• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Highlander Reboot/Prequel Anticipation Thread

It's time to meet immortals
It's time to hack off heads
It's time to sharpen broadswords
on the Highlander show tonight

Sounds kind of like the Muppet spoof of Hamilton.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
So this video claims that Michael Fassbender will be "The Mongol", the main villain
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

He is from the comics... like Benedict Cumberbatch, he is a great actor... but another Whitewashing????

I hope we at least get a diverse group of other Immortals, like the first film. It would have been creative if they had a woman instead.
 
Someone speculated on the internet that Cavill makes more sense as the Kurgan and really I think Fassbender would make more sense as Connor. Maybe it's all a bait and switch? :lol:

I don't really get "The Mongol", from what I could google he was just someone the Kurgan beheaded centuries ago and doesn't sound like anything that special. How can you remake Highlander without the Kurgan?
 
....46 year-old Michael Fassbender as an immortal? I mean....sure...but still feels like an odd choice age-wise.
 
Odder that a 56 year old Sean Connery?
Yea, I mean if we go by the 'rules' from the original you become immortal when you die an unnatural death. So the physical age of the 'immortal' can vary.

The TV series had a child who died and was an immortal locked in that form for like hundreds of years. Highlander 3 had a Japanese Immortal who had his violent death in his 60s and had lived in that form for centuries.
 
Yea, I mean if we go by the 'rules' from the original you become immortal when you die an unnatural death. So the physical age of the 'immortal' can vary.

The TV series had a child who died and was an immortal locked in that form for like hundreds of years. Highlander 3 had a Japanese Immortal who had his violent death in his 60s and had lived in that form for centuries.
Immortallity can really suck.
 
The TV series had a child who died and was an immortal locked in that form for like hundreds of years.

Kenny was supposedly over 800 years old- about twice as old as Mac. In my mind, his appearance was really (for me) the first time Highlander truly dipped into something like a horror genre. Kenny was like a live version of Chucky.
 
Well the Kurgan needs to be someone around the Black Sea, Russian, Turkey, Ukrainian, greek etc.
Just like Rameirez needs to be Egyptian, or atleast middle eastern.
Mongol? Of course Mongolian, but maybe from some of the -Stan countries like Uzbekistan?
 
The tv show was fun however.
My first introduction to Highlander was the TV series, that was on when I was visiting a couple of SCA friends. Our shire was working on a group project - a latch hook rug/banner of the shire's heraldic device. That thing was big enough for 3 people to sit side by side and work on it, so we just gathered over at their place and Highlander was on in the background.

I really didn't understand much about it, and at that point it wasn't on TV at any predictable time (the channel it was on seemed to use it for filler in the schedule), so it was a long time before I could actually watch the series from start to finish. And eventually I saw the first movie. I tried the second, didn't like it, heard bad things about the third, so gave up on the movies.

I loved the TV show, though, and also enjoyed Highlander: The Raven.

I've got a small stack of Highlander fanzines, and my current bedtime reading is one that takes up a day or two after Nick becomes Immortal. Amanda has mysteriously gone somewhere, and so Nick really has no clue about what he's supposed to do at this point. The story (novel length) has Methos, Joe, and two female Immortals - one of whom is Joan of Arc (she goes by the name 'Jehanne'). The other one's name is Jade, and I can't remember if there was any TV character by that name.

And If they don't have David Tenneant in the movie using his natual scottish lilt in atleast a supporting roll, there not trying hard enough.
Tennant's natural accent is very pleasing to the ear.

Oh, I heartily recommend the TV show. I hate the sequel movies, but the TV show is just wonderful.
And, hey, I like origami too! ;)
As for the TV show, I ran across a YT channel that has some massively long video compilations of every single one of Duncan's historical flashbacks. Each video covers a century of his life, and I've finally reached partway through the last one (20th century), and it's over 5 HOURS long.

The series peaked with season 4 for me, season 5 was fine too. But was gutted with the ending of season 5.

I actually quite liked the raven series. Amanda was a good character
The beauty of fanfic is that if you don't like something about the source material, just write an AU. I haven't read it myself, but I did see a reference to a series of stories in which Richie survives for centuries, and joins Starfleet (during the TOS era).

Which brings up an interesting point. It's asking a lot of audiences to suspend their disbelief at a bunch of people in the 20th century who carry swords around with them that are invisible until it's time to fight. Where would Richie have carried one while serving on a starship?

I can imagine it being an age thing. While some movies are popular with younger generations despite their age I'd think Highlander is one that would appeal to those of us of a certain age. I'd be willing to be my 30 ish nephews nieces never heard of it, and also the same for the likes of the breakfast club etc, but they will know top gun,grease etc
I don't think age matters as much as what someone is interested in. My intro, as mentioned earlier in this post, came as a result of the SCA. That organization has people of all ages in it, from young kids to great-grandparents. It's older than Star Trek (by a couple of months) and especially when you get multiple generations of the same family being part of it, you have multiple generations being exposed to all kinds of medieval-era historical things (and earlier, as some of us are history buffs in general; I was into Roman history for 10 years before getting into the SCA and medieval history).

Like most, I dislike the first season of the show, but when they moved production to Paris, it got much better. Roger Daltry's character was a lot of fun!
Fitz was such a hoot! :lol:

Yep, Amanda is a decent actor and the series was okay. I'm still questioning the choice of cutting off all that lovely black hair giving her a bleached white buzz cut in a show called "Raven." :lol:
Well, corvids are attracted to shiny things, and so is Amanda. Rebecca was only able to civilize her so much before she embarked on centuries of being a thief.

