Does anyone else think that Agent 33/Kara Palamas's name is very similar to that of Carolyn Palamas from TOS - "Who Mourns for Adonais?"?
Does anyone else think that Agent 33/Kara Palamas's name is very similar to that of Carolyn Palamas from TOS - "Who Mourns for Adonais?"?
She's in the middle of a peaceful negotiation. The proper response to that is to say "no" and/or kick Gonzales out. It's not to kill Gonzales, and then tamper with the crime scene to make it look like justifiable homicide.And, yeah, I think it's safe to say that Jiaying planned this in advance -- but she did so because she probably saw SHIELD's intention to put the Inhumans on the Index coming. It is notable that she waited for Gonzalez to say so, however; maybe she would have been willing to halt the plan and work in good faith if SHIELD had not make the demand to Index her people?
A better comparison might be Doctor Who's novel line. They're equally beholden to what the parent show does, but there's actually been some pollination from the novels back into the show. (Ignoring the obvious straight-forward adaptations, my favorite example is Rose's first visit to an alien planet; the original script for "Boom Town" had a different name, Grajick Major, but RTD changed it to Justicia to reference the novel.)In a lot of ways, the mandate for Agents of SHIELD resembles the mandate for media tie-in novels such as the Star Trek novel line. Though Agents of SHIELD is considered equally canonical with the films, the simple fact is that the films have the "right of way" in setting the story agenda: They're going to do what they're going to do, and the producers of Agents of SHIELD have to write around them and stay consistent with them, while the filmmakers don't really have to keep themselves consistent with Agents. And if the films are going to do something that affects Agents of SHIELD's storyline, they get to do it first and Agents must follow up on it.
She's in the middle of a peaceful negotiation. The proper response to that is to say "no" and/or kick Gonzales out. It's not to kill Gonzales, and then tamper with the crime scene to make it look like justifiable homicide.And, yeah, I think it's safe to say that Jiaying planned this in advance -- but she did so because she probably saw SHIELD's intention to put the Inhumans on the Index coming. It is notable that she waited for Gonzalez to say so, however; maybe she would have been willing to halt the plan and work in good faith if SHIELD had not make the demand to Index her people?
Okay, it's weird for the "cover" posters of AoS episodes to be used as variant covers on books that have nothing to do with AoS. I guess the idea is to make them available for people to own, but you have to put up with having an unrelated title printed across the top.
And, yeah, I think it's safe to say that Jiaying planned this in advance -- but she did so because she probably saw SHIELD's intention to put the Inhumans on the Index coming. It is notable that she waited for Gonzalez to say so, however; maybe she would have been willing to halt the plan and work in good faith if SHIELD had not make the demand to Index her people?
She's in the middle of a peaceful negotiation. The proper response to that is to say "no" and/or kick Gonzales out. It's not to kill Gonzales, and then tamper with the crime scene to make it look like justifiable homicide.
In a lot of ways, the mandate for Agents of SHIELD resembles the mandate for media tie-in novels such as the Star Trek novel line. Though Agents of SHIELD is considered equally canonical with the films, the simple fact is that the films have the "right of way" in setting the story agenda: They're going to do what they're going to do, and the producers of Agents of SHIELD have to write around them and stay consistent with them, while the filmmakers don't really have to keep themselves consistent with Agents. And if the films are going to do something that affects Agents of SHIELD's storyline, they get to do it first and Agents must follow up on it.
A better comparison might be Doctor Who's novel line. They're equally beholden to what the parent show does, but there's actually been some pollination from the novels back into the show. (Ignoring the obvious straight-forward adaptations, my favorite example is Rose's first visit to an alien planet; the original script for "Boom Town" had a different name, Grajick Major, but RTD changed it to Justicia to reference the novel.)
I don't think that's a good comparison, though; the influence has, so far as we know, pretty much always been one-way: the films influence (or, in Captain America: The Winter Soldier's case, dictate) the direction of the show, but the show does not influence or dictate the content of the films.A better comparison might be Doctor Who's novel line. They're equally beholden to what the parent show does, but there's actually been some pollination from the novels back into the show. (Ignoring the obvious straight-forward adaptations, my favorite example is Rose's first visit to an alien planet; the original script for "Boom Town" had a different name, Grajick Major, but RTD changed it to Justicia to reference the novel.)
All this is a separate question from whether Jiaying de-values the lives of normal Humans or otherwise thinks of Inhumans as superior to Humans a la Magneto. I am not yet willing to conclude that she necessarily de-values the lives of non-Inhumans or views Humans as inferior to Inhumans. A person may be acting in what they believe to be self-defense--even if that belief is not objectively accurate--without necessarily being bigoted.
All this is a separate question from whether Jiaying de-values the lives of normal Humans or otherwise thinks of Inhumans as superior to Humans a la Magneto. I am not yet willing to conclude that she necessarily de-values the lives of non-Inhumans or views Humans as inferior to Inhumans. A person may be acting in what they believe to be self-defense--even if that belief is not objectively accurate--without necessarily being bigoted.
They said that her parents were monsters and slaughtered a whole village and a bunch of SHIELD agents to get baby Daisy or Mary Sue or Skye. That sounds a bit like a disregard for human life.
But you're right, it's not conclusive.
All this is a separate question from whether Jiaying de-values the lives of normal Humans or otherwise thinks of Inhumans as superior to Humans a la Magneto. I am not yet willing to conclude that she necessarily de-values the lives of non-Inhumans or views Humans as inferior to Inhumans. A person may be acting in what they believe to be self-defense--even if that belief is not objectively accurate--without necessarily being bigoted.
They said that her parents were monsters and slaughtered a whole village and a bunch of SHIELD agents to get baby Daisy or Mary Sue or Skye. That sounds a bit like a disregard for human life.
But you're right, it's not conclusive.
Though not having a problem with dumping Cal near non-Inhumans and pretty much not being to concerned with what he might do and who might get hurt when he figures out he's been ditched does make you wonder.
And while Jiaying might not de-value the lives of normal humans, she's still using the Magneto playbook of assume war is the only option, provoke people to make war happen, believe self to be totally right and as such make sure there is nobody who disagrees with war plans.
Hopefully for this Inhuman group it doesn't go to the usually inevitable conclusion of the Magneto playbook as pointed out by Days of Future Past which is severely underestimate humans, force they to do something stupid in desperation or anger, and get nearly exterminated.
Excellent, totally non-spoilery review of the season finale. No spoilers.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/merrillbarr/2015/05/11/agents-of-shield-season-finale/
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.