• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Flagships Enterprise and beyond...

Actually, it's pretty realistic. Hollywood had done a good job of painting PR in a negative light, but it's really just public messaging. The Enterprise being used as a public symbol for Starfleet not only is plausible but likely, especially post TOS.
I meant fake as in phony. Having one ship being the public face of the fleet doesn’t work for me. Too gimmicky. Hell, it maybe casts hair-conscious Pike in not the best light. :rommie::rommie: I prefer a more open future with greater transparency across the entire fleet, not one ship “ready for Primetime.”

For me flagship is not simply PR but an actual position in the defense structure of the fleet.
 
I think it was a little more than ‘just something suggested.’ The problem, however, was that Matalas’s definition of ‘refit’ was some strange usage of the word we had previously been unaware of.
It’s not just Matalas, right? The Stargazer was a vastly different ship in s2, head showrunner Akiva Goldsman.

Also, refits in Trek overall are insane. TMP Enterprise had how much of its original ship in it still? It gets more of a pass because it looked closer to the original, but put them side by side and not a lot remained.
 
It’s not just Matalas, right? The Stargazer was a vastly different ship in s2, head showrunner Akiva Goldsman.

Also, refits in Trek overall are insane. TMP Enterprise had how much of its original ship in it still? It gets more of a pass because it looked closer to the original, but put them side by side and not a lot remained.

The word 'refit' can have different connotations, even in Star Trek. But in the case of the Titan, we know with 100% certainty that the Titan mentioned in Nemesis and seen in Lower Decks is a Luna class starship with the registry of NCC-80102. But then in PIC we are introduced to a different, later Constitution III class Titan NCC-80102-A (in which the letter suffix previously denoted a newer ship) but the dialogue in PIC seemed to strongly indicate that it was Riker's ship from Nemesis and LDS. Most likely because Matalas wanted it to be the same ship, at some point realized it wasn't, and then came up with some incredibly vague and awkward dialogue that made it sound like it still was.
 
I don't think any of the dialog in PIC was altered to indicate that the Titan wasn't the same ship from NEM, all the stuff making it the Titan-A to be consistent with LDS seemed to be on the production-design side. I'm a little surprised the dedication plaque has the "-A" and the save wasn't done entirely by the CG team.
 
I didn't say the dialogue was altered. I said that the dialogue was vague and awkward in regards to the exact nature of the ship, based on what we see onscreen. Matalas wanted the Constitution III design as the Titan mentioned in Nemesis. The VFX personnel just built the CG model and gave it the registry of the previous Titan from LDS, with a suffix to indicate it was a newer ship, despite the dialogue giving the indication that it was the same ship. So to explain this discrepancy, that's when all that off-screen backstory about parts of the old Titan being put in the new one and then calling it a 'refit' came about.
 
Last edited:
I meant fake as in phony. Having one ship being the public face of the fleet doesn’t work for me.
Probably works for Starfleet though.
Too gimmicky.
Not really, It's far less gimmicky than "It's not just a job, it's an adventure."
Hell, it maybe casts hair-conscious Pike in not the best light. :rommie::rommie: I prefer a more open future with greater transparency across the entire fleet, not one ship “ready for Primetime.”

For me flagship is not simply PR but an actual position in the defense structure of the fleet.
It works both ways. Enterprise can serve as both the public symbol of Starfleet and its lead command ship. And as I said upthread, it doesn't mean that other ships can't serve as flagships in the traditional sense.
 
It works both ways. Enterprise can serve as both the public symbol of Starfleet and its lead command ship. And as I said upthread, it doesn't mean that other ships can't serve as flagships in the traditional sense.
It's not about whether other ships can serve as flagships. If anything what you're saying is that whatever ship the flagship is, that's the one ship the public follows. Whether it's the Enterprise, the Kumari, T'Plana-Hath, Yorktown, Agavè, Proxima, Bonaventure, Europa, Constitution, New Jersey, Federation, Ambassador, or Titan (did I miss any?) that carried the flag for the entire fleet at the time.