Here's her original death, which just shows how silly it was in her own series when she took on a French persona.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

What I want to know is what the reboot does differently. I do expect better acting. But how else can they make it better?
Ditch the notion that every Immortal has to be a foundling. I always found that idea ridiculous.

So can Sam Heughan given the timeline Outlander is set in.
Is that series still on? I lost track of it years ago after it was switched to a channel I don't get.

I could read the novels, but they're so huge that it's literally painful to hold them.

In terms of some of the TV series' "problems"...
1. Don't give them magic sword pockets.
2. Have the Watchers be part of the lore from day one, and have the Watchers clean up after duels so that there aren't dozens of headless people all over the place. (Headless people aren't a problem if you use that as part of the storytelling, but the TV show mostly ignored it.)
Some of the fanfic I've read lately addresses the issue of the Watchers being the cleanup crew. Watchers aren't any more eager than the Immortals for the mortal cops to find out what's going on.

The movie gives us one of the most bonkers moments in cinema, that of Christophe Lambert, who's about as Scottish as a croissant, explaining haggis to Sean Connery.
:lol:

I'm cautiously excited for this reboot. Cavill (who seems to be making a thing of taking on iconic roles in franchise reboots; Superman, Napoleon Solo and now Connor MacLeod) seems much closer to a Duncan type than Lambert's Connor.
I've only seen him in The Tudors.

One thing I always chuckled about with the series was that so many older immortals seemed to have learned absolutely nothing in the centuries they'd been alive, or managed to amass enough resources to live without needing to resort to petty theft, shenanigans, or borrowing from their friends.

In reality, a 400 year old immortal would probably live in a shadow world where nobody knew of his existence for the most part, he was rarely seen, and had an entire 'secret society' like the Templars or something as his personal staff to do his bidding, mind his investments, keep the properties free of trespassers, and ensure his existence and training was undisturbed. Meetings between immortals would require decades worth of Machiavellian planning and execution, like a gang war of old (but more subtle), resulting in a meeting between two master swordsmen where the duel would be over in a pass or two and winner take all. An organization like the Watchers would have been eradicated as soon as the first immortal learned of its existence. The deal where they randomly bump into each other on a street and have a sword fight in the dirty alley a block over? That wouldn't happen between men and women who had survived for centuries. As TV entertainment it would be pretty boring, but that is how it would probably go.
Older in how long it's been since they died, or older in their biological age when they died? Immortality doesn't grant instant knowledge or wisdom. Duncan was illiterate when he died, and later he learned to read in a monastery. The person who taught him was an Immortal lay priest, and the reading material was Shakespeare's Macbeth. People like Duncan opted to improve themselves, learn new things. Others either didn't want to, or they couldn't manage the opportunity.

It's also clear in the TV series that not all Immortals learn to fight. Instead, they either find protectors or they stay on holy ground.

I'm still not sure whether I saw all of the series or not but suspect I saw a lot of it. I seem to recall that Methos was my favourite character by far and my only real memory of the show is the episode where he castigated all the newer immortals for growing up in a world where chivalry and nobility existed whereas he'd come from a much more barbaric time and hence could be way more of a bastard!
That would have been the episode in which Kristin became a problem. She was obsessed with remaking Duncan into her idea of the perfect man, and he finally had enough of it and left her. She didn't take it well.

When things got to the point where it was necessary to kill her, Duncan hesitated. Methos correctly realized that Duncan had reservations about killing a woman, and that's when he gave that speech about chivalry. Methos himself had no qualms whatsoever with killing a woman if it was necessary.

In Highlander three Connor says that a potential immortal can have children, and will die of old age eventually, unless they prematurely expire from a violent death, which is when their "powers" kick in.
The TV series makes the point that whatever makes a pre-Immortal into an Immortal is only activated with a quick and violent death.

That's why Amanda shoots Nick in the season finale of Highlander: The Raven. Immortals can tell when someone is pre-Immortal, but the custom is that they don't reveal that.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

(last 5 minutes or so; Amanda explains it to Nick)

Kenny was supposedly over 800 years old- about twice as old as Mac. In my mind, his appearance was really (for me) the first time Highlander truly dipped into something like a horror genre. Kenny was like a live version of Chucky.
I have a short story anthology called An Evening at Joe's. All the stories were written by people involved in the series, whether production, tech, or actors. Peter Wingfield, who played Methos, wrote an absolutely chilling story about an Immortal baby.

Kenny was old enough to survive on his own, though he had to use older Immortals to protect him. A baby would remain a baby forever.


I've gotten back into this series after a long hiatus, since I got an idea for a long fanfic project that's a crossover between Highlander, Highlander: the Raven, and BBC Merlin. Merlin himself is immortal due to his magic. Sir Leon is theorized by some fans to be immortal due to drinking from the Cup of Life. There's one other character in the show whose death I thought was unjust, so I decided to fix that.

And now I'm doing research, to figure out what he's going to do with himself for the next 1500 years (and no, it's not Arthur).

On the other hand, someone else wrote a crossover in which an older King Arthur turns out to be Immortal and manages to stay out of the history books by remaining on holy ground. Duncan MacLeod meets him... and is knighted.
 
The beauty of fanfic is that if you don't like something about the source material, just write an AU. I haven't read it myself, but I did see a reference to a series of stories in which Richie survives for centuries, and joins Starfleet (during the TOS era).

Which brings up an interesting point. It's asking a lot of audiences to suspend their disbelief at a bunch of people in the 20th century who carry swords around with them that are invisible until it's time to fight. Where would Richie have carried one while serving on a starship?

That's easy (see 35s mark):

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top