• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Does it hurt to be shot by phaser?

Shat Happens

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
We only see phasers on stun (and the person being shot instantly faints to uncounsciousness) or desintegrate (where they, well, desintegrate). I remember Terrell and Kruge's gunner screaming.
 
I should imagine you wake up with a splitting headache after being stunned, vaporised is probably extremely painful but over so quick you barely know it's happened.
 
If a taser does, I imagine a phaser could. Starfleet phasers might have settings that hurt less, depending on who you're shooting at, given the more enlightened Humans we supposedly become.
 
We only see phasers on stun (and the person being shot instantly faints to uncounsciousness) or desintegrate (where they, well, desintegrate). I remember Terrell and Kruge's gunner screaming.

In "The Man Trap," Crater did not faint from the Phaser setting Kirk used; Crater was in a sort of dazed / drunken state:

CRATER: "Ooh! I feel strange."
KIRK: "Just stunned. You'll be able to think in a minute."
 
Wonder why being shot by a Varon-T Disruptor apparently hurt so much more than being vaporized by a Phaser or other disruptors, so that the weapon became banned?

The Vaporization process doesn't last much longer than what happened to Kruge's gunner and just a short moment longer than a TNG Handphaser.
 
Wonder why being shot by a Varon-T Disruptor apparently hurt so much more than being vaporized by a Phaser or other disruptors, so that the weapon became banned?

The Vaporization process doesn't last much longer than what happened to Kruge's gunner and just a short moment longer than a TNG Handphaser.
As Kivas Fajo described the Varon-T disruptor, "It's vicious. It tears a body apart, inside out, and very slowly too by your phaser standards. It's tortuous. A very, very painful death" (as transcribed at chakoteya.net). Comparing the scene to other disintegrations, it does seem take a longer amount of time from the moment when Fajo pulls the trigger until the victim disappears.

Kor
 
Wonder why being shot by a Varon-T Disruptor apparently hurt so much more than being vaporized by a Phaser or other disruptors, so that the weapon became banned?

The Vaporization process doesn't last much longer than what happened to Kruge's gunner and just a short moment longer than a TNG Handphaser.
It's not the time; it's the mileage. It's designed to inflict pain as you are being disintegrated. Not just kill you; hurt you as you die. Cruelty in handheld form.
 
I would liken pain from a phaser hit on a scale of 1 and up as a 1 being... a 9 volt battery just to get your attention, to a disintegration. (Capt. Terral)

In between I think they would feel like increasingly strong electric jolts. Highest I have felt is 110 so I can imagine 240 - 480 - 960 as voltages I would not want to :censored: around with.
 
There's a canonical answer, in DS9:"Profit and Loss"

- Natima and Quark

True, but we'll have to take into account that Quark is a whiny little creature. Moreover, he was trying to get a rub from Natina at that point (and possibly more).

That said, these phasers deliver an energy blast to your body so it probably really isn't a pleasant felling, even on low settings.
 
This topic reminds me of Down Periscope:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I suspect that, as far as Fed weapons are concerned, the "kinetic stun" that Kirk used to blast the Klingon guards 20 feet in the air on Genesis in TSFS would probably hurt more than any other kind of stun. As for kill settings, who knows? Has anyone ever canonically survived being shot by "kill" to say "that REALLY fucking hurt!!"? :D
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top