Re: Gary Seven - Why try create new series when current one is struggl
Well, that doesn't mean he had a specific plan to do it as a non-Who story -- just that he wanted to explore the idea in some form. As he says, "I wanted to tell a story in which civilisation snaps, in which we turn on ourselves, in which nothing is safe." And
Torchwood was the show that gave him the opportunity to examine that theme. All writers have a bunch of basic ideas or issues or questions that they want to write about in some form, but it may take them years to find the right specifics, the right characters and context to tell them in, the right way to structure or resolve the story. In the quotes I've found, Davies talks about how he didn't even have the ending for
Children of Earth worked out yet while he and his collaborators were writing the scripts to parts 1-4.
I meant more my reaction - or the lack thereof - about the death of a character. Of course you react differently if you only know him for a relatively short time vs. someone who has known and loved and got attached to him for years.
True, some people are fans specifically of a single character and can be inordinately upset if that character is killed off. When the
Voyager novels killed off Captain Janeway for a few years (she got better), the sheer savagery of the vitriol and condemnation from a small segment of the fanbase was kind of alarming. They were convinced they'd been personally attacked. This was perhaps understandable, given that there had long been an ugly thread of misogyny directed against Janeway from certain dark corners of fandom, and so Janeway's stalwart fans probably had some reason to feel that they and the character had been attacked unjustly in the past, and some of them evidently jumped to the erroneous conclusion that the creative decision to kill off the character was part of that attack. But still, their reaction was astonishingly disproportionate considering that it was only a completely imaginary figure who'd died, and only in one iteration of the tie-ins.
But I consider that to be one of the more extremist flavors of fandom, and I think extremists tend to dominate the conversation more than they should because they're so much louder than everyone else. I think that there are always going to be plenty of fans who are fans of the whole series or the whole franchise, who recognize that characters may come and go as part of any ongoing story, and that a character's death isn't some horrible crime against fandom but just a story choice that seemed right to the creators at that time. In the case of Janeway, I felt that she actually had a stronger and more influential presence in the books set after her death, and dealing with its ongoing aftereffects upon her friends and crewmates, than she did in many of the books where she was alive. Character deaths can be a valuable and powerful storytelling device because of the way they affect and change other characters. And those other characters' reactions to a loved one's death can be a great tribute to that character.
Offhand, I can think of only one time that I've really been offended by a character's death in a TV series. It was the second-season premiere of
War of the Worlds: The Series, where the new showrunner just happened to kill off both of the nonwhite characters and add a new white character to replace them, and then claimed it was for reasons having nothing to do with race. One of the characters he killed off, Colonel Ironhorse, was by far the show's most beloved and popular character, and the new showrunner claimed he'd somehow been unaware of that fact when he killed him off. Anyway, as wrong as that was to me, what really hurt was just how badly and callously his death was handled. He nominally sacrificed himself to save others, which in theory would be a noble end, but the situation was just so blatantly contrived and forced to make him kill himself, and the actual scene was directed so coldly and brutally, that it just left me bitter and furious at how badly the character had been handled.
But that's the exception, not the rule. I've been a fan of a lot of shows since, and seen a lot of characters I liked get killed, but it's never really offended or outraged me like it did then. Disappointed, sure, but I've never taken it so personally. Generally I've understood that it's just something that happens in ongoing series.
That's nice, I like that! Sometimes you really don't want to call yourself a fan for the reasons you stated. "Fancy" is a British word, right? Torchwood and Doctor Who and its actors and creators taught me a lot of British slang
It's an old-fashioned word in the US, but I don't think it's exclusively British. We have expressions that use it, like "a passing fancy," "catch one's fancy," "fancy that," etc.