Am I the only one that likes the nazi time travel episode

[Tuskin38]

but 'Trek' wouldn't be the same without Nazis making an appearance.

There were no Nazi episodes in TNG or DS9.

These 'Am I the only one' thread titles are kind of silly IMO. No you're not. I don't think any episode has a 100% hate rate from the fan base (even Threshold)

Better title would be more like 'Thoughts on *episode name*" or something.

 

[a thousand-yard stare]

'Trek' wouldn't be the same without Nazis making an appearance

There were no Nazi episodes in TNG or DS9.

and there you go...

 

[Green]

Yep, there you go.

 

[Nerys Myk]

There were no Nazi episodes in TNG or DS9.

These 'Am I the only one' thread titles are kind of silly IMO. No you're not. I don't think any episode has a 100% hate rate from the fan base (even Threshold)

Better title would be more like 'Thoughts on *episode name*" or something.

Cardassians are the ultimate Space Nazis.

 

[Hopeful Romantic]

I don't think any episode has a 100% hate rate from the fan base (even Threshold)

Wait, what? Someone liked "Threshold"?

But seriously, I have found something to like in every episode of ENT. Even when the plot stinks, there are wonderful little character moments or directing touches or something.

I liked that John Fleck as Silik got a lot of facetime in his last episode - with his real face, no Suliban makeup. And there was the moment when Trip discovered Archer wasn't dead. And the spaceship dogfight was cool.

 

[Gaith]

These 'Am I the only one' thread titles are kind of silly IMO. No you're not. I don't think any episode has a 100% hate rate from the fan base (even Threshold)

You sayyyyyy I'm crazy
'Cause I think "A Night in Sickbay" is fun
But I started this thread to establish -
And to know, I'm not the only one

 

[Prax]

Did anyone know that "A Night in Sickbay" was nominated for a Hugo Award?

 

[Tenacity]

There were no Nazi episodes in TNG or DS9.

Cardassians (to reiterate).

 

[Tuskin38]

I thought you people meant literal swastika toting goosestepping Nazis.

 

[Hopeful Romantic]

Did anyone know that "A Night in Sickbay" was nominated for a Hugo Award?

Another example that one fan's dreck is another fan's treasure. I'm one of the happy few who enjoyed it, perhaps because I have also been strung out and exhausted worrying over a sick pet, so I totally understood Archer. Plus the goofy comic relief stuff worked for me.

Maybe if ENT had gotten to Season 5 or 6 of a guaranteed 7-year run, when shows can comfortably experiment, ANiS might have fit better there. Right before the "Archer Sings!" episode, or the one that takes place entirely during Movie Night.

 

[Gingerbread Demon]

So the beginning of season 4-the whole Nazi time travel two parter received criticism.

I actually enjoyed it? Did anyone else?

+1 here I liked it for what it was worth.

Seeing the Enterprise flying over the city in the 40s was cool. I loved that bit and them dogfighting with WW II planes I mean it was no contest.

 

[Reanok]

I liked Stormfront I re-watched it again recently. It's been along time since I watched it I liked Archer and the gangsters fighting against the Space Nazis .Silik actually helped the Enterprise crew.

 

[Mr. Laser Beam]

I like the fact that even as Silik died, he acknowledged Archer as a worthy opponent.

 

[{ Emilia }]

I hate every Nazis in Space episode tbh. It's so annoying that they keep doing this.

The only time Nazis in Space were hilarious was Iron Sky.

 

[Gingerbread Demon]

I hate every Nazis in Space episode tbh. It's so annoying that they keep doing this.

The only time Nazis in Space were hilarious was Iron Sky.

I LOVE that movie.

Have you seen the trailers for the sequel. Hitler riding a dinosaur..... I mean what more could you want?

 

[Prax]

I like the fact that even as Silik died, he acknowledged Archer as a worthy opponent.

It's funny how many of Archer's enemies develop bromantic feelings for him. There's of course Shran, then Degra, Silik, you might say Soong. I shouldn't be surprised, though. The Scatula is a stud.

 

[Shaka Zulu]

Did anyone know that "A Night in Sickbay" was nominated for a Hugo Award?

