything about WWI, which to me is just a depressing muddle caused by sheer stupidity, with nothing to be learned from it other than Don't Fight Stupid Wars.

Civil War movies tend towards bland battle-epics and are lacking in the human and political dimension. The one you're forgetting is Glory, which at least had a point of view. Wanting more movies like that is why I'm looking forward to Lincoln and even Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter, which I plan to view as an extended metaphor and therefore history of a sort. ;)
 
I'd rather see that than anything about WWI, which to me is just a depressing muddle caused by sheer stupidity, with nothing to be learned from it other than Don't Fight Stupid Wars.

Except that that's not so. It was just the opposite. A great deal was learned during WWI about how to fight war using machine guns, artillery, armor, aircraft, U-boats, destroyers, and all varieties of weapons, innovations that were perfected to bring us WWII.

Yes, people learned what not to do, but that didn't stop Stupid Wars from being fought. Rather, ultimately it just made people more effective at fighting Stupid Wars.
 
To say nothing of social changes in Britain - the extension of the franchise to women and (for better or for worse) the beginnings of Irish Independence
 

Good choice. Though luck was a big part of that, any time a group of destroyer and aircraft carriers manages to defeat a battleship group in a surface gunnery battle it should make for a good story.

How about something about the fight for Guadalcanal. That involved several major carrier and surface gunnery battles in addition to a year long struggle over a rock in the central Pacific?

I'd also like to see something about the Battle of Jutland in WW1. Probably has already been done, but I've never heard of one. Along the same lines, something about the design, manufacture, and subsequent battle between the USS Monitor and the CSS Virginia.

There are a number of non-war historical films I'd love to see as well. How about a major Hollywood biopic of MLK? FDR's life would also make for an interesting biopic. How about something about the Montgomery Bus Boycott from the 50s?
How about the involvement of the Western powers in China in the 19th century? The building of the Transcontinental Railroad?
 
The Revolutionary War, or the War of 1812. I don't think there are enough stories about early U.S history. There's the Civil War, but that seems to have been done accordingly with Gettysburg, Gods & Generals, and another I'm forgetting. There was the John Adams miniseries, but it would be fun to see something even earlier than that, like during Washington's term right when it officially became an independent country.

I'd nominate the Revolutionary War as one of the most ignored periods in film-dom. I'd like to see a movie that's less like The Patriot (blech) and more like John Adams. Maybe it's too big and complicated a topic for any movie. In that case, how about a Revolutionary War version of Band of Brothers? I'd rather see that than anything about WWI, which to me is just a depressing muddle caused by sheer stupidity, with nothing to be learned from it other than Don't Fight Stupid Wars.

Yeah, I can definitely agree with that. There are just too many details for it to be done justice in a movie unless they just gloss over the topic, so a mini-series like you say would be better. But it does make you wonder why nothing about it has been done as it's a wide open topic. Maybe the John Adams team should tackle it?

Civil War movies tend towards bland battle-epics and are lacking in the human and political dimension. The one you're forgetting is Glory, which at least had a point of view. Wanting more movies like that is why I'm looking forward to Lincoln and even Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter, which I plan to view as an extended metaphor and therefore history of a sort. ;)
Hah yeah, that's the one. Thanks for reminding me. That was a great movie. It bugged me that I couldn't remember.
 
Last edited:

Good choice. Though luck was a big part of that, any time a group of destroyer and aircraft carriers manages to defeat a battleship group in a surface gunnery battle it should make for a good story.

How about something about the fight for Guadalcanal. That involved several major carrier and surface gunnery battles in addition to a year long struggle over a rock in the central Pacific?

I'd also like to see something about the Battle of Jutland in WW1. Probably has already been done, but I've never heard of one. Along the same lines, something about the design, manufacture, and subsequent battle between the USS Monitor and the CSS Virginia.

There are a number of non-war historical films I'd love to see as well. How about a major Hollywood biopic of MLK? FDR's life would also make for an interesting biopic. How about something about the Montgomery Bus Boycott from the 50s?
How about the involvement of the Western powers in China in the 19th century? The building of the Transcontinental Railroad?

Well the Transcontinental Railroad is kinda getting it in Hell on Wheels on AMC.

I still want a movie about the USS Indianapolis. Thats a hollywood script that practically writes itself.
 
I still want a movie about the USS Indianapolis. That's a hollywood script that practically writes itself.

That has a heck of a lot of potential. The Navy may put the kibosh on it though since the major part of the drama involved in the sinking of the Indianapolis comes from the fact that the Navy screwed up and didn't even know she was overdue.

If you're wanting to do a movie about a WWII US Navy ship, then what about the story of the survival of the USS Franklin? The Franklin damned near sank off of Okinawa. She's known as the most heavily damaged US carrier to survive the war. She lost 800 men to one bomber attack.
 
The life of Orde Wingate. From his Wikipedia entry:

Major-General Orde Charles Wingate, DSO and two bars (26 February 1903 – 24 March 1944), was a British Army officer and creator of special military units in Palestine in the 1930s and in World War II.

A highly religious Christian, Wingate became a supporter of Zionism, seeing it as his religious and moral duty to help the Jewish community in Palestine form a Jewish state. Assigned to the British Mandate of Palestine in 1936, he set about training members of the Haganah, the Jewish paramilitary organization, which became the Israel Defense Forces with the establishment in 1948 of the state of Israel. Wingate became known to the Jewish men he commanded during the Arab Revolt as "The Friend". He is most famous for his creation of the Chindits, airborne deep-penetration troops trained to work behind enemy lines in the Far East campaigns against the Japanese during World War II.

Wingate was known for various eccentricities. For instance, he often wore an alarm clock around his wrist, which would go off at times, and a raw onion on a string around his neck, which he would occasionally bite into as a snack. He often went about without clothing. In Palestine, recruits were used to having him come out of the shower to give them orders, wearing nothing but a shower cap, and continuing to scrub himself with a shower brush. Lord Moran, Winston Churchill's personal physician, wrote in his diaries that "[Wingate] seemed to me hardly sane—in medical jargon a borderline case." Likewise, referring to Churchill's meeting with Wingate in Quebec, Max Hastings wrote that, "Wingate proved a short-lived protegé: closer acquaintance caused Churchill to realise that he was too mad for high command."

He died in a plane crash and is buried in Arlington National Cemetery.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top