I think that's too myopic of the Federation. Not what a future of trillions would be like. There would be billions of people interested in the goings on of the fleet, and eyeballs aplenty to explore the mission logs and material from many many ships. Some would be less interesting than others (Dr. Elizabeth Lense's dull charting expedition in DS9's "Explorers" where they got excited if they found moss comes to mind), but I dunno, I don't like the idea that all the really interesting stuff only happens to the Enterprise.

I imagine a vast fleet with some really interesting and bizarre things that happen to all sorts of ships throughout the far-flung reaches of deep space. Indeed, much closer to home as well. Who knows what ancient wonders an archeological dig might find on a planet long-populated, maybe by different aliens at different times in its history. Are the Ancient Taguans of 2 Billion years ago from TNG's "Qpid" the same as the current ones? Why are there so many different aliens native to the Rigel System? Was Earth a lost colony of Kobol, er, Mars before its demise?

I imagine future Federation citizens all over all of that, curious about the world around them and how it informs their lives, long-since over the uncurious dopamine-addled dark ages of the 21st Century.
 
Last edited:
It's not about whether other ships can serve as flagships. If anything what you're saying is that whatever ship the flagship is, that's the one ship the public follows. Whether it's the Enterprise, the Kumari, T'Plana-Hath, Yorktown, Agavè, Proxima, Bonaventure, Europa, Constitution, New Jersey, Federation, Ambassador, or Titan (did I miss any?) that carried the flag for the entire fleet at the time.

I think that's too myopic of the Federation. Not what a future of trillions would be like.
Agree to disagree on that.
 
to throw another rock into the flagship thing, one of the romulans in Balance of Terror refers to the BoP as the "empire's finest flagship"...
 
The Stargazer was a vastly different ship in s2, head showrunner Akiva Goldsman.
Terry was Showrunner for the first half of Season 2. He oversaw how the season was built etc.

It was his idea for them to go back in time to modern LA.
 
When Starfleet is engaged in a conflict needed a fleet of some kind, an admiral or other senior officer will usually have a flagship for that formation. But that is aside from the title of "Flagship of the Federation", which is ceremonial. Captain Pike nor Captain Picard are flag officers. Captain Pike is given a temporary promotion to Fleet Captain for a mission. Captain Picard is granted a 22-ship blockade force during the Klingon Civil War with no promotion. He is a senior captain that could easily have a flag rank but refuses most time to accept a potion that will take him from the captain's chair. Captain Kirk does get a promotion to Admiral and managed to negotiate his command back, but we are not sure exactly for how long. It is assumed Kirk remained on the refit Enterprise for another Five Year Mission before he took an early retirement before returning to teach at the Academy, then getting demoted back to Captain and running a starship again until his death. But we really don't know for certain if the USS Enterprise under Captain Kirk was the "Federation Flagship". It was never seemingly that important of a ship aside that it was a "Starship", and that a "Starship Captain" was a special and rare breed.
 
Probably the most military-accurate example of "flagship" use in TNG was in "Descent", when Admiral Nechayev rolls up to brief Picard on the Starfleet response to the latest Borg incursion:

"There will be fifteen starships in this sector by the day after tomorrow. The Gorkon will be my flagship. You'll have command of task force three, consisting of the Enterprise, the Crazy Horse and the Agamemnon."

The Gorkon is an Excelsior-class starship, which probably pales in comparison to the shiny Enterprise-D in every conceivable way. But with Nechayev aboard, it became the flagship for the whole operation.

Strangely enough, in all the various battle scenes in DS9 the Defiant was never referred to as the flagship despite Sisko being in charge of hundreds of ships on multiple instances. Only in "What You Leave Behind" did we hear of the "Romulan Flagship" being destroyed; Admiral Ross was there but seemed to be worrying about other elements of the fleet from his own ship (unless he was in the Defiant's engineering, as the visual showed he was standing in front of its consoles when on comms).

