• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

David Gerrold was not invited to the premiere. Seems unhappy about it.

Maybe they wanted relatively equal representation from each of the shows - which looks like what they achieved.

TOS - Nicholls, Shatner
TNG - McFadden, Frakes
DS9 - Visitor, Farrell, De Boer
VOY - Dawson
ENT - Billingsley, Montgomery
 
Maybe they wanted relatively equal representation from each of the shows - which looks like what they achieved.

TOS - Nicholls, Shatner
TNG - McFadden, Frakes
DS9 - Visitor, Farrell, De Boer
VOY - Dawson
ENT - Billingsley, Montgomery

I'm going to bet Shatner and Nichols were paid to attend. Frakes was there because he's directing one (or several?) Discovery episodes. The rest fit my theory that the A-listers declined.
 
I'd guess Stewart declined, Bakula is probably off filming NCIS New Orleans. There was a story about Michael Dorn refusing a cameo due to how much they were offering to pay him - if true, then they may not have invited him.

I still think there's a casting announcement for Michael Trucco or a cameo in an episode - he was a bit of a random choice, and seemed to be hanging around with Ted Sullivan (?) in the background of several interviews I've seen with the cast and crew. Yes - he did Galactica, but that's a very tenuous connection and I'd imagine if you were going to invite BSG alumni, you'd aim for Helfer, Bamber, Olmos or Sackhoff.
 
IDK - yes, TOS - "Journey To Babel" gave Spock's parents 'life' as more then just a passing mention (which happened in a few first season episodes); but Theodore Sturgeon did just as much and more with TOS - "Amok Time"
^^^

My point - yes, she wrote a pivotal Spock episode, but a number of others did so as well that also contributed a lot to the Vulcan mythos of Star Trek..
Not just "Journey to Babel", but also "Yesteryear", Sturgeon elaborated on Vulcan culture, but only indirectly on Spock's immediate family
 
Do we know for a fact that Wheaton didn't get an invitation? Or did he get one, and chose not to attend? The number of B-list celebs there not directly connected to Discovery suggests that it was an "I'll pass" decision for most.

Also there is the possibility of a scheduling conflict on Wheaton's part. Of course, this is all speculative and I'll take Gerrold at a grain of salt until Wheaton says something himself.

Oh, Gerrold was the source for Wheaton not being invited? Well, that immediately seems suspect then! I missed that detail upthread, insufficient fact-checking on my part, my bad...

Maybe they wanted relatively equal representation from each of the shows - which looks like what they achieved.

TOS - Nicholls, Shatner
TNG - McFadden, Frakes
DS9 - Visitor, Farrell, De Boer
VOY - Dawson
ENT - Billingsley, Montgomery

Linda Park and Connor Trineer were also there.
 
One notable episode is more than most people will ever achieve.
What do you call "achieve"? I've had an 18 year successful career as a professionally qualified person during which I have accomplished notable things in my field. In terms of sustained success I am more successful than Gerrold. The problem with your comment is it presupposes that I and anyone else aspire to fame or write for television (and/or Star Trek). For many of us we can be Star Trek fans and have no compulsion to want to work on the show or gain fame in fan circles. You obviously do, otherwise you would not consider people like Gerrold to be professionally superior and more accomplished than you, which is the inherent sentiment in your remark.
 
What do you call "achieve"? I've had an 18 year successful career as a professionally qualified person during which I have accomplished notable things in my field. In terms of sustained success I am more successful than Gerrold. The problem with your comment is it presupposes that I and anyone else aspire to fame or write for television (and/or Star Trek). For many of us we can be Star Trek fans and have no compulsion to want to work on the show or gain fame in fan circles. You obviously do, otherwise you would not consider people like Gerrold to be professionally superior and more accomplished than you, which is the inherent sentiment in your remark.
I don't write Star Trek. Don't care to.
 
Um.. why? My point was he has achieved something more than others may have. He has.
Again, that depends on what you consider to be an achievement. You are basically making the case that writing one television episode of a famous TV show is a major achievement and by implication you are telling critics of him, including me, whose post you quoted, that it is more than we have achieved. Why else make the comment?
 
Again, that depends on what you consider to be an achievement. You are basically making the case that writing one television episode of a famous TV show is a major achievement and by implication you are telling critics of him, including me, whose post you quoted, that it is more than we have achieved. Why else make the comment?
If I recall what was quoted from you was 'notable episode'. I see it as an achievement, still do.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top