Doctor Who – 4x12 – The Stolen Earth (Grade/Discuss)

[Mr Awe]

Oh, I WANT to see that!

And for those commenting on Rose's complaints, I found this on (iirc) deviantart a year or so ago (sorry for page stretch, it was much bigger):

The problem for me there is i can't actually tell which one Sarah Jane is supposed to be. Is it the one in the purple pant-suit?

Yep, that's her. Between Jo Grant and Leela.

Mr Awe

 

[Australis]

lvsxy808 said:

The problem for me there is i can't actually tell which one Sarah Jane is supposed to be. Is it the one in the purple pant-suit?

Yes. They're in order, so she's between the red/blonde Jo Grant and brown haired Leela, ninth one along.

I like the way the artist did the black and white period companions... in black and white. This tells me the guy is one serious fan!

 

[Stevil2001]

The Torchwood scenes felt like an episode of Torchwood,

I was surprised by that, because RTD's script for Torchwood, "Everything Changes," was one of the weaker scripts in the first season, and I felt like he didn't "get" Torchwood. The one thing that felt wrong with the Torchwood scenes was Jack's fatalistic reaction to the Daleks, because if anyone should know better, he should.

What does Jack know? That the only reason he survived his last encounter with the Daleks was because of divine intervention. I think being fatalistic is perfectly reasonable.

It's Sarah Jane who shouldn't be. The Daleks she remembers weren't exactly formidable opponents!

 

[Hobs202]

^ If anyone's interested, here's the original link:
http://mimi-na.deviantart.com/art/Doctor-s-Girls-46247500

 

[The Nightmare Doctor]

And for those commenting on Rose's complaints, I found this on (iirc) deviantart a year or so ago (sorry for page stretch, it was much bigger):

The problem for me there is i can't actually tell which one Sarah Jane is supposed to be. Is it the one in the purple pant-suit?

Yes, that's her.

I love that picture. mimi-na's pictures for the male companions, The Doctor, and monsters being chased by K-9 are also great. Still waiting for her version for The Master (which she "promised" she would do months ago but has been too busy with commissions).

I'm still uncertain about the "three-fold man" bit.

I'm guessing it refers to a past, present, and future Doctor all being in one place/time simultaneously. It'll take 3 Doctors to resolve this mess.

Ah, that would make sense. In fact, so much sense that I can't believe I didn't think of that before.

 

[Mr Awe]

I'm still uncertain about the "three-fold man" bit.

I'm guessing it refers to a past, present, and future Doctor all being in one place/time simultaneously. It'll take 3 Doctors to resolve this mess.

Ah, that would make sense. In fact, so much sense that I can't believe I didn't think of that before.

If its true, then it implies that they were able to keep a past Doctor returning a secret. My guess is that it's McCoy. But, wow, what a secret if true!

And, while we know how the future version of the Doctor arrives (via regeneration), and can guess about Tennant (the hand being involved), I don't have any guesses as to how the past Doctor would appear?

Mr Awe

 

[Captain Pike]

Not sure which way I'll vote yet, but Donna's jugs definitely get a "Fantastic"..

 

[Roshi]

23 pages within the broadcasting week of Doctor Who!
Niiice!

 

[captcalhoun]

i wish mini-na would go back and add in Martha and Donna...

 

[Mr Awe]

One question, if the Time War was locked, how did Eccleston get out?

Mr Awe

 

[Bob The Skutter]

One question, if the Time War was locked, how did Eccleston get out?

Mr Awe

By living past the event. I'd think Time Locked means you can't travel forward/back to that event from any other time, but you could live through it.

 

[The Nightmare Doctor]

23 pages within the broadcasting week of Doctor Who!
Niiice!

12 pages for me, but it all depends on how many posts you have for each page.

But I agree with the shock at the amount of posts and votes in such a short term. It's fantastic!

i wish mini-na would go back and add in Martha and Donna...

I want her to do The Master first. Plus she said she wanted to redo The Doctor at some point. Unfortunately, she's too busy with commissions. Silly money.

One question, if the Time War was locked, how did Eccleston get out?

Mr Awe

By living past the event. I'd think Time Locked means you can't travel forward/back to that event from any other time, but you could live through it.

That's how I look at as well.

 

[tomalak301]

23 pages within the broadcasting week of Doctor Who!
Niiice!

Kind of feel bad for the people who will come in after Scifi airs this episode. No One else will care.

 

[The Nightmare Doctor]

23 pages within the broadcasting week of Doctor Who!
Niiice!

Kind of feel bad for the people who will come in after Scifi airs this episode. No One else will care.

Not necessarily. I always read what the new viewers have to say about the episode and sometimes comment on what they say.

 

[Haggis and tatties]

Davros ranting now explained......who new.

Davros rant explained

 

[wamdue]

it feels like its missing an ending, like the forum crashing at he tried to post it

 

[The Nightmare Doctor]

There is a poster by the name of Davros...

 

[wamdue]

There is a poster by the name of Davros...

yes, dont recall seeing his review of the episode yet

 

[The Nightmare Doctor]

There is a poster by the name of Davros...

yes, dont recall seeing his review of the episode yet

You probably missed it because it was quick and straight to the point.

 

[Haggis and tatties]

^^^^Oops.....

I hope he takes it in good spirits...

it feels like its missing an ending, like the forum crashing at he tried to post it

Oh i never thought of that.....good idea.....