Mark
 
The Term flagship is used in First Contact when the Ent-E tuned into the fleet communications

FLEET COMMUNICATIONS: Flagship to Endeavor. Standby to engage at grid A-fifteen. Defiant and Bozeman, fall back to mobile position one. Acknowledge. We have it in visual range. A Borg cube on course zero point two one five, speed warp point nine six.

Presumedly referring to Admiral Hayes's ship

Martok's ship is referred to as his flaghship a couple times. a Klingon General is presumedly the equivalent to a Starfleet Admiral.
 
Last edited:
Captain James T. Kirk seems relatively new and young in his first Five Year Mission on the Enterprise. Was it still the Federation Flagship during TOS? Or had that title shifted once Pike stepped down?

My assumption is that Constellation was originally the flagship during the TOS era, though DSC/SNW present other possibilities that may cover this era and IMO it would be reasonable to assume that Lexington was the flagship during its onscreen period with either the Excelsior or the Titan replacing that over time.
 
My assumption is that Constellation was originally the flagship during the TOS era, though DSC/SNW present other possibilities that may cover this era and IMO it would be reasonable to assume that Lexington was the flagship during its onscreen period with either the Excelsior or the Titan replacing that over time.
What is the reasoning behind Constellation and Lexington as flagships?
 
A "Flagship" is whatever ship a "Flag" Officer flies their "Flag" from...

That's basic naval tradition. Whether that be HMS Victory in 1805 with Nelson's Admiral's Flag flying or USS Constellation in 2265 with Decker's virtual Commodore's Pennant flying.
 
A "Flagship" is whatever ship a "Flag" Officer flies their "Flag" from...

That's basic naval tradition. Whether that be HMS Victory in 1805 with Nelson's Admiral's Flag flying or USS Constellation in 2265 with Decker's virtual Commodore's Pennant flying.
And yet there was no flag officer on either Picard's or Pike's Enterprise. In-universe it means both the original meaning (Nechayev on Gorkon) and something like "premier ship," meaning the largest, most prestigious, or most technologically advanced vessel in a fleet. Or, given this is a TV show we're talking about, flagship is used as in a flagship show of a network (VOY on UPN), meaning its lead show.

It is in this context the term and ship(s) are interesting to me. The original meaning is not in dispute.
 
Agreed, but as has been noted above, TNG anyway ALSO presents the term to describe the "best ship" of the fleet. Cribbing the fan-made description used at Memory Alpha:

"A flagship was a status given to a starship considered to be the premier ship of a fleet. Typically, a flagship was a vessel commanded by a flag officer (an admiral or similar rank). The term was also properly applied to the ship of whichever commanding officer was in charge of a grouping of ships. A third, more colloquial usage of the term could mean that the ship in question was considered an "exemplar" of the best capabilities and virtues of the force it represented."

So it can be argued that when in TNG they often described the Enterprise-D as the "flagship", it's the more colloquial use of the term even if it's seemingly an official designation. It's pretty much ONLY the Enterprise-D that has been referred to in this way, with a couple outliers that come to mind:

"The maiden voyage of our newest flagship deserves more pomp and circumstance than we can afford today, but her christening will have to be our reward." - Captain Pike, Star Trek (2009)

And more recently:

"I am the Chief Medical Officer on the flagship of Starfleet..." - M'Benga, SNW "Ghosts of Illyria"

Otherwise it's pretty consistently used to refer to "that ship the fleet's commanding officer is aboard".

Mark
 
What is the reasoning behind Constellation and Lexington as flagships?

Well, Constellation had a more senior commanding officer and Lexington literally appeared in the role of a flagship in her only canon appearance... which is inconclusive, but it's more evidence than we have for Enterprise being the Flagship during that period, even discounting DSC/SNW.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top