Big deal, so was The Omega Glory. And at least it wasn't a stupid episode that strained credulity like The Omega Glory, but a nice little episode about cultural misunderstanding and the love of the main character for his pet dog. Unfortunately, people hate that but are willing to tolerate shit like The Omega Glory and the even shittier The Way To Eden.

 

[Nerys Myk]

Big deal, so was The Omega Glory. And at least it wasn't a stupid episode that strained credulity like The Omega Glory, but a nice little episode about cultural misunderstanding and the love of the main character for his pet dog. Unfortunately, people hate that but are willing to tolerate shit like The Omega Glory and the even shittier The Way To Eden.

The following TOS episodes have bee nominated for Hugos

Best Dramatic Presentation ""The Menagerie" Won
Best Dramatic Presentation "The Corbomite Maneuver" Nominated
Best Dramatic Presentation "The Naked Time" Nominated
1968 Best Dramatic Presentation "The City on the Edge of Forever" Won
Best Dramatic Presentation "Amok Time" Nominated
Best Dramatic Presentation "The Doomsday Machine" Nominated
Best Dramatic Presentation "Mirror, Mirror" Nominated
Best Dramatic Presentation "The Trouble With Tribbles" Nominated
MA says Omega Glory was submitted by Roddenberry for an Emmy nomination. Though it didn't get one. (Surprise!)

 

[Prax]

For anyone unfamiliar, the Hugo (science fiction) awards only have one category(Best Dramatic Presentation) That Star Trek can win in. The other categories are:

Best-
-Novel
-Novella
-Novelette
-Short Story
-Professional Magazine
-Professional Editor(like a magazine editor)
-Professional Artist
-Fanzine
-Fan Writer
-Fan Artist
(There are sometimes others)

They've added more categories since the 60's. For instance, Best Dramatic Presentation used to include any TV episode, motion picture, or short film. They're now divided as "short form" and "long form." They've also added podcasts, graphic novels, et al.

In 1966, there was no winner of Best Dramatic Presentation due to insufficient nominations.

In 1967, 3 of the 5 nominations were Star Trek. One of the others was Fahrenheit 451, and I don't remember the last. The Menagerie won. (As mentioned Above)

In 1968, ALL FIVE nominations were Star Trek. and 2 were awarded. Trouble with Tribbles, and City on the Edge of Forever(As Above). A third Hugo Award went to Gene Roddenberry!

In 1969, there were no Trek contenders, but Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldrin, and Michael Collins won a Hugo Award for "Best Moon Landing Ever"


Other Hugo noms/wins from Trek are:

-In 1980, Star Trek: The Motion Picture was nominated for BDP.(Lost to Alien)
-In 1983, The Wrath of Khan was nominated.(Lost toBlade Runner)
-1984, Search for Spock. Nom(lost to 2010: Odyssey Two)
-1987, The Voyage Home. Nom(lost to Aliens)
-1992, The Undiscovered Country. Nom(lost to Terminator 2: Judgement Day)

TNG
-1988, Encounter at Farpoint. Nom(lost to The Princess Pride)
-1993, The Inner Light. Won
-1995, All Good Things. Won
-1995, Star Trek: Generations. Nom(lost to TNG-All Good Things, lol)
-1996, Star Trek: First Contact. Nom(lost to Babylon Five-Severed Dreams)
-1998, Star Trek: Insurrection. Nom(lost to The Truman Show)

DS9
-1996, The Inner Light. Nom(lost to Babylon Five-The Coming of Shadows)
-Trials & Tribble-ations. Nom(lost to Babylon Five-Severed Dreams)

ENT
2003-Carbon Creek. Nom
2003-A Night in Sickbay. Nom(both lost to Buffy-Conversations with Dead People. 2003 was also the first year that film and tv were divided into separate categories)

I believe the first Kelvin film was nominated also. I'm not sure why I wrote all this. Enjoy, I guess.

 

[a thousand-yard stare]

I'm not sure why I wrote all this. Enjoy, I guess.

Really informative...

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

(with apologies to mods)