• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Did Bail Organa know that Vader was Anakin? Did Owen and Beru know?

Mage

Vice Admiral
Admiral
I can't remember if it was stated during Obi-Wan. But I assume not, right?
I know Obi-Wan was surprised to hear that Anakin was still alive, but does that mean Vader was not a know entity at that time?
Sidious calls Anakin Vader in the holo recording that Obi-Wan and Yoda are looking at, and I always assumed that they told Bail about this. But now I am unsure.
 
Nothing's ever been explicitly states, but it's generally accepted that Owen and Beru did not know. As for Bail, I'm pretty sure he did know in the EU, though I'm not sure if that's been carried over to the current canon.
 
"He has too much of his father in him."

"That's what I'm afraid of."

I know, I know... but it makes for some nice retroactive context. :D
 
As for Bail, I'm pretty sure he did know in the EU, though I'm not sure if that's been carried over to the current canon.
It was. The scandal in Bloodline that led to Leia losing her political position was the leaking of a recording Bail made for Leia telling her her biological father was Darth Vader in case he died before he could tell her.

It did confuse me about what everyone else knew, post-RotJ. It seems to be common knowledge that Luke and Leia are siblings, and anyone over the age of thirty when the Rebellion won with a pair of eyes would know Luke was the son of the Jedi general Anakin Skywalker, and it also seems to be known that Luke turned Vader against the Emperor on the Death Star. Since it was still a shock to the public (and even the family; one of the things that hurt Leia was that it meant Ben would find out about his grandfather on the news), I guess the public story maintained Obi-Wan's fiction that he had a second apprentice who turned out to be Darth Vader, and Anakin was killed by him with the rest of the Jedi. Or, at least, Luke and Leia never said, and allowed people to continue to believe whatever theories they already had for Darth Vader's origin.
 
Last edited:
My read on it is that Obi-Wan told Owen & Beru that Anakin died with the other Jedi, without really elaborating on the details, and details were not sought. After all, Owen's connection to Anakin was mostly though his loyalty to the memory of Shmi. He barely knew the man he became.

Insofar what the public knew post-RotJ; I don't think an elaborate cover story was necessary. While the connection between Luke and Anakin, and by extension Leia would be self-evident; there's no obvious connection between Anakin and Vader.
So far as any public record might be concerned, Anakin Skywalker died at the end of the Clone Wars. That would have been the Empire's official story (though even then only in sealed security files; the public records of all Jedi would likely have been erased entirely), and there'd be no reason to doubt that account later down the line.

Vader on the other had was always a mystery, even to the higher echelons of the Empire. Even the ISB likely had no clue who he was, and knew better than to poke too deep into the Emperor's own secrets. Those reckless or ambitious supervisors that might have, likely ended up never being heard from again.

Who knows what, if anything Luke said to the Rebellion about his confrontation with Palpatine. All anyone besides Leia (and probably Han) knew; he was captured before the assault on the bunker, taken up to the Death Star, and escaped in the chaos of the attack. I mean it's not like it'd be the first time he'd ever escaped from a Death Star, so why would anyone question it?
 
From the Obi-Wan show:

I know we said no communication, but your silence worries me. If he's found you, if he's learned of the children...

Yes, but at that point Obi-Wan didn't seem to know Vader was Anakin. He was shocked when Reva told him. And that is what I find odd, since both him and Yoda saw the recording at the temple where Sidious called Anakin Vader. So one would assume when Obi-Wan heard stories of Vader he knew that was Anakin, right?

Unless Bail ment the Emperor, not Vader.
 
Obi-wan assumed Anakin died on Mustifar. I am unsure if anyone had said the name Vader to him or around him in those ten years. He knew Anakin had turned into Darth Vader, but was he aware that Darth Vader was operating in the Empire?

Bail might have known and also known of Vader since he was still a Senator with a lot of connections. One wonders if Ahsoka hadn't heard of Vader before Rebels (roughly 4 BBY), or if she was aware of him, just obviously wasn't told he was Anakin Skywalker. Owen knew enough to roast Obi-wan about training him when Obi brought up training Luke.
 
Yes, but at that point Obi-Wan didn't seem to know Vader was Anakin.
He absolutely knew Vader was Anakin. He had been shocked to find out Vader was alive, but that was earlier ( at the end of the second episode ).
 
Last edited:
Who knows what, if anything Luke said to the Rebellion about his confrontation with Palpatine. All anyone besides Leia (and probably Han) knew; he was captured before the assault on the bunker, taken up to the Death Star, and escaped in the chaos of the attack. I mean it's not like it'd be the first time he'd ever escaped from a Death Star, so why would anyone question it?
Rey knew about Vader's redemption in TLJ, so unless Leia looped her in on the family lore before she left, it seems that that was part of the Legend of Luke Skywalker.

Owen knew enough to roast Obi-wan about training him when Obi brought up training Luke.
I think Owen just didn't care for Anakin. Looking back, I still think it would've made more sense based on how Beru and Owen talked about him (and their last names) for Beru to have been established as Anakin's sister, rather than Owen being Anakin's step-brother (or Obi-Wan's actual brother, which makes no sense at all; I wonder what they were thinking beyond "put this whole thing to bed" when they came up with that for RotJ).
 
Rey knew about Vader's redemption in TLJ, so unless Leia looped her in on the family lore before she left, it seems that that was part of the Legend of Luke Skywalker.
Who's to say she didn't? She was sending Rey off to get Luke back after all, so it's not beyond the realms of possibility they she made sure Rey had the full picture, knowing she'd probably have to talk Luke into it, and especially after what Rey witnessed between Han and Kylo Ren.
It wouldn't have done the cause any favors sending Rey in half-blind and ignorant.

Conversely; there are many "Legends of Luke Skywalker" that don't jibe with accepted facts. It's not impossible that by chance or unusual circumstance that one or two of them happen to actually be true, regardless of what the official story says.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top