• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Best Episode of Season 3, Part 1

Vote for the THREE best episodes!


  • Total voters
    37

Michael

A good bad influence
Moderator
Thanks for voting in the second season polls. This is the first part of the third season poll where you have to vote the three episodes you consider to be the best. The five episodes receiving the most votes will go on to the next round. Well, you know the routine. ;)

Winners to date:
Duet (Season 1)
The Wire (Season 2)

The poll is open for three days.
 
A couple of unusual choices, I'm sure, but I went with:

The House of Quark
Past Tense, I
Past Tense, II
 
Destiny, Improbable Cause, and The Die is Cast.

Honourable mentions to Equilibrium and Visionary. I still consider this DS9's weakest season, on the whole.
 
Now things are really gonna get very difficult. Very.

From now on, this show is full of excellent episodes. Thus, it'll be harder to choose.
 
OK, I'm sorry, I couldn't not vote the two parts of Past Tense apart, so I voted for four episodes.

Past Tense (best episode(s) of the season)
Improbable Cause
The Die Is Cast

I must stretch, but Past Tense is really the most effective social commentary this show has ever done, in my opinion.
 
I LOVE season 3, so this is tough. I'm voting from the heart here, not the head ;)

Civil Defense (first DS9 episode I ever saw, so it's special to me :))
The Die Is Cast (Kick. Ass.)
Explorers (The Visitor be damned, THIS is my favorite Ben/Jake episode)
 
I'm surprised Improbable Cause is losing to The Die is Cast. I always thought it was better. If you ask me, I think it had the very best dialog (as a whole) of any episode of Trek.
 
The Search pt1

House of Quark

Improbable Cause

Yes, the first part of the two parters is the best, the second half never lives up IMHO. Search pt 2 winds up being mostly fake-out and The Die Is Cast just a one sided Trek battle as the Dominion wipes out the Cardassian-Romulan fleet. Not bad episodes at all, but a little bit of a let down.
 
I disagree with previous posts. "The Die Is Cast" is just as strong if not better than "Improbabale Cause." "The Die Is Cast" gave us a payoff...finally! Not just talk of war but actual repercussions as well as plots put into motion. There is not a wasted scene and the direction is brilliant (the final scene stands for me as the most inspired bit filming in the history of Trek. The Dominion is shown to be a truly worthy Trek villain, one that got the best of the enemy in a way that no foe on Trek had ever done so before, making them officially the best bad guys to appear on the scene since the Borg. Its level of dialogue was not quite at the level of "Improbabale Cause" but it was still crackling with energy and purpose. Besides the legitamately thrilling action and justified fireworks made up for any drop on the dialogue front. Not to mention it expanded the boundaries of "Improbable Cuase" from the more intimate focus of two mysterious men talking about galactical conspiracies while in small rooms to the more grand approach of actual epic betrayals and defeat of major military powers of the galaxy. Instead of just talking about the blood that could be spilled (which Trek during the TNG era unfortunately did a bit too much), this episode showed you the blood being spilled. The results of this episode shifted much of the balance of power in the AQ and initiated storylines that would carry the show during its final seasons. As I wrote before in many ways it did for DS9 what "Coming of Shadows" did for B5.

"Improbabale Cuase" is marvellous, without question. But The Die Is Cause is just a bit better. Tain's words to Garak at the end seem sad and chilling (astonishing just to se the fall of this great military mind). The torture scenes between Odo and Garak provided more heartpounding moments than anything we got in "Improbable Cause." Odo's remarks about wanting to return home is an important revelation that you could not find in the previous ep. The decloacking of the Romulan and Cardassian ships around DS9 just before they entered the wormhole was one of the greatest opening teasers that the show ever had.Sisko's defiance of an order from Starfleet was much needed and overdue for the character IMO. The added bonus of the use of Michael Eddington wasn't bad either. The look of dread and horror on Tain and Garak's faces as they realized they had walked into a trap. The revelation of Luvok being a changeling was actually a legitimate surprise. The Definat being granted arguably its most kick-ass moment ever on screen. "You know what the sad part is? I'm actually a very good tailor." You folks are telling me that that's not a classic piece of work?

What is so amazing about "Improbabale Cause" is how it manages to be so great despite being a script written at the last minute to make the story a two-parter. Still that being said the main purpose of that episode was as filler and it at times show with its numerous running dialouge scenes between Odo and Garak. But The Die Is Cast is about consequences.

Anyway, I voted fo "The Die Is Cast", "Improbabale Cause" and "The Search Part One (part two was awful). I have a soft spot for "Explorers" and a strong liking for "Destiny" (which really got the Emissary story-line up and running again) "The Abandoned", "The Adversary", "Facets", "Through The Looking Glass", "Past Tense", "Defiant", "Second Skin", "Civil Defense".
 
Past Tense Part I
Past Tense Part II
Improbable Cause

Honorable mentions: The Die Is Cast, Explorers, The House of Quark, The Search Part I, Defiant, and Visionary. Many good episodes this season.
 
Past Tense, Part 1
Past Tense, Part 2
Visionary

I really, really enjoy that 2 parter. Trek has always been about the morality tales, and this one feels very real to me. It's also very well put together.

Visionary because it's a fun O'Brien episode.
 
Visionary
...which becomes more important in context: is this the episode where the Rommies decided that Plan A wasn't going to protect them from the Dominion, time to enact Plan B, which led to... Improbable Cause
The Die is Cast

Given the close proximity of these episodes, the Rommies had Plan B in the works while they were trying Plan A. But that's what you would only expect of them. ;)
 
Season 3 had a lot of great episodes (along with a few clunkers), so it was tough to narrow it down to three. My picks:

"The House of Quark"
"Improbable Cause"
"The Die is Cast"
 
'Improbable Cause', 'The Die Is Cast' and 'The Adversary' for being integral parts of the bigger picture.
 
Improbable Cause
Visionary
Civil Defense

But I could easily pick a lot more. :cool: I didn't vote for Past Tense because I didn't want to use up two options for that and also didn't want to cheat. :D
 
The Past Tense episodes were some of my favorites of the series. It was such a believable premise. They also upheld the tradition in Star Trek to focus on modern societal issues, and they did so without it feeling like it was being thrown in your face. In the DVD extras I recall the writers saying that while they were filming those episodes the mayor of LA or San Fran (I can't remember which!) announced a plan to set aside blocks of the city as "havens" for the homeless.

I also voted Civil Defense, because it was probably one of the most purely entertaining episodes of DS9 ever. Every time a new obstacle presented itself I just laughed hysterically, but was riveted at the same time. Also, Gul Dukat was fantastic in that episode.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top