Does anyone think Star Trek Legacy will ever happen?

[FederationHistorian]

There will be plenty of new people (The La Forge sisters, Jack Crusher, Dr. Ohk, Mura, Esmar, [The] Shaw[logram]).

Right now, that’s just fan hype. That’s not confirmed yet. And even though we like them, half of them might get replaced.

I believe this as before SNW aired, there were supporting characters introduced in DIS and Short Treks that were not carried over to SNW, despite expecting them to be involved with the show. Louvier was replaced by Hemmer, and the Pelia and Scotty in engineering. Amin was replaced by Ortegas and Jenna Mitchell at the helm. The comm officer Nicola was replaced by Uhura. Even Lynn Lucero, who - based on the Short Treks about her - had a history with Pike and has every reason to regularly visit the Enterprise crew after losing her ship, has been replaced by Kirk as the one who (annoyingly) drops by every few episodes. There was only a three year gap between DIS S2 and SNW airing.

If Legacy ever comes on, it will have been several years since PIC S3. In that time, Jack, Alandra, and Esmar will likely have ranked up to lieutenant. While Sidney and Mura will have ranked up to lieutenant commanders. Raffi might even be in line for her own command. I find it plausible that half of them (Mura, Ohk, Esmar) will have been reassigned to different ships in the time between PIC and Legacy, and we will be introduced to new characters.

 

[Nerys Myk]

Dr. Ohk, Mura, Esmar,

I'd be surprised to see any of these in a show.

 

[Danja]

If Legacy ever comes on, it will have been several years since PIC S3. In that time, Jack, Alandra, and Esmar will likely have ranked up to lieutenant.

That's assuming Alandra even gets on again (she didn't have much going on other than the novelty of LeVar's RL daughter playing La Forge's daughter).

Jack might be Lt. j.g..

While Sidney and Mura will have ranked up to lieutenant commanders.

Mura, maybe.

Sydney might get up to full Lieutenant (she was a Lt. j.g. at the end of Picard).

Raffi might even be in line for her own command.

Commands hinge on the speed of plot (How often did Riker get jerked around on TNG?)

 

[FederationHistorian]

Commands hinge on the speed of plot (How often did Riker get jerked around on TNG?)

That’s presuming that Raffi hangs back like Riker did. I’m not aware of her wanting to command the Enterprise, or having a Pegasus incident in her past.

If she isn’t on the Enterprise at the start of Legacy, maybe Mura is first officer. Meaning he changed over to the command division.

Raffi doesn't have to be ranked up to captain to actually be a captain.

 

[Paul755]

Commands hinge on the speed of plot (How often did Riker get jerked around on TNG?)

How was Riker jerked around? Dude refused to take a command of his own, it’s not like he didn’t have opportunities. If anyone got jerked around on TNG it was Data and Worf.