• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Dune: Prophecy - Spoilers!

Interesting Finale

i) Javicco and Sister Francesca are dead, the Empress Consort has thrown her lot in with Desmond Hart and Princess Inez is on the Run.

Who gets the throne? Does Natalya try to hold it on behalf of her "kidnapped" daughter, or does Prince Constantine seize the throne (or get placed on it by the Empress) - and more to the point, if Theodosia was supposed to pretend to be Inez to cover up the Princess and Kieran's escape, why did she then pretend to be a "Not-Sardaukar" and attempt to kill Desmond instead. Was she in league with the true villains ...

ii) Is that Erasmus? And are the Mentats the Big Bads? Or is it Omnius?

iii) The timeline feels a little "off" - the time jump feels like it should have been more than thirty years to fit everything in. Desmond is only supposed to be about 29, but Kieran's father is (presumably) Albert Atreides, the kid who survives Tula's massacre. Or is Kieran significantly younger than Mason?
It doesn't need to be Erasmus, or Omnius. It could also be the Ixians. We know that they, like Richese, were famous for skirting the edges of what was permissible Tech. And the Ixians were also noted for being not exactly friendly to the Imperium. Using forbidden machines to create a virus in order to destabilize the Imperium would be right up their alley...
 
Interesting Finale

if Theodosia was supposed to pretend to be Inez to cover up the Princess and Kieran's escape, why did she then pretend to be a "Not-Sardaukar" and attempt to kill Desmond instead.
She was meant to replace Ynez, but that was when they were leaving Kieran there. The idea was that nobody would realize the princess was in on the breakout and nobody would be looking for her, only for Valya.

Once Kieran was also breaking out there was no point in leaving a replacement Ynez behind, because nobody is that stupid. Who breaks out the Mother Superior and the Atreides swordmaster but leaves the rebel princess behind? Everybody with half a brain would see through that.

So, because their plan was already shot to hell by Ynez refusing to leave her boyfriend behind, Theodosia improvised to by them time. It was the best she could do with resources on hand.
 
Me too. What's the Empress' background? Could she be from Ix?

I think all we've had was that she is a Butlerian (ironically more so than her husband, a member of House Butler), they cited her noble house at one point (House Arat?), and her marriage brought in the non-aligned worlds to the Imperium
 
Damn, that was bad.

When i saw the run time of 1.2 hours i groaned ( bad sign 1). Then halfway i started fast forwarding through most of the Javico scenes ( really bad sign 2). Nothing that happened in this season finale excited me even a little bit.

The Sisters are an infighting, internally treacherous group of women ( as in not just disagreeing on the course of action but actively infighting), the Emperor is a wet blanket, Desmond Hart is just going around killing people and i wonder what the whole point of the season was at all. Everybody is running around like headless chickens, doing something then pivoting to doing something else, nobody has a real plan much less Valya/The Sisters who seem completely inept at this point even though they like to think themselves as master manipulators ( which never really gets to be seen in the show).

The writing is a mess, the characters even more so and as much as i love Fimmel from his Vikings days he's a complete failure here.

So yeah, i'm out for season two. This was an endurance slog for me after the mediocre pilot episode with the hopes it would get better and it only got worse. Too bad, i had hopes they would pull off something good worthy of the universe but the producers ain't Villeneuve or Frank Herbert, that much was evident.
 
I think all we've had was that she is a Butlerian (ironically more so than her husband, a member of House Butler), they cited her noble house at one point (House Arat?), and her marriage brought in the non-aligned worlds to the Imperium
Deep cover?
 
I love this show. (I know a lot of people don't. That's okay. I understand some of the complaints.) It's SO right up my alley because it has so many soap opera elements and tropes. It's I, Claudius set in the Dune universe, and since I have some rudimentary knowledge of what's going on in that universe it's the perfect show for me. And the presence of Javicco Corrino doesn't hurt either. I can't wait for the BluRays in April, I hope they'll put a decent amount of bonus and behind the scenes stuff on them.

Even though my favorite character most likely won't be in season 2 (sigh) I'll still keep track of this show. It doesn't happen very often that a 'modern' show manages to capture me, I prefer re-watching old shows over and over again these days, but this one sure managed. I'm glad they'll be getting another season. I hope they'll be able to flesh things out a bit more, something they couldn't do in the first season for a number of reasons.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top